The recent success in generating live offspring from embryonic stem cell (ESC) –derived gametes in mice sparked visions of growing tailor-made sperm for men faced with infertility.1
Nayernia K, Nolte J, Michelmann HW, Lee JH, Rathsack K, Drusenheimer N, et al. In vitro-differentiated embryonic stem cells give rise to male gametes that can generate offspring mice. Developmental Cell 2006;11:125–32.
In the first part of this article, we review special reproductive settings in which it is difficult to argue why someone is—or is not—a genetic parent of the resulting child. Procedures that are discussed are ooplasmic transfer, reproduction through fetal oocytes, reproductive cloning, and haploidization.
In the second part, we analyze what the core elements are upon which our judgments regarding genetic parenthood are based. The aim is not to indicate what kind of parenthood generates parental rights and obligations. Other authors have repeatedly and extensively argued that genetic derivation is not or should not be the key factor in the establishment of these rights and obligations. Rather, parental rights and obligations should be rooted in elements such as causation, intentionality, or foreseeability.2
Austin MW. The failure of biological accounts of parenthood. The Journal of Value Inquiry 2004;38:499–510; Bayne T, Kolers A. Toward a pluralist account of parenthood. Bioethics 2003;17:221–42; Fuscaldo G. Genetic ties: Are they morally binding? Bioethics 2006;20:64–76; Silver LM, Silver SR. Confused heritage and the absurdity of genetic ownership. Harvard Journal of Law & Technology 1998;11:593–618.
Finally, we tackle the question of whether ESC-derived gametes would create genetic parenthood.
Ooplasmic Transfer and Oocyte Nuclear Transfer
Ooplasmic transfer (also called cytoplasmic transfer) involves the injection of a small amount of ooplasm from a donor egg into a recipient oocyte of which the ooplasm is unable to support normal embryonic development. It was first successfully performed in humans in 1997 but was subsequently banned in the United States.3
Cohen J, Scott R, Alikani M, Schimmel T, Munne S, Levron J, et al. Ooplasmic transfer in mature human oocytes. Molecular Human Reproduction 1998;4:269–80.
Brenner CA, Barritt JA, Willadsen S, Cohen J. Mitochondrial DNA heteroplasmy after human ooplasmic transplantation. Fertility and Sterility 2000;74:573–8.
Although the amount of mtDNA contributed by the donor is minimal in this technique, a similar procedure is being researched that would include all of the donor's mtDNA and none or little of the recipient's. In oocyte nuclear transfer, pronuclei from a fertilized egg are transplanted into an enucleated donor egg. This procedure would prevent the transmission of mitochondrial diseases to an affected woman's children. Although in this case the mtDNA is not mixed, one objection persists against both ooplasmic transfer and oocyte nuclear transfer, namely, that the resulting child would have two genetic mothers: one providing the nuclear DNA (and in the former case most of the mtDNA) and another providing mitochondrial DNA.5
Embryo with two mothers approved. BBC News, September 8, 2005. Available from: URL: http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/health/4225564.stm (accessed on August 8, 2006).
The question then arises of whether it is reasonable to designate the “ooplasm donor” as a genetic parent. The influence of mtDNA on the child will be very limited, especially compared to the influence of half the nuclear DNA originating from the “other” genetic mother. On the other hand, it is somewhat premature to dismiss the importance of mtDNA as having no influence at all, because a number of hereditary diseases are passed on through mtDNA and because it may also have an impact on certain behavioral traits.6
Chinnery PF, Howell N, Andrews RM, Turnbull DM. Clinical mitochondrial genetics. Journal of Medical Genetics 1999;36:425–36; Lease LR, Winnier DA, Williams JT, Dyer TD, Almasy L, Mahaney MC. Mitochondrial genetic effects on latent class variables associated with susceptibility to alcoholism. BMC Genetics 2005;6:S158.
Robertson JA. Reconstituting eggs: The ethics of cytoplasm donation. Fertility and Sterility 1999;71:219–21.
International Human Genome Sequencing Consortium. Finishing the euchromatic sequence of the human genome. Nature 2004;431:931–45.
Fetal Oocytes
A second possible development blurring the notion of genetic parenthood is the use of fetal oocytes for reproductive purposes. The procedures for the collection of oocytes from normal healthy women are very demanding and hold certain health risks. In addition, only a limited number of oocytes can be retrieved per cycle, resulting in an acute shortage of donor oocytes for infertility treatment and medical research. One possible alternative source of egg cells would be aborted female fetuses, whose ovaries could be transplanted into women lacking ovarian function or whose oocytes could be removed, in vitro matured, and used in infertility treatments. Due to the morally charged nature of this kind of procedure, it is unlikely to find its way to the clinic anytime soon and should thus be considered as a thought experiment rather than a clinical reality. There seem to be two ways to represent the hypothetical situation of a child born from such a “fetal” oocyte: the creation of a child that has no genetic mother or the creation of a child whose genetic mother is a fetus.9
Ethics Committee of the American Society of Reproductive Medicine. Use of fetal oocytes in assisted reproduction. Fertility and Sterility 2004;82:S258–9; Berkowitz JM. Mummy was a fetus: Motherhood and fetal ovarian transplantation. Journal of Medical Ethics 1995;21:298–304.
Reproductive Cloning
The use of donor ooplasm and the possibility of using fetal oocytes in infertility treatment are not the only advancements that are forcing us to rethink genetic parenthood. The prospect of making children that are genetically identical to an existing person poses an even greater challenge to the common outline of a family tree. Several mammals have been cloned by transferring a somatic cell nucleus of the “original” animal to an enucleated oocyte, which is then artificially activated to start embryogenesis. This procedure is called somatic cell nuclear transfer (SCNT), but is better known as “cloning.” Reproductive cloning in humans is so far purely theoretical because it is still unknown if the procedure has any chance of success. Given the levels of risk involved and the controversy surrounding this procedure, it is banned by many countries. For the sake of argument, however, we will envisage a situation in which children can be produced by cloning a prospective parent. Not 50% of the nuclear DNA would be identical, but virtually 100%. Does this mean that that person is even more a genetic parent than someone who only contributed half of his/her child's DNA or does it mean that the parents of the somatic cell donor, each contributing 50% of the nuclear DNA, are the actual genetic parents rather than grandparents (possibly together with the “mitochondrial mother” who provided the oocyte used in the SCNT procedure)? In the latter case, the person who was cloned would gain an identical twin brother or twin sister rather than a child.10
See note 2, Silver, Silver 1998.
Artificial Gametes by Haploidization
Reproductive cloning may not be appealing to many prospective parents because most couples long to have a baby that is related to both partners. The solution for people who lack usable gametes then consists of creating gametes tailored to their DNA. One route that is being explored to achieve this goal is somatic cell haploidization.11
Nagy ZP. Current advances in artificial gametes. Reproductive Biomedicine Online 2005;11:332–9.
Artificial haploidization relies on the ability of an oocyte to reduce a diploid nucleus by means of meiosis, resulting in pronuclei with haploid, single-chromatid (1n, 1c) chromosomes. When an artificial female gamete is needed, a donor oocyte is enucleated, receives the somatic cell nucleus (2n, 2c) of the prospective mother, and is then activated by the prospective father's sperm, leading to the formation and extrusion of a polar body containing half of the female nucleus' chromosomes. When a male gamete is needed, the male somatic cell nucleus is transferred to an intact oocyte of the female partner, which then needs to be artificially activated, leading to the extrusion of not only half of the female's but also half of the male's genetic material in a (pseudo) polar body.12
Tesarik J. Somatic cell haploidization: An update. Reproductive Biomedicine Online 2002;6:60–5.
Heindryckx B, Lierman S, Van der Elst J, Dhont M. Chromosome number and development of artificial mouse oocytes and zygotes. Human Reproduction 2004;19:1189–94.
Tateno H, Akutsu H, Kamiguchi Y, Latham KE, Yanagimachi R. Inability of mature oocytes to create functional haploid genomes from somatic cell nuclei. Fertility and Sterility 2003;79:216–8.
Criteria for Genetic Parenthood
We turn now to the common notion of genetic parenthood and which criteria can be used to define it, keeping in mind these new reproductive possibilities and the questions that follow from them.
The Importance of Genetic Information and Physical Contribution
The main aspect of genetic parenthood clearly lies in passing on genes to the next generation. A first important distinction that needs to be made is that between passing on the information that is contained in these genes and passing on genes as physical entities.15
Kolers A. Cloning and genetic parenthood. Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics 2003;12:401–10.
The Importance of Reshuffling
In the case of reproductive cloning, requiring genetic derivation both on an informational and physical level does not suffice to determine who a clone's genetic parents are. Here the child is derived from the genes of its “original version,” but another basic feature of human reproduction is missing: the mixing of two different genomes into a new individual. Silver and Silver have dubbed the person whose cell was used for cloning a “genetic progenitor,” whereas they consider the people whose genomes were reshuffled to form the child's genome the genetic parents.16
See note 2, Silver, Silver 1998.
If this distinction is adopted, the requirement of a direct physical contribution for genetic parenthood is invalid. However, the requirement of physical derivation of some kind needs to be retained. Instead of requiring direct physical derivation, it may be sufficient to require that a genetic parent be a physical cause of the child. This would explain why identical twins do not consider each other's children as their own and, at the same time allows retaining the idea that a child's genetic parents are the people whose genomes were reshuffled to constitute that child's genome. Thus, in the case of clones, both their progenitor as the parents of the progenitor are physical causes of their existence, but the progenitor needs to be ruled out as a candidate-genetic parent because his/her genes were never reshuffled.
The distinction between genetic information and physical genes is once again important with regard to reshuffling. Imagine the situation in which a clone would have children. If reshuffling the genetic information would be decisive, both the clone and its genetic progenitor would be genetic parents of the child. This is counterintuitive; most people will ascribe genetic parenthood only to the clone, whereas the progenitor of the clone will socially be regarded as an aunt/uncle or grandparent. Thus, parenthood is only ascribed to the person whose physical genes are reshuffled rather than to anyone whose genetic information is reshuffled.
A Definition of Genetic Parenthood
We have now reached a more precise definition of what is normally denominated as genetic parenthood: X is considered a genetic parent of Y if (i) X passes on genetic information to Y, (ii) X is a physical cause of Y's existence, and (iii) X's physical genes were reshuffled once to constitute Y.
According to this definition, a woman whose fetus' oocytes were used cannot be the mother of the resulting children because two reshufflings of the genome took place between her and the child. She is therefore the child's genetic grandmother. In the case of mtDNA being transferred by an oocyte donor, there is a physical causal connection, but there is only a very limited transfer of genetic information, and, because the contributed mtDNA is not reshuffled, the oocyte donor is not considered a genetic parent. When a clone is created, both the genetic progenitor and the progenitor's parents pass on their genetic information and are a physical cause of the clone's existence. The progenitor's genes were, however, not reshuffled, thus leaving only his or her parents as the genetic parents of the clone, and he or she is at the same time a sibling and genetic progenitor. Using gametes created by haploidization results in the transfer of genetic information, a physical causal relation, and reshuffling. Once technically possible, it would therefore be a valid method to achieve genetic parenthood. In the case of an artificial female gamete, the donor of the (enucleated) oocyte can again be ruled out as a possible genetic parent.
Embryonic Stem Cell-Derived Gametes
Having clarified the elements that underlie genetic parenthood, we can now return to our original question. Can genetic parenthood be established by reproduction through ESC-derived gametes? This hope has certainly been vocalized since the successful production of both sperm cells and egg cells from mouse ESCs in vitro and especially since the recent success in obtaining live births from mouse ESC-derived sperm cells.17
See note 1, Nayernia et al. 2006; Geijsen N, Horoschak M, Kim K, Gribnau J, Eggan K, Daley GQ. Derivation of embryonic germ cells and male gametes from embryonic stem cells. Nature 2004;27:148–54; Hübner K, Fuhrmann G, Christenson LK, Kehler J, Reinbold R, De La Fuente R, et al. Derivation of oocytes from mouse embryonic stem cells. Science 2003;300:1251–6; Toyooka Y, Tsunekawa N, Akasu R, Noce T. Embryonic stem cells can form germ cells in vitro. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2003;100:11457–62.
The procedure involves the transfer of the nucleus of a somatic cell from the infertile patient to an enucleated oocyte, which is then artificially activated, creating a cloned embryo. After 5 days, the inner cell mass of the embryo can be isolated in order to derive stem cells. These stem cells are then coaxed into becoming eggs or sperm, which, after an IVF procedure, could theoretically result in genetic offspring from the original donor of the somatic cell and his or her partner. Because “male” stem cells can become both eggs and sperm, this technique might even allow two men to have a baby together that is 50% genetically related to both of them. Another possibility is to produce children with just one genetic parent that would deliver both the “natural gamete” and the artificially derived gamete. This would not create a clone because the genetic material would be reshuffled.18
Newson AJ, Smajdor AC. Artificial gametes: New paths to parenthood? Journal of Medical Ethics 2005;31:184–6.
Just as for somatic cell haploidization, reservations about the numerous technical hurdles involved in using ESC-derived gametes are warranted. But in the latter case, we must also wonder if the procedure actually reaches its goal; is the donor of the somatic cell incontestably the genetic parent of the resulting baby? Because the child would have 50% of its DNA in common with the person whose somatic cell is used to create the stem cell line, the donor would have no problem passing a paternity or maternity test. However, even though the cloned embryo would only live for 5 days in this procedure and not be more than a ball of 150 cells, it may be regarded as an extra generation. So although using ESC-derived gametes could provide an infertile person with a child sharing 50% of his or her genetic makeup, in terms of family lineage, they are only related in the second (if the clone is regarded as a child of its genetic progenitor) or even third degree (if the clone is regarded as an identical twin of the progenitor). Thus, the child stands in a similar relationship to the progenitor as the children of the progenitor's identical twin (or clone), which, as we discussed earlier, is not acknowledged as a parent–child relationship.
Reproduction by means of ESC-derived gametes fulfills two of the three conditions that were formulated as requirements for genetic parenthood: Genetic information is passed on and the infertile patient is a physical cause of the child. However, not the patient's physical genes were reshuffled, but the embryo's.
This problem has not been discussed in recent literature on the possibilities of artificial gametes for infertility treatment.19
See note 18, Newson, Smajdor, 2005; Testa G, Harris J. Ethical aspects of ES cell-derived gametes. Science 2005;305:1719.
Alternatively, it can be argued that ESC-derived gametes do lead to genetic parenthood because the child contains half of the parent's genome. In this case, however, consistency requires that other widespread assessments of genetic parenthood are equally adjusted. For instance, identical twins will have to be considered as one entity because they only represent one genotype, and thus whenever one twin becomes a genetic parent, so does the other. For most people, especially for an identical twin sibling who is struggling with infertility, this will, however, not be a realistic assessment.
Therefore, the prospect of curing infertility with the help of embryonic stem cells on a therapeutic level—rather than using them as a research tool—needs to be put into perspective and there needs to be openness about its shortcomings.
Conclusion
Many people turn to reproductive medicine to fulfill their dream of becoming a genetic parent. Anticipated new reproductive methods differ profoundly from natural human reproduction, and the question arises of whether the link that is established between parents and offspring corresponds to the criteria for genetic parenthood. More specifically, the prospect of producing gametes derived from customized embryonic stem cells presents such an enormous “detour” from natural reproduction that some inquiry is warranted into the question of whether it can deliver what it promises, namely, genetic parenthood.
By reviewing and analyzing a number of existing and hypothetical reproductive possibilities, a core notion of genetic parenthood is defined. Three conditions are identified to determine when someone can be considered a genetic parent: (i) genetic information has to be passed on from parent to child, (ii) the parent needs to be a physical cause of the child, and (iii) physical genes have to be reshuffled once while going from parent to child.
Based on these three conditions, genetic parenthood cannot be obtained through ESC-derived gametes, because it would not be the infertility patient's genes that would be reshuffled but those of the cloned embryo. This does not mean that recent successes in the generation of artificial gametes have no importance for the treatment of infertility. The study of ESC-derived gametes is expected to lead to insights that will eventually lead to therapies, but should not be regarded as a possible treatment option in itself.
