Technological progress is an important facet of differential development paths between Europe and other economies. This volume, comprising nine chapters, constitutes an important contribution in understanding innovation and skill diffusion across space and generations in Eurasian pre-modern economies.
In general, each chapter builds on Joel Mokyr's distinction between propositional and prescriptive knowledge. Propositional knowledge answers “what”-questions while prescriptive knowledge addresses “how”-questions (Joel Mokyr, The Lever of Riches: Technological Creativity and Economic Progress, Oxford: OUP: 1990). Much of the pre-modern technological progress relied on incremental advances in prescriptive knowledge through a collective process. Due to the experiential and embodied nature of this knowledge, new techniques best disseminated through migration. Various chapters then examine the craft guilds’ role in innovation and diffusion in pre-modern economies within the framework that Stephan (Larry) Epstein had provided until his sudden, tragic death.
The first three chapters focus on particular regions in Eurasia. Epstein's chapter, published posthumously, demonstrates that craft guilds facilitated innovation and diffusion of technical knowledge in pre-modern Europe by sustaining skilled workers’ mobility and experimentation. Tirthankar Roy shows that apprenticeship in India was mostly based on family (and later caste) until the early nineteenth century, later being replaced by an indirect-control model, which compromised on-the-job learning. Kenneth Pomeranz shows that Chinese “guilds’’ were based on regional affiliation and lacked the regulatory power European guilds enjoyed in training, which might have contributed to a lower incidence of skill diffusion. Pomeranz also points out that one must pay particular attention to specific high-end industries and their spillovers. The latter six chapters follow this theme and focus on specific industries across Eurasia. Maarten Prak examines the building industry and finds support for Epstein's hypothesis by showing how craft guilds induced experimentation and skill diffusion through migration and collective effort. Richard W. Unger gives a comprehensive account of shipbuilding in Europe and Asia, showing craft guilds had a positive effect on innovation without discarding the non-guild sector in this industry. Karel Davids finds that Europe had a more consistent rate of circulation of knowledge in machine building since Europe developed formal structures to organize labor mobility. Christine Moll-Murata provides a balanced view of guilds’ role in her comparison of the porcelain industry in Europe and China, showing that at least Chinese guilds were less successful in training but had important civic roles. Gijs Kessler and Jan Lucassen show that brickmaking production was organized similarly in collective groups (not necessarily guilds), which were also responsible for teaching technical skills and cooperation in production. Finally, Jan Luiten van Zanden explains the differential diffusion and adoption of book production technology in Europe, China, and the Middle East, through the demand for printed books and the relative prices of capital and labor.
The volume provides an impressive examination of innovation and skill diffusion across pre-modern Eurasia. A consistent theme in all chapters is the embodied nature of tacit knowledge that characterized pre-modern economies and how this knowledge was best circulated through the mobility of skilled labor. The collective and experimental nature of pre-modern technological progress is another common factor that emerges in these different economies. Furthermore, several chapters successfully dispel the myth that Western Europe was technologically more advanced across the modern than others (notably India and China) in all industries.
The evidence mainly relies on the secondary literature and several chapters analyze various regions and industries within Epstein's framework on craft guilds. The geographical scope of the analysis is monumental and conclusions on regions that are not Europe are often speculative or provisional due to lack of evidence. By the same token, the Middle East does not receive too much attention, either (except in Prak's and van Zanden's chapters).
The fact that much of the pre-modern technological progress was based on improving the tacit knowledge (and thus moving the economy closer to its production possibility frontier instead of pushing the frontier outwards) is not controversial. However, with the exception of Pomeranz and Moll-Murata, the volume does not give a detailed discussion of the contrasting views on craft guilds’ role in skills diffusion and technical progress. (See, for example, Shelaigh Ogilvie, “ ‘Whatever is, is Right’? Economic Institutions in Pre-Industrial Europe,” Economic History Review 60 (2007), 649–84; S.R. Epstein, “Craft Guilds in the Pre-Modern Economy: A Discussion,” Economic History Review 61 (2008), 155–74; Sheilagh Ogilvie, “Rehabilitating the Guilds: A Reply,” Economic History Review 61 (2008), 175–82.) This book shows that despite variations in “guild” organization between Europe and Asia, the latter did well in several important industries such as shipbuilding in the eighteenth century. Indeed, the salient distinction between Europe and other economies seems to be jurisdictional fragmentation. As Jean-Laurent Rosenthal and Roy Bin Wong explain in Before and Beyond Divergence: The Politics of Economic Change in China and Europe, Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 2011, constant warfare in Europe allowed advances in fine metal crafts that had strong spill overs into technologies necessary for industrial revolution. As Epstein points out in his chapter, the same ceaseless feuding and state competition facilitated migration and displacement of skilled technicians (p. 66). Regardless, he emphasizes the role of pull factors and formal structures like guilds in facilitating migration. In addressing the question of technical innovation in the pre-modern world, future research now faces the challenge of systematically disentangling these two effects.
