Most people had probably never heard of Muscle Shoals prior to the 2013 theatrical release of the documentary Muscle Shoals. Located in the northwest corner of Alabama, “The Shoals,” as it is known locally, is comprised of four cities: Florence, Tuscumbia, Sheffield, and Muscle Shoals.Footnote 1 While Lynyrd Skynyrd memorialized Muscle Shoals in their 1974 tune “Sweet Home Alabama,” folks familiar with that song may not have known who the “Swampers” were or why they could “pick a song or two.” However, it is likely that many individuals had heard at least one track recorded at either Florence Alabama Music Enterprises (known as FAME) or at Muscle Shoals Sound Studio (hereafter MSSS), because numerous tunes recorded at these two studios became part of the popular musical fabric of the 1960s and 70s.
Muscle Shoals tells “the incredible true story of a small town with a big sound” by narrating the life of Rick Hall, the owner of FAME.Footnote 2 Hall's personal life is truly tragic, perhaps even Faulknerian: he was born into poverty, his brother died as child, his mother left the family and became a prostitute, his first wife died in a car crash, and his father died in a tractor accident. Despite, and perhaps as a result of, these hardships, Hall would go on to achieve great success in the recording industry. Even though his life provides the through line of Muscle Shoals, however, the soundtrack is the film's real star. The audience hears excerpts throughout the documentary, with numerous hit tracks that had been recorded at either FAME or MSSS interspersed between the interviews.
After the release of Arthur Alexander's 1961 track “You Better Move On,” Hall and FAME's studio musicians developed a reputation within the recording industry as one of the hot studios and rhythm sections in the South. The Shoals recording industry gained further national attention with Atlantic Records’ 1966 release of Percy Sledge's “When a Man Loves a Woman,” a track that reached number one on both the pop and R&B charts. In early 1966, Hall formed a partnership with Jerry Wexler and Atlantic Records to record the labels’ R&B acts at FAME. Up through 1969, a who's who of R&B artists including the Tams, Jimmy Hughes, James and Bobby Purify, Wilson Pickett, Arthur Conley, Etta James, Aretha Franklin, and many others recorded at FAME, usually with Hall producing. Then, in 1969, just after Hall signed an exclusive production and distribution deal with Capitol Records, his rhythm section at that time—Jimmy Johnson, guitar; David Hood, bass; Roger Hawkins, drums; and Barry Beckett, keyboards—left to form MSSS with financing by Atlantic Records. This rhythm section, later dubbed “the Swampers,” went on to provide the backing tracks and production for R.B. Greaves, Jimmy Cliff, the Staple Singers, Paul Simon, Bob Seger, and many others. Rick Hall still owns FAME, but the Swampers sold their studio and publishing interests to Malaco Records in the mid-1980s.Footnote 3
During the DVD bonus feature, “Swampers and Rick Reunion,” Hall states, “It means so very much to me for these guys to put me on a pedestal and give me credit for something I didn't necessarily do by myself.” This quotation exposes one of the documentary's primary flaws: it depicts Hall as a “lone genius” while essentially erasing many key figures from the history of the Shoals recording industry.Footnote 4 For instance, James Joiner, Tom Stafford, and Bobby Denton are all left out of the film, and yet they were instrumental in launching the Shoals recording scene years before Hall recorded his first track. Muscle Shoals also presents events that are not factually accurate, which is particularly troublesome for a documentary. When the Swampers left FAME in 1969, Hall was furious. But soon after, these individuals helped to form and served as board members for the Muscle Shoals Music Association, a group that lobbied on behalf of the many recording studios in the area. A weekly column about the Shoals recording industry, published in the Times Daily, the local paper in Florence, documented this and other stories. In fact, beginning in the mid-1960s, Billboard, Cashbox, and Record World, as well as leading newspapers frequently wrote about the Shoals recording scene.Footnote 5 Instead of narrating the actual events between Hall and his former rhythm section, the film depicts a modern day “reunion” accompanied by slow-motion cinematography to heighten the staged moment. Furthermore, several of the film's interviewees, including Hall, are prone to hyperbole, and Greg Camalier (a first-time director) does not critically interpret the many assertions heard throughout the documentary. In one egregious example, Jimmy Johnson, while speaking about the Rolling Stones’ 1969 recording session at MSSS, states that “nobody [in the band] was drinking and nobody was drugging.” The director quickly cuts to Mick Jagger, who says, “Well . . . I think we were drinking quite a lot,” a fact that Camalier supports by interspersing footage of the Stones at MSSS shot for Gimmie Shelter between the recent interviews. This moment received a huge laugh when I saw the film in a theater. But for me as a music historian, it underscored the film's lack of historical rigor by calling into question nearly all statements made by Johnson, Hall, and others.
Muscle Shoals shines a bright light onto the contributions of Hall and the numerous studio musicians who helped to create so many hits. The film includes recent interviews with the local musicians as well as commentary by a few music superstars about the lasting impact of tracks recorded at FAME or MSSS. But perhaps more importantly, the documentary has helped to revitalize musical tourism in the Shoals. In late 2011, not long before the film's release, the Alabama Music Hall of Fame, located in Tuscumbia, closed because of budget cuts. After the documentary's release in September 2013, several major events then took place: Beats Electronics, LLC, partnered with the Muscle Shoals Music Foundation to restore Muscle Shoals Sound Studio and to update FAME.Footnote 6 The Hall of Fame reopened in fall 2013. In 2014 Rick Hall received a Trustee Award from the Grammys.Footnote 7 Thanks in part to the film's buzz, Muscle Shoals became part of the Americana Music Triangle, a series of driving routes across the South with memorial plaques placed at key musical destinations.
In many ways, Muscle Shoals is a paradigmatic example of public musicology because it narrates historical musical events, reaches an audience of thousands, and produces tangible positive results for the local music community. When using this film or others like it in a class, responsible teachers will provide enough sociocultural and musical background so that their students can ask their own questions and reach their own conclusions as to the accuracy of the events depicted on screen. Shown along with the documentaries Standing in the Shadows of Motown (2002) and Respect Yourself: The Stax Records Story (2007), these films provide insight into three powerhouse R&B music production centers of the 1960s.Footnote 8
At one point in Muscle Shoals, musician John Paul White states, “There's a perfect storm here. Everybody needs to know all the different nuances that went into making this thing happen and all the stars aligning and exploding the way it did.” The documentary doesn't achieve a nuanced approach to telling the Muscle Shoals story, but it is a good place to continue the discourse about this important regional production center.
