We live in interesting times, both blessed and cursed by the moment. Classics as a discipline is being downsized, demoted, and dispersed across the academy; simultaneously, classical material and works of imagination inspired by antiquity are more broadly dispersed, more easily available than ever before. Fuelled, to some extent, by this tension, the growing field of reception studies builds connections between specialists and non-specialists, between the revered classical core and the often irreverent periphery it inspires.
Drawing on papers produced for an interdisciplinary conference at the University of Reading in 2007, Dunstan Lowe and Kim Shahabudin have put together an excellent collection of twelve analyses of classicizing material. The volume's chief success is in the efforts of all authors to grapple seriously with a truly varied range of popular media, efforts not limited to teasing out titbits derived from ancient culture. Some of the assembled authors press the inquiry notably further, to consider the function of specific media, how and why the consumer engages with a particular product, and the range of possibilities available for the deployment of classical content as dependent on the medium. The chapters are grouped into four large categories, based on the kind of mediation between the past and the present under scrutiny. The collection as a whole showcases the use of antiquity outside the academy, but a handful of pieces offer major contributions in areas seldom touched by classicists, inspiring this reader to look with new eyes on both the ancient originals and their modern reconfigurations.
Pathbreaking scholarship on ancient sexuality has had, in the past few decades, a transformative effect on the academy. Rome of the popular imagination has, for centuries, been constructed as a foundational realm of the senses. In ‘Dickus Maximus: Rome as pornotopia’, Nisbet explores the Private Media Group's presentation of ancient Rome; while the marketing copy touts the ‘frenzied’ and ‘raunchy’ ‘sex saga’ of the Private Gladiator trilogy, the Rome that appears on film is luxurious, comforting, perhaps even clichéd, an appropriate ambience for ‘entry-level’ hardcore. Far from the Caligulan debauchery imagined by earlier generations, this is a vanilla Rome, employed here to connect the viewer to Hollywood blockbusters and distanced by several removes even from receptions of Rome. Nisbet cautions us, however, that the medium matters. ‘Rome’ is not the point for the consumer of pornography; adult films are crafted as a framework to enable the viewer to achieve a desired end, the scenario following a set of rules meant to focus the audience toward that goal. Complicated plotlines with richly nuanced characters and a vividly authentic reconstruction of historical context would both distract the viewer from his/her target and generate additional cost for the producers. Nisbet goes on to question the lingering strength of the Roman paradigm in porndom (indeed, in popular culture generally), noting that practical extremes of the modern West have surpassed Rome's notorious, albeit traditional, capacity to shock and titillate its post-Roman audience.
Videogames are scary, by intention, of course. And for many classicists, they represent a frighteningly basic use of antiquity, with their habitual reduction of the ancient past to a handful of symbols and shreds of narrative. Nevertheless this medium is the primary conduit to the classical world for millions of young males and warrants scrutiny on that basis alone. The point is well argued by Lowe in ‘Playing with Antiquity’, who likewise emphasizes the opportunity for creative engagement in this medium especially, in which users can customize their experience by mining the riches of the past. Lowe admits, however, that the choice of content for use in the unalterable software paradigms of most videogames is overdetermined, selected from a very narrow range of classical material, a point reiterated with some distressing detail by Ghita and Andrikopoulos in ‘Total War and Total Realism’. Even with specialist users, the videogamers’ version of historical realism narrowly focuses on the replication of military equipment, largely removed from meaningful context. To hope for educational value from Total War: Rome, however, is, perhaps, to miss the point. Nisbet applies his analysis of the function of porn equally to videogames; here, too, the consumer demands a familiar experience, driven by specific rules, in which variations in setting, character, weapons or tools at hand lend a slightly different flavour, at most, from one game to the next. The pleasure to be taken from the product relies on a certain familiarity, a certain sameness, which allows the player to settle into the experience and reach the goal, whether that goal be sexual satiation or the ‘eXpurgation’, ‘eXtermination’, and annihilation of one's opponents. Lowe notes in passing the overwhelmingly male demographic in the market for videogames, a point implicit as well in Turner's recognition that 300's all-male narrative homosociality and the high level of explicit violence were meant to appeal to the male, specifically young male, target audience. Could one imagine another type of videogame? Could one construct a different pornography?
In ‘This way to the red light district’, Fisher and Langlands draw out the meanings and relevance of antiquity made by modern tourists (both live and internet) visiting Pompeii's re-opened Lupanar or brothel. Featured prominently in the guided tourist itinerary, the Lupanar shapes how many visitors experience Pompeii; travellers are encouraged to position themselves as modern equivalents of randy ancient sailors arriving in Pompeii's commercial port, following in their footsteps to satisfy essential human needs. Tourists replay and rework their experience of antiquity on the Flickr website through the exchange of annotated photographs of the brothel and its frescoes. Visitors embrace the Lupanar specifically, and ancient Rome in general, as a site that celebrates the expression of healthy sexuality, eliding the physical evidence for unequal power relations within the economics of prostitution, despite the efforts by professional guides to represent this aspect of Pompeian pragmata. The authors note that the perceived permissiveness of Pompeii, demonstrated in the display of sexual images in a ‘public’ context, gives the web participants permission to articulate their own views on sexuality, as well as legitimizing their consumption of explicit images.
Film analysis, a field already well established in reception studies, is also strongly represented here, with Turner and Shahabudin both exploring relatively new ground. In ‘Ancient mythology and modern myths’, Shahabudin contextualizes the original audience projected for the peplum or swords-and-sandals film, suggesting that anticipated venue and viewer habits influenced key features of the genre, rather than these simply being results of poor quality and low budget. Viewer discipline in third-tier or drive-in theatres, she notes, was casual, punctuated by disruptions and periodic inattention. The ebb and flow in peplum narrative accommodated this kind of informality: formulaic set pieces, designed to appeal to a particular demographic, structured the film and ensured a specific, and pleasurable, experience. Her deconstruction of the ‘atomic’ motif in Hercules Conquers Atlantis! is intriguing, certainly, but one could hope for more connection to the motif's contemporary occurrence in B-grade monster movies, where the relationship between science and humanity is inflected somewhat differently. In ‘Only Spartan women give birth to real men’, Turner focuses on 300's visual content, specifically the conspicuous male nudity, and how Snyder's stylistic choices in this area use multiple classical models to subtly shade the film's message. Noting Frank Miller's acknowledged influence of vase painting in the development of the graphic novel, Turner points to the strong correspondence between the film version's digitally-crafted (and markedly uniform) physiques and the proportions and surfaces of late Classical and Hellenistic sculpture. The Spartans are not merely sculptural in form, however; they invoke both ruins and monuments. Drawing in the film's metanarrative of memorialization by the character Dilios, Turner reminds us that the heroizing process in the West typically involves the creation of artifice or partial truths, often signified by ancient idealized forms. 300 itself serves as such a monument. Nudity also functions in 300 as nakedness, as the human body made available to a desiring gaze. Turner's deft consideration of the sexualized body likewise turns on multiple points of classical intrusion, while noting that, for a modern audience, classical nudity cannot carry a classical meaning. Here, as throughout the volume, the consumption of antiquity is not a passive process.
