Emma Fattorini's work, beautifully translated by Carl Ipsen, utilizes previously unpublished source material from the recently opened Vatican secret archives to explore the evolution in Pope Pius XI's (Achille Ratti) thinking regarding fascism, National Socialism, and totalitarianism in general. Weaving together the aging pope's decline in health, accompanied by his inner reflections on the nature of the world around him, Fattorini seeks to reconstruct both the internal and external factors that resulted in Pius XI's final speech which would have strongly condemned fascism and National Socialism. The speech, however, was never delivered as Pius XI died on 10 February 1939 with the text of his address at to his bedside. His former secretary of state, Eugenio Pacelli (Pope Pius XII), acting as camerlengo, had the text immediately destroyed following Pius's death.
What contributed to Pius XI's growing disillusionment with fascism and National Socialism when he certainly has been portrayed as an antidemocratic, antiliberal pope? To answer this question, Fattorini begins the work with an examination into Pius's early life and how his love of mountain climbing allowed him to draw parallels with the values of his Catholic faith: perseverance, determination, contemplation of nature, and reverence for the work of God. These qualities would remain with Pius until his death and would serve him well when, as a young man, he entered political-diplomatic service, first as nuncio in Poland and Lithuania (1918–1921) and then as papal commissary to Upper Silesia in 1920. From these first experiences, Ratti experienced firsthand the perils of ultranationalism, believing that such extremes could result in the subjugation of a religious identity to that of a national one. After his service in Poland, Ratti was named cardinal by Pope Benedict XV, and then went to Milan as its archbishop. His time spent in Poland, watching the interplay of Bolshevism, German nationalism, and Polish nationalism, would remain with him as a source of concern, as he realized that ultranationalism could not uphold the true principles of Christianity.
With Benedict's death in January 1922, Ratti emerged as the choice of the conclave, just a few months before Mussolini's rise to power in Italy. As the new pope, Pius XI embraced the idea of re-Christianizing society, connecting his mission to the spirituality of St. Therese de Lisieux. He wanted to minimize the secular political world and to protect Catholicism from becoming a political “tool.” Once Mussolini's “March on Rome” had occurred, Pius would first believe that he could work with the fascists as they shared a common core of values: authority, order, family, moderation (37). The numerous challenges Pius XI would face, however, would ultimately lead him to great disillusionment.
As the mid-1930s progressed, the Pope would find himself facing many daunting decisions. In France, the Communist Party would make a famous offer of “the proffered hand.” In such a delicate situation in 1936, Pius renewed calls for Catholic social peace, while simultaneously making it understood that Catholics should not work with Communist organizations. Soon Pius received a letter from the Superior General of the Jesuits, Count Wlodzimierz Ledochowski, asking the pope to issue an encyclical condemning Bolshevism. The resulting encyclical, Divini Redemptoris, went through numerous drafts, with the Superior General pushing for attacks against Free Masons and Jews as well as Communists while Pius noted in the margins, “Verify!” (69), to each of Ledochowski's demands. Further demands would be made on Pius in 1936 to declare the Spanish Civil War a “holy crusade” of General Francisco Franco waged against the specter of “godless atheism and Bolshevism.” The Holy Father was increasingly shocked by the murderous violence perpetrated against the members of the Catholic Church in Spain, but he waited for almost two years before endorsing Franco's side in the conflict.
Fattorini's chapter on Nazism addresses Pius's perception that Communism was perhaps not the greatest threat to civilization, but instead, Nazism was. She traces some of the challenges presented to the Catholic Church in Nazi Germany and explores the creation of the encyclical Mit brennender Sorge in 1937. There are many missing pages regarding the discussions that led up to the creation of the encyclical, and Fattorini is correct to ask just where the documents have gone. There was certainly a divided discussion regarding the contents of the encyclical, but the core of the final copy is that Nazism is to be rejected owing to its elevation of race, blood, and the state to levels of idolatry. The encyclical exploded on the scene, infuriating the Nazi leadership and resulting in ramped up persecutions of the Church in Germany. To the Nazis, Mit brennender Sorge was seen as a near diplomatic rupture, but to the Vatican, the encyclical and its aftereffects suggested a temporary problem to the relationship.
Complicating the situation even more would be the 1938 Anschluss of Austria, where anti-Catholic and anti-Semitic measures were ruthlessly put in place, and Hitler's spring 1938 visit to Italy, resulting in Pius's retreat to Castelgandolfo for the entire summer. Snubbing Hitler, Pius contacted the American Jesuit John LaFarge, and meeting with him at the papal summer residence, asked the stunned Jesuit to write a strong, simply worded draft for an encyclical denouncing racism and anti-Semitism. Fattorini argues that this request to LaFarge shows Pius's change in thinking in the last years of his life: “it was not then a hasty reaction or improvisation, but rather exactly the opposite, in some sense a distillation of the pope's thought that he wanted to sanction in a formal encyclical dedicated for the first time explicitly to the issue of anti-Semitism” (155). It was also over this summer of 1938 that Pius would have to do battle with Mussolini over the introduction of racial laws in Italy as well. Finally, by September 1938, Pius issued a clear statement on anti-Semitism: “Christians are not permitted to take part in anti-Semitism. … Spiritually we are all Semites” (161). By this point in 1938, Pius seems to have concluded that the aims of fascism and the Catholic Church were incompatible.
As to the final weeks of the life of the pope, Fattorini addresses the image of Pius as old, weak, and too ill to control events transpiring around him. In her portrayal, Pius maintained his mental faculties to the absolute end of his life even while his body failed him. In this chapter, Pius is struggling to hold on to his life long enough to issue a strong condemnation of Mussolini at the tenth anniversary of the Lateran Treaties. This final duel between Mussolini and the pope kept Pius working on his speech until the moment of his death. As the speech was never delivered, much speculation swirled for decades around its contents. Fattorini provides an examination of the discourse, including Pius's disillusionment with fascism and racial theories, as he declared definitively that “all races are joined together and all of the same blood in the common link of the great human family” (192). The remarks, hidden from the public by Eugenio Pacelli, might have challenged the dominant image in the press of the time of a pope aligned with the forces of fascism.
Fattorini's book does a fine job of weaving the inner world of the Vatican with the outer world of fascist and Nazi regimes. There are, however, some areas where further elaboration would have been beneficial. For example, when discussing the role of Father Tacchi-Venturi as liaison between Pius XI and Mussolini, bringing out the priest's own anti-Semitic views would serve to highlight just how far Pius had traveled in his opinions regarding Jews. Or, when discussing the valor of then bishop of Muenster, Clemens August Graf von Galen (later a cardinal), perhaps it would have been useful to disclose his silence regarding Nazi anti-Semitic attacks in Germany. Again, this type of example would reveal Pius to have matured beyond the traditional anti-Judaism of the Catholic Church. Discussing the role of Father Ledochowski or Father Rosa of Civilta Cattolica and their virulent anti-Semitism would also complicate the picture of Vatican politics. Finally, it would have been helpful if the book had a bibliography so that readers could pursue their own course of study in any number of the topics Fattorini chose to tackle.
