No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 February 2005
A. G. Noorani is a lawyer, and this book is a piercing prosecution of a narrow interpretation of jihad, of attitudes he calls “Muslim bigotry,” and of U.S. and Western policies vis-à-vis the Middle East and the world. In this short yet thorough book, Noorani offers a valuable contribution to the “clashist” debate and makes strong argument advancing the rationalist position. With his extensive reference to sources and issues of South Asia, this volume will help to broaden the perspective of those who may be focused exclusively on the Arab world.
This book is an assertion that bāb al-ijtihād should remain open. Through a well-organized progression of logic, the reader is led through an argument that starts with an overview of the representation of Islam in Western media and culture, offering the intellectual roots of this “specter” that “haunts” the West and that recalls Samuel Huntington's “clash of civilizations” thesis. The haunt of the Islamic specter can be found “in the media, in academia, in the arts and in scholarship. Few care to free themselves from its thrall” (p. 23). Noorani singles out Bernard Lewis, who has perpetuated the association of Muslims and militant fundamentalists. Noorani's approach is reminiscent of the breadth and conviction of Edward Said's Orientalism. Noorani appreciates those—such as Said and John Esposito—who have cared, and attempts to continue in that vein. Referring to 11 September 2001, Noorani writes, “Who was it, then, militant Arab nationalists, or militant Islamists? The former wreak vengeance for wrongs done by Western colonialism and the corrupt rulers it props up. The latter strive to establish an Islamic state. Only a political illiterate would confuse the two” (pp. 12–13).
After exposing the intellectual framework behind the “clash,” Noorani begins to chip away at its foundations. He starts by defining “jihad”—correctly—as “struggle,” but without any hesitation links it in the next sentence to ijtihād, the “exertion of the intellect” (p. 45). Recognizing that the term “jihad” can be misinterpreted by Muslims as well as by non-Muslims, Noorani compares its use to “crusade,” which has neutral as well as historically loaded meanings. He cites commentators such as Chiragh Ali and Sayyid Ahmad Khan who have refuted such narrow interpretations and who have developed the positive interpretations of jihad as found in the Qur

an and in the Prophet's sunna. Similarly deconstructing the idea of a fatwa as an “edict,” Noorani cites both South Asian and North American scholars to conclude that popular usage of both terms is inspired by “politics, not religion … exposing both to ridicule and Islam to misunderstanding and misrepresentation” (p. 62).
In Chapter 4, Noorani addresses the 20th-century “malaise” called fundamentalism, which is found in all of the major religions and characterized by “revivalism, hostility toward minorities, anti-intellectualism, intolerance, arrogant insularity, intellectual bankruptcy, and moral blindness” (p. 65). He is especially critical of the (recently defeated) Bharatiya Janata Party of India and its nationalistic Hindu outlook. Tracing the intellectual roots of fundamentalism to Hasan al-Banna, Sayyid Qutb, and Abul A

la Mawdudi, he differentiates between Arabic speakers and non-Arabic speakers, the former who interpret the language of the Qur

anic texts and the latter who are only able to read the texts literally and therefore less able to access historical contexts (p. 81). Asserting the need to engage in rational thought, Noorani condemns fundamentalism of all sorts. Nevertheless, he attributes its rise to all that the West, especially the United States, is responsible for, as well as the failure of the Muslim political class and intelligentsia to contain it (p. 90).
In the last two substantive chapters of the book, Noorani proposes for Islam an argument for respecting human rights and facing modernity. Regarding human rights, Noorani treats the matter historically, highlighting the concern among the first Muslim community, and thematically, with a focus on the place of non-Muslims. Recognizing the reality of history, he admits that the “record of actual practice [of Muslims] reveals both tolerance and intolerance towards the non-Muslims, dhimmis as they were called” (p. 96). Noting that the Universal Islamic Declaration of Human Rights (included in Appendix 1) “does not list among the rights of minorities (article X) the right to share in the governance of the State,” Noorani concludes, “[t]his is utterly unacceptable in modern times” (p. 97; emphasis in the original). He then makes a historical and textual case for non-Muslims to enjoy that very right.
Noorani's prescription for Islam as it faces modernity is to ensure that bāb al-ijtihād remain open. Again, he skillfully builds a case for the use of reason, appealing to the modern Islamic discourse of many scholars, including Jamal al-Din al-Afghani, Sayyid Ahmad Khan, Muhammad Iqbal, and Fazlur Rahman, but he reserves the “last word” for Abul Kalam Asad, who espoused the place of human freedom to develop an “Islamic theology of liberation” in the context of British rule in India. Noorani concludes by demonstrating that the nonviolent jihad of liberation from alien rule was superlative, but that a “jihad is yet to be fought out against ignorance, economic deprivation, social injustice, constitutional abuse and political wrongs” by first waging the greater jihad to change the self (p. 118). In this greater jihad, Noorani makes an example of Iranian President Muhammad Khatami, who has called for the “dialogue of civilizations,” despite the temptation to resort to extremism in response to Israeli suppression of Palestinians. He writes, “No other wrong stirs the Arab and Muslim world as much as the brutal repression by Israel … and the support it draws from the United States” (p. 126). Nevertheless, Noorani concludes by calling for dialogue based on rational self-examination in which the “West reflect[s] on the iniquities it … continues still to impose on the world” and Muslims avoid the temptation to “wallow in memories of grave wrongs, seek comfort in apologia, turn a blind eye to the injustices of Muslim society and, worse of all, refuse to discard their monstrously wrong notions of their own majestic faith, Islam” (p. 128).
In his reliance on Western, Middle Eastern, and South Asian sources, A. G. Noorani has demonstrated that there is much fodder in the sources to advance such an argument. His select bibliography reflects the breadth of the literature. Noorani's approach is scholarly, even as he advances a clear position and prosecutes another. This book is very accessible to the specialist, offering in one place the ideas of many rationalist, reforming scholars. The emphasis on South Asian thinkers is especially helpful. In addition, the two appendixes—containing the Universal Islamic Declaration of Human Rights and a resolution from the First Islamic Conference on “The Protection of Human Rights in Islamic Criminal Justice”—are also useful primary documents. The book offers a clear alternative to the prevalent media and therefore can also be recommended enthusiastically to the nonspecialist and for libraries.
Islam and Jihad is a book that ought to be read as an example of current intellectual trends among Muslims struggling with globalization; economic, political, and social suppression; and the stereotypes advanced by other, less discerning outlets.