Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-wxvwp Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T13:13:52.126Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Reynolds number dependence of turbulence induced by the Richtmyer–Meshkov instability using direct numerical simulations

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 December 2020

M. Groom*
Affiliation:
School of Aerospace, Mechanical and Mechatronic Engineering, University of Sydney, Sydney, NSW 2006, Australia
B. Thornber
Affiliation:
School of Aerospace, Mechanical and Mechatronic Engineering, University of Sydney, Sydney, NSW 2006, Australia
*
†Email address for correspondence: michael.groom@sydney.edu.au

Abstract

This paper investigates the Reynolds number dependence of a turbulent mixing layer evolving from the Richtmyer–Meshkov instability using a series of direct numerical simulations of a well-defined narrowband initial condition for a range of different Reynolds numbers. The growth rate exponent $\theta$ of the integral width and mixed mass is shown to marginally depend on the initial Reynolds number $Re_0$, as does the minimum value of the molecular mixing fraction $\varTheta$. The decay rates of turbulent kinetic energy and its dissipation rate are shown to decrease with increasing $Re_0$, while the spatial distribution of these quantities is biased towards the spike side of the layer. The normalised dissipation rate $C_{\epsilon }$ and scalar dissipation rate $C_{\chi }$ are calculated and are observed to be approaching a high Reynolds number limit. By fitting an appropriate functional form, the asymptotic values of these two quantities are estimated as $C_{\epsilon }=1.54$ and $C_{\chi }=0.66$. Finally, an evaluation of the mixing transition criterion for unsteady flows is performed, showing that, even for the highest $Re_0$ case, the turbulence in the flow is not yet fully developed. This is despite the observation of a narrow inertial range in the turbulent kinetic energy spectra, with a scaling close to $k^{-3/2}$, where k is the radial wavenumber.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2020. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Isosurface of volume fraction $f_1=0.5$ at time $\tau =0$.

Figure 1

Table 1.The molecular weight $W$, ratio of specific heats $\gamma$ and Prandtl and Schmidt numbers of fluid 1 (heavy) and fluid 2 (light).

Figure 2

Table 2.The initial impulse, total simulation time, domain size and maximum grid resolution employed for each initial Reynolds number.

Figure 3

Figure 2.Contours of volume fraction $f_1$ for $(a)$$Re_0=174$ and $(b)$$Re_0=697$ at time $\tau =0.94$, bounded by the isosurfaces $f_1=0.1$ (black) and $f_1=0.9$ (white).

Figure 4

Figure 3.Temporal evolution of $(a)$ integral width and $(b)$ mixed mass. Shown are data for $Re_0=43$ (dotted black lines), $Re_0=86$ (dashed black lines), $Re_0=174$ (white diamonds), $Re_0=348$ (grey squares), $Re_0=697$ (black circles) and $Re_0=1395$ (dash-dot grey lines).

Figure 5

Figure 4.$(a)$ Temporal evolution of molecular mixing fraction at the mixing layer centre plane. Shown are data for $Re_0=43$ (dotted black lines), $Re_0=86$ (dashed black lines), $Re_0=174$ (white diamonds), $Re_0=348$ (grey squares), $Re_0=697$ (black circles) and $Re_0=1395$ (dash-dot grey lines). $(b)$ Minimum value of molecular mixing fraction vs. initial Reynolds number, including curve fits to the data (dashed lines).

Figure 6

Figure 5.Temporal evolution of $(a)$ turbulent kinetic energy and $(b)$ dissipation rate at the mixing layer centre plane. Shown are data for $Re_0=43$ (dotted black lines), $Re_0=86$ (dashed black lines), $Re_0=174$ (white diamonds), $Re_0=348$ (grey squares), $Re_0=697$ (black circles) and $Re_0=1395$ (dash-dot grey lines).

Figure 7

Figure 6.Spatial distribution of turbulent kinetic energy in the $x$-direction for times ($a$) $\tau =0.187$, ($b$) $\tau =0.939$ and ($c$) $\tau =4.70$. Shown are data for $Re_0=43$ (dotted black lines), $Re_0=86$ (dashed black lines), $Re_0=174$ (white diamonds), $Re_0=348$ (grey squares), $Re_0=697$ (black circles) and $Re_0=1395$ (dash-dot grey lines).

Figure 8

Figure 7.Spatial distribution of dissipation rate in the $x$-direction for times ($a$) $\tau =0.187$, ($b$) $\tau =0.939$ and ($c$) $\tau =4.70$. Shown are data for $Re_0=43$ (dotted black lines), $Re_0=86$ (dashed black lines), $Re_0=174$ (white diamonds), $Re_0=348$ (grey squares), $Re_0=697$ (black circles) and $Re_0=1395$ (dash-dot grey lines).

Figure 9

Figure 8.Compensated power spectra of the average transverse turbulent kinetic energy per unit volume taken at the mixing layer centre plane for times ($a$) $\tau =0.187$, ($b$) $\tau =0.939$ and ($c$) $\tau =4.70$. Shown are data for $Re_0=43$ (dotted black lines), $Re_0=86$ (dashed black lines), $Re_0=174$ (white diamonds), $Re_0=348$ (grey squares), $Re_0=697$ (black circles) and $Re_0=1395$ (dash-dot grey lines).

Figure 10

Figure 9.Compensated power spectra of the normal turbulent kinetic energy per unit volume taken at the mixing layer centre plane for times ($a$) $\tau =0.187$, ($b$) $\tau =0.939$ and ($c$) $\tau =4.70$. Shown are data for $Re_0=43$ (dotted black lines), $Re_0=86$ (dashed black lines), $Re_0=174$ (white diamonds), $Re_0=348$ (grey squares), $Re_0=697$ (black circles) and $Re_0=1395$ (dash-dot grey lines).

Figure 11

Figure 10.Decomposition of the compensated average transverse turbulent kinetic energy per unit volume (black circles) in the $Re_0=697$ case into solenoidal (white circles), total dilatational (solid grey lines) and compressible (dashed black lines) components for times ($a$) $\tau =0.187$, ($b$) $\tau =0.939$ and ($c$) $\tau =4.70$.

Figure 12

Figure 11.Temporal evolution of $(a)$ scalar variance and $(b)$ scalar dissipation rate at the mixing layer centre plane. Shown are data for $Re_0=43$ (dotted black lines), $Re_0=86$ (dashed black lines), $Re_0=174$ (white diamonds), $Re_0=348$ (grey squares), $Re_0=697$ (black circles) and $Re_0=1395$ (dash-dot grey lines).

Figure 13

Figure 12.Spatial distribution of scalar variance in the $x$-direction for times ($a$) $\tau =0.187$, ($b$) $\tau =0.939$ and ($c$) $\tau =4.70$. Shown are data for $Re_0=43$ (dotted black lines), $Re_0=86$ (dashed black lines), $Re_0=174$ (white diamonds), $Re_0=348$ (grey squares), $Re_0=697$ (black circles) and $Re_0=1395$ (dash-dot grey lines).

Figure 14

Figure 13.Spatial distribution of scalar dissipation rate in the $x$-direction for times ($a$) $\tau =0.187$, ($b$) $\tau =0.939$ and ($c$) $\tau =4.70$. Shown are data for $Re_0=43$ (dotted black lines), $Re_0=86$ (dashed black lines), $Re_0=174$ (white diamonds), $Re_0=348$ (grey squares), $Re_0=697$ (black circles) and $Re_0=1395$ (dash-dot grey lines).

Figure 15

Figure 14.Temporal evolution of $(a)$ normalised dissipation rate and $(b)$ normalised scalar dissipation rate at the mixing layer centre plane. Shown are data for $Re_0=43$ (dotted black lines), $Re_0=86$ (dashed black lines), $Re_0=174$ (white diamonds), $Re_0=348$ (grey squares), $Re_0=697$ (black circles) and $Re_0=1395$ (dash-dot grey lines).

Figure 16

Figure 15.Transverse Taylor microscale Reynolds number vs. $(a)$ normalised dissipation rate and $(b)$ normalised scalar dissipation rate at the mixing layer centre plane. Shown are data for times $\tau =0.187$ (dotted lines), $\tau =0.939$ (dashed lines), $\tau =3.76$ (grey dashed lines) and $\tau =4.70$ (solid lines).

Figure 17

Figure 16.Evolution of length scales for $Re_0=174$$(a)$, $Re_0=348$$(b)$ and $Re_0=697$$(c)$. Plotted are the outer scale $h$ (circles), the integral length $\varLambda$ (squares), the Taylor microscales $\lambda _{x}$ (upward triangles) and $\lambda _{yz}$ (downward triangles) and the Kolmogorov microscale $\eta$ (diamonds).

Figure 18

Figure 17.Evolution of Reynolds numbers for $Re_0=174$$(a)$, $Re_0=348$$(b)$ and $Re_0=697$$(c)$. Plotted are the outer-scale Reynolds number $Re_h$ (circles) and the Taylor-scale Reynolds numbers $Re_{\lambda _{x}}$ (upward triangles) and $Re_{\lambda _{yz}}$ (downward triangles).

Figure 19

Figure 18.Evolution of length scales $(a)$ and Reynolds numbers $(b)$ for $Re_0=1385$. Plotted are the outer scale $h$ and associated Reynolds number $Re_h$ (circles), the integral length $\varLambda$ (squares), the Taylor microscales $\lambda _{x}$ (upward triangles) and $\lambda _{yz}$ (downward triangles) and associated Reynolds numbers $Re_{\lambda _{x}}$ and $Re_{\lambda _{yz}}$ and the Kolmogorov microscale $\eta$ (diamonds).

Figure 20

Figure 19.Liepmann–Taylor (black lines, white symbols) and inner-viscous (grey lines, black symbols) length scales vs. time. Results are shown for $Re_0=174$ (upward triangles), $Re_0=348$ (downward triangles), $Re_0=697$ (diamonds) and $Re_0=1395$ (squares). Also shown is the estimated diffusion layer length scale (white circles) for the $Re_0=1395$ case.

Figure 21

Figure 20.Decomposition of the compensated average transverse turbulent kinetic energy per unit volume (solid black lines) in the $Re_0=1395$ case into solenoidal (white circles), total dilatational (solid grey lines) and compressible (dashed black lines) components for times ($a$) $\tau =0.187$ and ($b$) $\tau =0.939$. Also shown are the wavenumbers corresponding to the Liepmann–Taylor (right triangles) and inner-viscous (left triangles) length scales.

Figure 22

Figure 21.($a$) Liepmann–Taylor (black squares), inner-viscous (grey diamonds) and diffusion layer (white circles) length scales vs. Taylor-scale Reynolds number at the mixing layer centre plane for time $\tau =0.939$ ($\tau -\tau _s=0.929$). Also shown is the ratio of the inner-viscous to diffusion layer length scales vs. Taylor-scale Reynolds number (triangles) including the line of best fit (dashed lines). ($b$) Critical Taylor-scale Reynolds number vs. time.

Figure 23

Figure 22.Temporal evolution of enstrophy $(a)$ and scalar dissipation rate $(b)$ for the $Re_0=697$ case. Results are shown for grid resolutions of $180\times 128^2$ (dotted lines), $360\times 256^2$ (dashed lines), $720\times 512^2$ (solid lines) and $1440\times 1024^2$ (circles).

Figure 24

Figure 23.Power spectra of enstrophy $(a)$ and scalar dissipation rate $(b)$ at time $\tau =0.470$. Results are shown for grid resolutions of $180\times 128^2$ (dotted lines), $360\times 256^2$ (dashed lines), $720\times 512^2$ (solid lines) and $1440\times 1024^2$ (circles).