Abdullah al-Arian wisely uses a wide lens for his study of Islamic activism in Egypt during the Sadat period (1970–81). Those years witnessed the return of Islam to public life after some two decades of harsh repression under the Nasserist regime. The return of religion in the 1970s was a global development that reversed a long held conviction of Western scholars that the future belonged to secularism. In Egypt, the renewal of Islam was a mass phenomenon rather than simply a movement of politicized Islam. Al-Arian captures that dimension by bringing the full spectrum of Islamic popular activism into view. The everyday actions of ordinary Egyptians reasserting their Islamic identity in myriad ways, as well as the activities of students with Islamic commitments, helped shape what al-Arian follows others in labelling an “Islamic resurgence.”
Al-Arian, at the same time, does not neglect the critical role of the Muslim Brothers (MB). This important book explains as no other the durability and adaptability of that venerable Egyptian movement. Al-Arian's key contribution is his analysis of the ways an aging and authoritarian MB leadership not only survived decades of repression but also succeeded in bringing new activist blood into the organization. Additionally, the book provides lessons in resilience that speak to the future of the MB.
As a young man in his twenties, Hassan al-Banna founded the MB in 1928 in the provincial city of Ismailia. The deeply religious al-Banna was a practical activist rather than a speculative thinker. Al-Banna gave his theoretical insights institutional rather than theoretical expression. He laid the lasting foundations for a pragmatic and effective organization that combined work for Islamic renewal with innovative social welfare practices. The Brothers under al-Banna's leadership invented new ways of acting for Islam in the modern world. Those innovations created a model of centrist Islamic activism with far-reaching effects across the Islamic world, including both Shiʿi and Sunni movements. At the same time, al-Banna's legacy built a contradiction into the MB. He combined support for vibrant activism that engaged members fully and afforded them a distinctive identity, and leadership under al-Banna that was both highly centralized and secretive. That paradox of authoritarian rigidity and fluid social interactions plagued the Brothers throughout their history, as al-Arian's account makes clear. The tightness of governance undoubtedly was a factor in survival in the face of the long years of repression under Jamal ʿAbd al-Nasir, Egypt's revolutionary leader. At the same time, social activism and service created wellsprings of popular support. Without an appreciation of this core paradox that al-Arian's book brings into view, it would be hard to imagine the spectacular return of the MB to public life in the wake of the fall of the Mubarak regime. The MB candidate, Mohamed Morsi won the office of presidency in Egypt's first democratic presidential election in June 2012.
Al-Arian analyses in precise, nonideological, and jargon-free terms the ways in which the organizational legacy of the MB was renewed by the senior cadres. Al-Arian tells the story of how key figures of the MB leadership, far too often dismissed as inept and sclerotic, in fact oversaw the absorption of the most gifted of Islamic student leaders of the Sadat years into a renewed MB organization. Al-Arian does not gloss over the organizational and ideological rigidities of the leadership. Yet, the analysis of these shortcomings is balanced by two factors that the author brings into view. In authoritarian circumstances, the tightness of the organization and the strong loyalties it demanded proved a considerable asset. The MB created a powerful identity for members that sustained them in difficult circumstances. Less a political and social movement than a disciplined way of life, the MB were uniquely equipped for survival in daunting circumstances. At the same time, and despite organization inflexibility, the MB managed to keep the banner of politicized Islam as an integral and attractive part of Egyptian public life.
Al-Arian demonstrates in precise detail the ways in which the new generation of leadership has been shaped in very distinctive ways by their formative experiences of student activism out of which they came to the MB. In tracing student activism, the author draws appropriately on the standard secondary sources on the MB in Arabic and English. The real contribution comes, however, with his thoughtful use of Arabic language memoires and interviews.
Al-Arian has a competent grasp of social movement literature and positions his work in that theoretical context. However, his most important contribution comes in the substantive chapters. Answering the Call comes to life in the second chapter where the author rescues the extremely important and universally neglected Youth of Islam (Shabab al-Islam) student movement from near oblivion. This important story is for the most part absent from the annals of Islamic activism. Answering the Call then makes its most important contribution in Chapters 3 through 6, which deal with the ways in which the MB leadership absorbed the best of the cadres developed by the Islamic student movements of the Sadat years. The focus is on the social and political activism of the MB and related Islamic movements. However, the implications go much further: al-Arian gives readers a window onto the struggles of a generation of young Egyptians to define Islam's place in modernity, their modernity, not through abstract speculation on the experience of others but by themselves acting politically and socially in their own, often difficult, circumstances.
The book does have its limitations. There is not enough attention to the independent scholars who emerged out of the Brothers, such as Muhammad al-Ghazzali as well as Yusuf al-Qaradawi who never completely broke with the MB. There is understatement of the importance of the centrist Wasat party experience and the leadership of Abul ʿEla Madi, in particular. Madi was a key player in the foundation of the Kifaya movement that paved the way for later revolutionary activism. There is almost no attention to the impact of the Brothers in the larger Islamic sphere, most notably Iran and Turkey.
Yet, for all those with an interest in the role of Islam in public life, this book makes a major contribution. Scholars and pundits, al-Arian's work suggest, have perhaps been too quick to speak of the end of Islam or the dawn of an era of post-Islamism. Al-Arian's epigraph provides a concise, fair assessment of the tragic events that have overtaken Egypt since the military, with American acquiescence, deposed the democratically elected MB president and took power in 2013. The account also captures the pathos of the self-inflicted wounds of the Brothers in power. Al-Arian does not, however, ignore the far more important manipulations of the powerful forces, both internal and external, that brought them down. Readers will better understand just why Egypt's democratic moment was judged so threatening to Egyptian secularists as well as the United States and so many of the major players in the region, notably Israel and the monarchial regimes of the Gulf. More importantly, they will come away with a grasp of the continuing centrality of popular activism in sustaining the work begun by Hassan al-Banna to secure a place for Islam in public life.
