In this impressive volume, the first major reconsideration of Phillips's life and work since James Brewer Stewart's Wendell Phillips: Liberty's Hero, a host of established and emerging scholars evaluate the abolitionist's legacy through a variety of scholarly lenses.Footnote 1 The famous “golden trumpet of abolition,” we are reminded, was not only a champion of the rights of the enslaved and a steadfast racial egalitarian, but a determined advocate of the rights of women, Native Americans, and the labor movement. The scion of an elite Boston family who never wavered in his conviction that “the people never err,” Phillips was a staunch Calvinist who became a leading spokesperson for a movement widely identified with religious heterodoxy; a faithful upholder of the rule of law who advocated Northern disunion; a committed socialist who turned his back on his own class prerogatives and advocated the redistribution of wealth; and an instinctive radical who at various times defended the Haitian Revolution, the Paris Commune, and even the Russian Nihilists. In the twelve essays collected here, leading scholars skillfully weave from these seeming paradoxes a fuller picture of both the man and the movement he represented. The portrait of Phillips they collectively draw largely continues a trend in recent scholarship on the abolition movement that aims to up-end the still all-too-prevalent depiction of abolitionists as narrow-minded and dogmatic zealots who did little to address societal ills outside of the question of slavery.Footnote 2
The contradictions that Phillips embodied are confronted with scholarly precision and care throughout the volume. As essays by James Brewer Stewart and Michael Les Benedict make clear, Phillips's abolitionism was “fully grounded in the political culture” and constitutional understandings of his time, and he allowed his patriotism to take a back seat to no one's, even as he damned the Constitution as an instrument of slaveholders and embraced disunion (40). In similar fashion, Dean Grodzin shows that, while Phillips simultaneously supported armed resistance by enslaved people and aligned himself with non-resistants, his understanding of the rule of law prevented him from fully endorsing either violent revolution or pacifism. Dan McKanan's chapter on Phillips's brand of “New England religion,” meanwhile, suggests that Phillips trod a fine line between the Orthodoxy of his Puritan forefathers and the liberal Unitarianism of many of his abolitionist colleagues. Essays by Hélène Quanquin and Angela Murphy argue that, while Phillips was far ahead of most of his contemporaries in his consistent embrace of women's rights and the plight of Native Americans, his failure to understand or take seriously the unique circumstances of either meant that his advocacy of these causes was ultimately circumscribed.
Far more consistent, according to James Brewer Stewart, was Phillips's embrace of civil, social, and political equality for African Americans. An unlikely egalitarian given his undeniably Brahmin background, Phillips nonetheless far surpassed most of his fellow abolitionists in his embrace of black equality and color-blind politics, even if his occasional denunciations of individual black colleagues were sometimes tinged with condescension.
Such conclusions seem authoritative coming from Stewart, Phillips's most recent biographer and perhaps the nation's leading authority on the abolition movement. Yet several of the standout contributions here are from less well-established scholars. W. Caleb McDaniel expands on the thesis he eloquently articulated in his pathbreaking The Problem of Democracy in the Age of Slavery, extending the analysis of Phillips he began in that work and further situating him in the context of radical transatlantic thought. The learned Phillips's commitment to democracy and equality, we are told, was in large part the product of his intellectual engagement with liberal thinkers like Tocqueville and John Stuart Mill and of his study of ancient Athenian democracy. Peter Wirzbicki also places Phillips in the context of transatlantic radicalism, but focuses on the abolitionist's engagement with labor reform as a turning point in his “evolution” toward a greater appreciation for issues of labor and class. In Wirzbicki's telling, Phillips's postwar emergence as an advocate for labor can be traced back to his encounter with the British Chartist movement and 1848 revolutions that transformed his thinking at a pivotal moment for both abolitionism and labor movement internationalism. Historians who have cited Phillips's widely-publicized disputes with labor leaders like George Henry Evans as evidence of abolitionism's hostility to working-class reform have missed the point, Wirzbicki suggests, for the sometimes-heated tone of these debates obscures broader agreement between the two movements on issues like land reform, hours of labor laws, and other “socialistic” measures.
Millington Bergeson-Lockwood picks up on this theme by examining Phillips's postwar emergence as a “champion of labor” and stump speaker for former Union general turned Labor Reform and Greenback Party candidate Benjamin F. Butler. If Phillips's embrace of electoral politics implied a departure from his abolitionist rejection of voting and political parties, Bergeson-Lockwood suggests that his support for labor not only represented the logical continuation of his postwar efforts on behalf the enslaved, but remained central to Phillips's activist agenda to the end of his life.
Coeditor Donald Yacovone contributes a powerful and strikingly original rumination on Phillips's posthumous role in the collective memory of postwar Boston and the nation, tracing his curious trajectory from abolitionist pariah to widely-lionized local hero in the years after his death. And yet, despite being the subject of memorials and memorializations in Boston and elsewhere in the late-nineteenth and early-twentieth centuries, Phillips's unrepentant radicalism ultimately meant that his status as national hero proved ephemeral, eventually succumbing to the pressures of “Lost Cause” mythology, before being resurrected by historians and civil rights activists in the 1960s. A short coda on the contemporary Phillips Community of Minneapolis, Minnesota, extends the implications of Phillips's activist legacy into the twenty-first century.
Perhaps inevitably when writing about a figure whose beliefs and convictions overlap so closely with those of many modern-day academics, the overall tone here at times veers close to hagiography, even within those essays that attempt to offer a more critical perspective. As Yacovone points out in his introduction to the volume, recent scholarship on antislavery has begun to shift away from the focus on Garrisonian abolitionists like Phillips, in some cases in favor of an emphasis on formal politics and on more traditional figures like Abraham Lincoln.Footnote 3 One is tempted to reply, in response to Yacovone's invocation of Phillips's claim that “Garrison made Lincoln possible,” that it was a mass politics of the kind Phillips came to champion later in life, and not the non-voting abstention and agitation represented by the Garrisonians, that paved the way for Lincoln's election and, ultimately, the destruction of slavery (5). Given the way that the book's subtitle and much of what follows suggests that its editors are deeply invested in the notion of a usable past, surely an appreciation of the limitations as well as the possibilities of Phillips's approach to antislavery is in order. In all, however, the essays collected in this volume succeed in providing fresh insights into the period as a whole as well as in shedding new light on a figure who embodied many of its most noble and high-minded attributes.
