No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 November 2004
“To learn about learning in a context in which formal technical training, engineers, and drawn plans are non-existent” (pp. ix, 73): this is the main quest that lies behind the work of architectural anthropology authored by the architect turned anthropologist Trevor Marchand, currently a lecturer in the Department of Anthropology and Sociology, School of Oriental and African Studies, University of London. His efforts focus on the builders of the minarets that grace the famously spectacular skyline of the highland Yemeni capital Sanaa. As the title suggests, the professional practice of building, and the system of transferring the knowledge necessary in that practice, occupy the center of this study. Marchand spent a year working as an unpaid laborer in the projects of Bayt al-Maswari, the leading “house” of minaret builders in Yemen. Thanks to his participant-observation method and his practical understanding of architecture, his narrative is appealingly vivid and provides unique insights into the themes of craftsman hierarchy, non-propositional communication, and the learning process within the “hierarchized space of the building site” (p. 46).
Prolific and resilient, traditional Yemeni architecture has been the subject of numerous studies and films. Minarets have also been extensively studied, although they are central to only three other monographs in English: Doris Behrens-Abouseif's work on Cairo minarets, A. B. M. Husain's publication on Indo-Muslim structures, and Jonathan Bloom's authoritative Minaret: Symbol of Islam. To the study of both Yemeni architecture and minarets Marchand contributes the analysis of minaret building as a teaching and learning process and the explication of the role of builders as self-conscious agents. Focusing on the role and agency of expert craftsmen and of their patrons, Marchand reads into the symbolism of the soaring structures not only the status of the patron but also “the skill and dedication of the master craftsmen who built them.” (p. 41).
To his field observations Marchand applies theories of practice and cognition. By relating his findings to the notion of embodied knowledge advanced by Pierre Bourdieu and others, as well as to explanatory models of spatial cognition, he contributes a clear picture of the different stages through which “structured knowledge becomes gradually inculcated” (p. 75). The layout of the book's core reflects the order of these stages: after an introductory overview of the traditional building trade in Yemen and a first chapter on the history of Yemeni minarets, the next three chapters are devoted to laborers, apprentices, and master builders, respectively. In an effective metaphorical scheme, the author relates the three successive levels of expertise to the building of the three successive parts of the minaret structure. Chapter 2 describes the building of a minaret's foundations and focuses on the training of laborers, who acquire discipline and a position on the site through performance of simple mechanical tasks. Chapter 3 details the building of the minaret's shaft and the learning process for apprentices who acquire expert knowledge by making. Chapter 4 juxtaposes the construction of the minaret's dome with the attainment of master-builder status.
For Marchand, the defining characteristic of traditional apprenticeship is the inculcation of both discipline and expertise through the process of making; understanding of spatial and structural relationships but also internalizing of roles at the building site through action is what the Yemeni system of apprenticeship imparts to the aspiring builders. The physical, non-verbal nature of this type of learning is both inherent in the learning method and instrumental in the expert craftsmen's firm grip on production of expertise. Scholars working on non-formal learning will find in Marchand's case study and theoretical analysis a highly illuminating comparandum. One possible application of the apprenticeship model is in the study of traditional and historical boatbuilding and navigation: in both areas practitioners appear to have worked largely without blueprints or models, charts or portolans; to have learned through apprenticeship; and to have observed a strict hierarchy of masters and apprentices.
While it is unfair to criticize the author for something he did not set out to do, the brief mention in his concluding chapter of Sylvaine Camelin's work on the transmission of knowledge among fishermen at the Hadrami port of al-Shihr is tantalizing, and systematic reference to her findings would have been instructive. When he does pursue a comparative approach, the comparison is with Canadian craft training, which exemplifies the formal Western transfer of craft knowledge, and which the author interprets as diametrically opposed to traditional apprenticeship. Here I agree with one previous reviewer of Marchand's work (Cynthia Myntti, Yemen Update 44 [2002]: 37) who notes that the difference between the two systems is overstated. I would argue that the perceived gap is possibly mitigated on the one hand by the use of some drawings by Yemeni master builders (pp. 212–16) and on the other by the practical, hands-on component of modern, Western training.
A more serious problem is the sustained emphasis on Islam as an explanatory backdrop to the formation of the builders' consciousness, intentions, and action, a trope that leads Marchand to the vague correlation of the three apprenticeship stages described earlier to the three stages of Islamic spirituality, islām (surrender and ritual practice), imān (conscious piety), and iḥsān (perfection of coordinated piety and intentionality). The danger here is of viewing the Muslim experience as essential and pervasive. Is it really necessary, for example, to attribute the use of deteriorating building tools to what Titus Burckhardt calls “the very acute awareness that a Muslim has of the ephemerality of things” (pp. 233–34)? Are not economy, conservation, and a craftsman's attachment to tools that have served him well better explanations for the use of aging adzes and hammers?
On the technical front, the author supplements his text with a series of eloquent photographs of buildings and builders at work and at rest; judiciously selected technical drawings elucidate explanations of building devices and structures. The indexes by topic and by author discussed are useful, and so is the glossary of the Arabic terms, especially for students of architecture and material culture in general. What a pity, however, that neither the glossary nor the main text follows any recognizable system of transliteration. This is a serious and unexplainable obstacle to using the fascinating technical information in the book.
These few weaknesses aside, I recommend this intelligent and highly informative work to anyone interested in systems of knowledge, architecture, material culture of the Middle East, and Yemeni studies. It can also serve as an excellent case study on the reading list of any graduate course on these and related subjects.