In the prologue to his book, Mark Fonder includes an illustration of the September 1917 edition of C. G. Conn's Musical Truth, which features portraits of “Seven of the Most Prominent Bandmasters of America” (5). John Philip Sousa is in the center, surrounded by Patrick Conway, Arthur Pryor, Bohumir Kryl, Giuseppe Creatore, Frederick Neil Innes, and Alessandro Liberati. It is a sad commentary on the state of band research in the United States that whereas there are entries for all seven in Grove and the Heritage Encyclopedia, scattered articles in various journals, and Wikipedia pages for Kryl, Liberati, Pryor, and Sousa, not one, other than Sousa, has had a scholarly biographical study devoted to him.Footnote 1 Although none achieved the widespread fame of Sousa, all were very significant players during the “Golden Age of Bands” (ca. 1880–1932). Fonder's meticulously researched and comprehensive work on Conway and his band, therefore, is a major contribution not only to wind band research, but to the study of U.S. music in general.
Fonder, a professor of music and conductor of the Ithaca College Concert Band, succinctly outlines the reasons for Conway's inclusion in the top rank of professional bandmasters of the Golden Age: “Conservatively estimated, hundreds of thousands of people were entertained by ‘Conway and His Band’ on his nationwide tours. . . . It was claimed that his band could give as many as 100 concerts in a four-week period and never repeat a program.” Conway was also a prolific recording artist, regular radio broadcaster, familiar figure in the press, and founder of a nationally known band training school. Fonder concludes, “For almost 30 years, Patrick Conway rode at the top of his profession” (1–2). He suggests that one reason Conway has fallen into obscurity is that, unlike Sousa, Edwin Franko Goldman, and Pryor, Conway was not a composer. He is nevertheless significant because his life illustrates the professional band scene of his time.
The book is organized chronologically, beginning with Conway's early accomplishments and musical activities in the small village of Homer, New York. Born 4 July 1865 to Irish immigrants Martin and Bridget Dane Conway, Patrick (“Patsy”) learned the cornet and was playing with the Homer Band while still a teenager. The band toured throughout central New York and was even praised by Patrick Gilmore. The group disbanded in 1892 because of financial problems, and Conway became the manager and cornet soloist for the Cortland Band. In 1893 that band began to compete with other bands in yearly conventions organized by the Central New York Volunteer Firemen's Association. These conventions, with as many as twenty bands competing, predate the famous 1923 national school band contests and deserve further study on their own.Footnote 2 In 1895, Conway was invited to conduct a municipal band and orchestra for the city of Ithaca, New York, and to assume leadership of the Cornell University Cornet Band. The Ithaca Band became so successful in the yearly competitions that no band was willing to compete against it in 1900. Fonder credits these contests as the most important factor in the early development of Conway's professional career (79).
From the time of Patrick Gilmore following the Civil War, to when Sousa began touring with his band in 1892, many bands toured with success. The impetus for Conway forming his own fully professional, unionized touring band seems to have been an invitation for the Ithaca Band to perform at the 1901 Pan-American Exposition in Buffalo. Conway's engagement at the Exposition lasted only one week, but it represented the start of his yearly tours, which, as for most bands, took place only in the summer. During the rest of the year, Conway directed the Lyceum Theater Orchestra, taught at the Ithaca Conservatory, and provided music for special events in and around Ithaca. He was his own manager, seeking engagements and preparing music.
Conway was able to engage the finest symphony musicians for his tours because orchestral seasons did not last into summer. Further, he paid better than union scale wages, which the players certainly earned! Frank Seltzer, one of Conway's cornet soloists and a columnist for Jacobs Band Monthly, described the hard life of a touring band musician.Footnote 3 Appearing at parks, fairs, expositions, and other venues, the musicians would perform two to four concerts per day, seven days per week. The musician had to supply his own uniform and equipment, find his own lodging on tour, and pay for his own meals. It is a tribute to Conway's character that some of his musicians remained with him for more than twenty-five years. The size of the band varied over the years from thirty to fifty musicians.
Over the next several years, the scope of Conway's tours expanded, as did his fame. By 1907, the Ithaca Band was known as Patrick Conway and His Famous Band. The 1909 tour, with fifty musicians and two vocalists, involved a demanding itinerary that took him to four cities and as many states in eighteen weeks. But the 1916 tour was the most ambitious: nineteen weeks at nine different venues. His programs normally consisted of band transcriptions of classical orchestral works. Like Sousa, he inserted an encore after each work. “Depending on the era, he would use the latest ‘coon’ song, ragtime hit, the newest Broadway smash and the hottest in syncopated jazz as his encore, but he always used these as the metaphorical dessert to his classic repertoire main course” (252). In between tours, Conway was busy recording for the Victor, Edison, Okeh, and Pathé labels. Appendix 2, prepared by Frederick P. Williams, contains a useful and comprehensive discography of the more than 200 Conway Band recordings made between 1912 and 1922. Conway also found time to conduct the Syracuse Symphony Orchestra and the Empire Theater Orchestra. In addition to accompanying vaudeville acts, beginning around 1913, Conway's small orchestra also provided incidental music for silent movies.
The coming of World War I had an impact on Conway's band, both because venues became reluctant to book attractions and because many musicians volunteered or were drafted to serve, and Conway had difficulty finding qualified players. Inspired by Sousa's commissioning as a lieutenant in the Naval Reserve to train musicians at the Great Lakes Naval Station, in July of 1918 Conway applied for a position in the army. Granted a captain's commission, he was assigned to Camp MacArthur in Waco, Texas, tasked with developing bands for the new U.S. Air Service. His hope of developing a special Air Service Band equal to the famous U.S. Marine Band vanished when peace was restored in 1918, and he returned to civilian life.
Conway resumed touring during the summer months, but it was becoming more difficult to find qualified musicians. He responded by opening the Conway Military Band School in September 1922. Affiliated with the Ithaca Conservatory, it was described at the time as the first and only institute of its kind in the United States. That was good press, but not quite true, for there were some earlier schools that specialized in training band musicians.Footnote 4 Conway believed that a professional musician should have “a knowledge of all band instruments, of directing and organizing a band, of composing, and a thorough acquaintance, not only with band literature, but also of all other musical literature” (196). In addition to harmony, solfeggio, music history, and counterpoint, students had to study a major and a minor instrument. Fonder provides a thorough discussion of the school and its operations, including requirements for admission, tuition, daily schedules, repertoire lists, activities, and famous graduates.
In the years before his death on 10 June 1929, Conway became active as a national broadcaster. In 1926, the National Broadcasting Company formed a network of stations that enabled simultaneous national broadcasting, and General Motors soon sponsored a series of network broadcasts entitled the General Motors Family Party. Along with Nathaniel Shilkret's forty-piece orchestra and comedian Willie Collier, Conway's forty-piece band opened the series in November 1927. Chosen “because it had traveled the length and breadth of the country for the past 20 years,” Conway and his band performed on the program again in 1928 and 1929 (228–30).
Conway was described by his contemporaries as genial and easygoing. He maintained his military bearing and athlete's physique throughout his life and neither drank nor smoked. He hired only the finest musicians and soloists he could afford and paid them better than scale wages. Fonder's excellent biography makes a significant contribution in recovering the life and legacy of a major figure from the Golden Age of Bands.
