Michael Axworthy has recounted a “roaring tale” (p. xvi) in The Sword of Persia: Nader Shah, from Tribal Warrior to Conquering Tyrant. Using a vivid style, this work chronicles the rise and fall of Nadir Shah from his early origins in northern Khurasan to his assassination by his followers in 1747. The author begins with a prologue describing the zenith of Nadir's career, his conquest of Delhi and the Mughal Empire in 1739, to portray him as an exceptional ruler who prefigured later conquerors and tyrants like Napoleon, Stalin, and Hitler. Nadir's unique story, long regarded as anomalous, is presented as a vehicle to explore early modern Iranian history at a popular level. Acknowledging that the history of “great men” has become passé, Axworthy makes a good case for why the story of Nadir should attract the attention of a larger audience today. This work convincingly argues that Nadir should be seen as one of the first “modern” rulers in Iran, based on what he tried to accomplish and what transpired during his reign.
The text examines Nadir's career from his humble beginnings through his attempts to create an Asian empire. It draws on a variety of recent studies and a considerable range of primary sources to create a work accessible to both specialists and general readers. Information from Middle Eastern and European eyewitness accounts is cogently woven together in its clear narrative style. Axworthy gives special attention to certain sources, such as the work of the eyewitness Greek traveler Basil Vatatzes, that have not received much previous attention.
Trying to bring “Nadir's story to a new audience,” the author's approach has been to “look for elements of value in even the dubious sources” (p. xviii). He does this in a variety of ways, by reproducing anecdotes that capture the spirit of the times, such as those found in the Rustam al-Tavarikh, as well as applying the sociological theories of Ibn Khaldun and his concept of ʿaṣabiyya to Nadir's context in a novel, if somewhat uncritical fashion (pp. 26–27, 32). Axworthy also attempts to broaden his approach to early modern Iran, for example, by juxtaposing classic descriptions of combat found in the works of such European historians as Michael Howard and Tim Blanning with an account of the 1729 battle of Mihmandust to evoke the feelings unleashed there (p. 92). Sword of Persia rediscovers basic military history as it chronicles the unfolding of key battles at Gulnabad, Karnal, and Baghdad. The information presented is enhanced by a good selection of photographs and maps, which are well integrated into the text and with useful descriptions.
Axworthy's lively text is quite groundbreaking but does fall short in some ways. This work provides too little context for how Nadir justified his right to replace the Safavids in ruling Iran. One of the key issues in premodern and early modern Iranian history was how a ruler could demonstrate his farr, or royal charisma. Although some contemporary observers feel that the Safavids' farr had waned with such weak rulers as Shah Sultan Husayn, the dynasty was still believed in Iran to possess divine sanction, a fact reflected by the number of Safavid pretenders who continued to arise for decades after the fall of Isfahan in 1722. Sword of Persia focuses on the dissolute nature of the last Safavids, particularly Tahmasb II, compared with Nadir's military vigor, but does not give adequate treatment of the enduring power of Safavid legitimacy and how this affected Nadir's career.
Nadir's attempt to supersede the Safavids was also tied to his innovative religious policies, which Axworthy accurately depicts as part of Nadir's power politics. The work does not really touch, though, on how Nadir's challenges to the Shiʿi religious establishment fueled an exodus of clergy from Iran to Iraq and India as noted by Cole and others. This movement, in turn, figured in the emergence of a powerful independent religious bureaucracy back in Iran in the 19th century with the return of prominent Shiʿi clergy there under the Qajars, a development with profound effects on subsequent Iranian history. Another religious issue left unexamined is the question of how hajj pilgrimage politics shaped Nadir's relations with other Muslim rulers. Instead, the work turns to speculation about Nadir's personal religious beliefs, which leads Axworthy to make some unsupportable assertions: “It is unlikely that when Nader prayed before battle for example, he did so insincerely” (p. 169). Given what is known about Nadir, such a statement cannot be made in a rigorously historical fashion.
Axworthy asserts in his preface that if Nadir “had consolidated his military successes,” a “resurgent, dynamic Persia . . . could have averted the relative decline of the Islamic world vis-à-vis the West . . . As well as explaining how these things could have happened, this book explains why, for better or worse, they did not” (p. xviii). Fortunately, the book actually focuses much more on what did happen than what might have happened. Some of this uncertainty reflects the fact that 18th-century Iran remains quite unexplored compared with many other eras and topics in the region's history. The preceding list of caveats and problems does not detract, however, from the fact that Sword of Persia provides a very good overview of Nadir's career as well as an up-to-date summary of research on him.
