Chemical weapons are among the weapons of mass destruction that have caused huge human casualties in the last century. Because of their easy manufacturing and accessibility, and despite international treaties, they remain a serious threat to global security, not just limited to military staff but also to civilian populations and the environment in the short and long term.
The military conflicts, global flows of weapons and rearmament, military escalations in Europe, the Middle East, and Asia have significantly increased the threat of chemical, biological, radiological, nuclear, and explosive (CBRNE) attacks. Both Russia and Ukraine have accused each other of deploying chemical warfare agents (CWAs), with some allegations reported to the Organisation for the Prohibition of Chemical Weapons (OPCW).1 While most members of the international community have ratified the Chemical Weapons Convention, it does not cover all potentially weaponized chemical agents. For instance, substances such as white phosphorus and pharmaceutical-based compoundsReference Hadjimatheou2 such as aerosolized fentanyl, used lethally in the 2002 Moscow theatre hostage crisis,Reference Riches, Read, Black, Cooper and Timperley3 are being developed with the capacity to inflict mass casualties. The situation in the Middle East is even more alarming due to the involvement of multiple parties. The destabilization of Syria, uncertainty surrounding its CWAs stockpiles, and the potential acquisition of CBRNE materials by jihadist and terrorist groups such as the Islamic State of Iraq and Syria (ISIS) further underscore the urgency for comprehensive global preparedness and coordinated mitigation strategies.Reference Rathore4–Reference DeLuca, Chai, Goralnick and Erickson6
Beyond CWAs, several chemicals widely used in civilian life have dual-use potential, serving both industrial and military purposes, highlighting the widespread risks associated with such substances.Reference Mahfoud, Aicardi, Datta and Rose7 For instance, chlorine, a common disinfectant in swimming pools, can be weaponized. Thiodiglycol, found in pen ink, is also a precursor for mustard gas, and organophosphates, which are widely used in agriculture, can be modified into nerve agents like sarin. The sarin gas was manufactured and used by a non-state organization in terrorist acts against civilians in 1994 and 1995 in Japan.Reference Sugiyama, Matsuoka and Sakamune8 Other notable industrial dual-use chemicals include the 1984 Bhopal gas tragedy in India, where methyl isocyanate leakage caused thousands of deaths and hundreds of thousands injuredReference Murthy9; the 1976 Seveso disaster in Italy,Reference Bertazzi and di Domenico10 which released toxic dioxins; the 2015 Tianjin explosions in China, resulting from improperly stored chemicalsReference Li and Tian11; the 2005 chlorine gas release from a train derailment in Graniteville, South CarolinaReference Wenck, Van Sickle and Drociuk12; the 2020 Beirut port explosion caused by improperly stored ammonium nitrateReference Al-Hajj, Dhaini, Mondello, Kaafarani, Kobeissy and DePalma13; and the recent April 26, 2025, chemical incident in Bandar Abbas, Iran,Reference Nilo Tabrizy, Torbati and George14 involving the release of toxic gases. These incidents collectively underscore the persistent and global threat posed by industrial and dual-use toxic chemicals. They also highlight the pressing need for stringent international regulations, robust legal frameworks, and comprehensive medical emergency preparedness.
The severity of effects following exposure to CWAs and toxic dual-use chemicals depends on multiple factors, including the type of agent, the route and duration of exposure, environmental conditions and protective barriers, but access to medical disaster preparedness and robust, sustainable health care services might significantly influence the outcomes, not just in the acute phase but in the long term, although the knowledge is limited. For example, the 1995 Tokyo subway sarin attacks led to 11 deaths, and more than 5,000 persons required emergency medical evaluation.⁸ Immediate access to medical facilities, rapid decontamination, and availability of antidotes contributed to limiting casualties and long-term health effects. Even the 1987 mustard gas attacks on the Iranian Kurdish city of Sardasht, a city similar to Halabja, which killed an estimated 130 people and injured over 8,000, resulted in fewer casualties compared to Halabja, partly because there was at least some access to primary medical care and basic treatment.Reference Rabiee, Ghanei and Amini15 In contrast, the 1988 chemical attack on Halabja under conditions of limited medical preparedness, delayed evacuation, and poor access to treatment resulted in up to 5,000 deaths and around 10,000 injuries. Another example is the sarin attack on Ghouta on August 21, 2013, in Syria, which led to an estimated death toll of 1,144 and injured 5,000.Reference Moniz Bandeira and Moniz Bandeira16 The high casualty rate may be attributed to the very poor access to medical treatment and the lack of possibilities for evacuation, as the area was under siege at the time of the chemical attacks. A comparable example from the industrial sector is the 1984 Bhopal disaster in India, which killed over 3,000 people within days and caused long-term health effects in hundreds of thousands.Reference Murthy9 This highlights how lack of preparedness and inadequate medical infrastructure can increase the consequences of toxic chemical exposures.
Furthermore, studies on survivors of the Tokyo sarin attacks show a decline in long-term health complaints over time; researches on Halabja and Bhopal survivors indicate persistent or worsening health conditions in the years following exposure.
While the research and development of technologies for detecting CWAs has gained significant attention, studies on long-term health impacts of CWAs remain limited. Previous studies have documented an increase in self-reported health problems and reduced social functioning among populations residing near contaminated areas, suggesting that the ecological toxicity of these chemicals continues to affect residents over time.Reference Tanyanont and Vichit-Vadakan17, Reference Dworkin, Prescott, Jamal, Hardawan, Abdullah and Galea18
Despite international prohibitions, the threat posed by the development and use of chemical weapons persists and continues to undermine human security. However, progress in developing effective countermeasures is hindered by limited access to populations exposed to CWAs,Reference DeLuca, Chai, Goralnick and Erickson6 particularly within Western academic research communities, resulting in a notable gap in clinical research. This article aimed to discuss these gaps, particularly the lack of studies framed within the biopsychosocial model, a theoretical framework that explores the interconnections between physical symptoms, psychological burdens, and socioeconomic conditions in shaping patients’ quality of life.Reference Wenck, Van Sickle and Drociuk12, Reference Engel19–Reference Runkle, Zhang, Karmaus, Brock-Martin and Svendsen21 Moreover, there is a critical need to evaluate the current research approaches and to propose a roadmap for survivorship-centered studies that can guide future investigations and foster international collaboration. Strengthening regulations and improving global preparedness are essential to mitigate the persistent threat of CWAs.
International treaties have failed to prevent the use of CWAs in numerous regional conflicts, civil wars, and terrorist attacks, as well as in industrial incidents that caused mass casualties. This underscores the urgent need for effective medical countermeasures. However, ethical, legal, and humanitarian constraints prohibit experimental clinical research on CWAs in human subjects. Exposing healthy individuals to toxic and potentially lethal substances is universally deemed unethical and morally unacceptable. International frameworks such as the Chemical Weapons ConventionReference Thakur and Haru22 and the Geneva ProtocolReference Baxter and Buergenthal23 strictly prohibit the use of chemical weapons on humans, even for research purposes. From a humanitarian perspective, such exposure would violate fundamental rights to life, health, and dignity and would contravene the ethical standards outlined in the Declaration of Helsinki.Reference Salako24
The small number of known survivors living in Western countries also poses a significant challenge, rendering these individuals a “hard-to-reach” population for long-term studies. To overcome these limitations, it is imperative to study the thousands of Kurdish civilians in Iraqi Kurdistan who were exposed to CWAs, including mustard gas and nerve agents.Reference Moradi, Söderberg, Moradi, Daka, Olin and Lärstad25 These individuals, many of whom are now around 50 years of age, suffer high mortality rates due to the severity of their injuries. Studying civilian survivors from regions such as Iraqi Kurdistan, Iran, and Syria presents an ethically sound approach and practical opportunity to conduct structured, survivor-led research. Such studies could generate valuable findings while respecting ethical boundaries and contributing to the development of reliable and robust data.
In late May 2024, a conference held at Sulaimani University in Iraqi Kurdistan focused on genocide prevention and peacebuilding. It addressed the legacy of the Anfal military operations, during which CWAs were deployed against civilian populations. Presentations at the conference emphasized that these chemical attacks were not only historical atrocities but also ongoing public health crises with severe, enduring consequences. While several qualitative studies were presented, a significant gap in medical and quantitative research was evident.26
The chemical attacks on the city of Halabja and other regions of Iraqi Kurdistan in the late 1980s remain among the most tragic and well-documented instances of chemical weapons deployment against civilian populations in modern history.Reference Hilterman27 Documenting the long-term and far-reaching impacts of these attacksReference Moradi28 through comprehensive research is not only essential but also urgent. Such efforts are critical for achieving a more inclusive understanding of the enduring consequences of CWAs and for providing meaningful, sustained support to affected communities now and in the future. Previous studies have shown that survivors of CWAs exposure face a multitude of enduring challenges that persist decades after the initial incident. These include physical complications such as small airway damage potentially indicative of future respiratory risks like cancer,Reference Amini, Solaymani-Dodaran and Mousavi29 as well as persistent psychological illnesses and significant social burdens. Many survivors express uncertainty around marriage and family life, reflecting profound emotional and societal impacts. Additionally, survivors often face employment challenges, lower educational attainment, and experience stigma, discrimination, and social abandonment. These ongoing issues demonstrate the complex interconnected nature of the consequences of CWAs exposure, affecting nearly every aspect of survivors’ lives and underscoring their long-term vulnerability.Reference Moradi, Söderberg, Moradi, Daka, Olin and Lärstad25, Reference Moradi28–Reference Moradi, Moradi, Söderberg, Olin and Lärstad32
Although the immediate effects of CWAs exposure are well documented, there remains a critical gap in understanding the biopsychosocial complications that emerge over time. Although conducting comprehensive research on the effects of toxic chemicals on civilian survivors is essential for the classification, understanding, identifying, and addressing specific long-term impacts on physical, psychological, and socioeconomic factors, typically referred to as the biopsychosocial model,Reference Engel19 emerges many years following exposure to CWAs. Consequently, research on the effects of chemical weapons exposure in regions such as Iraqi Kurdistan and others regions in the Middle East holds significant implications for expanding our knowledge of the toxicological effects of these weapons, particularly among civilian populations, who are generally unprotected due to the absence of personal protective equipment against CWAs. Evidence-based research is also crucial for informing international legal frameworks, especially those concerning dual-use chemicals, and for holding perpetrators accountable for their actions. Moreover, investigating the socioeconomic consequences of toxic chemical exposure can help develop targeted support programs that address survivors’ long-term needs, while also promoting community resilience and recovery.Reference Dworkin, Prescott, Jamal, Hardawan, Abdullah and Galea18, Reference Snodgrass20, Reference Moradi, Moradi, Söderberg, Olin and Lärstad32
Another underexplored area is the long-term environmental contamination resulting from CWAs deployment. There is an urgent need for further research in this domain to guide public health interventions and decontamination strategies. Interventions may include health care provision, environmental remediation, and community-based rehabilitation programs. Such efforts can serve as the foundation for advocacy aimed at securing sustained international support and resources for affected populations in Halabja and other impacted regions.
To strengthen research, improve survivor care, and inform global preparedness, the following actions are recommended:
-
1. International Research Collaborations.
Establish collaborative studies among institutions in Iraqi Kurdistan, Syria, and Western academic centers to enhance data collection and create a centralized survivor database. This initiative would facilitate long-term clinical and observational research, strengthening preparedness for chemical incidents, and improve disaster response strategies. Research efforts should incorporate a gender-sensitive approach and address the broader social context beyond military frameworks.
-
2. Targeted Funding.
Encourage international bodies, including the EU, WHO, UNDP, and OPCW, to provide dedicated grants for research on the long-term biopsychosocial and ecosystem impacts of CWAs.
-
3. Environmental Decontamination.
Support scientific studies on the long-term environmental impacts of CWAs and fund the development of effective decontamination and rehabilitation strategies in contaminated areas.
-
4. Legal Restrictions on Dual-Use Chemicals.
Advocate for the OPCW to revise and expand the Chemical Weapons Convention to classify substances such as white phosphorus and pharmaceutical-based agents (e.g., aerosolized fentanyl) as controlled chemical weapons, tightening restrictions and oversight.
Conclusion
CWAs and dual-use chemicals remain a significant threat to global human security, not just limited to battlefields but also to civilian populations and the environment. The current lack of long-term, survivor-focused research continues to hinder the development of effective countermeasures. Clinical studies, particularly those conducted in regions such as Iraqi Kurdistan, Iran and Syria, are essential to bridge critical knowledge gaps. These efforts can improve survivor care, inform policy and legal responses, and contribute to global medical disaster preparedness.
Chemical weapons are among the weapons of mass destruction that have caused huge human casualties in the last century. Because of their easy manufacturing and accessibility, and despite international treaties, they remain a serious threat to global security, not just limited to military staff but also to civilian populations and the environment in the short and long term.
The military conflicts, global flows of weapons and rearmament, military escalations in Europe, the Middle East, and Asia have significantly increased the threat of chemical, biological, radiological, nuclear, and explosive (CBRNE) attacks. Both Russia and Ukraine have accused each other of deploying chemical warfare agents (CWAs), with some allegations reported to the Organisation for the Prohibition of Chemical Weapons (OPCW).1 While most members of the international community have ratified the Chemical Weapons Convention, it does not cover all potentially weaponized chemical agents. For instance, substances such as white phosphorus and pharmaceutical-based compoundsReference Hadjimatheou2 such as aerosolized fentanyl, used lethally in the 2002 Moscow theatre hostage crisis,Reference Riches, Read, Black, Cooper and Timperley3 are being developed with the capacity to inflict mass casualties. The situation in the Middle East is even more alarming due to the involvement of multiple parties. The destabilization of Syria, uncertainty surrounding its CWAs stockpiles, and the potential acquisition of CBRNE materials by jihadist and terrorist groups such as the Islamic State of Iraq and Syria (ISIS) further underscore the urgency for comprehensive global preparedness and coordinated mitigation strategies.Reference Rathore4–Reference DeLuca, Chai, Goralnick and Erickson6
Beyond CWAs, several chemicals widely used in civilian life have dual-use potential, serving both industrial and military purposes, highlighting the widespread risks associated with such substances.Reference Mahfoud, Aicardi, Datta and Rose7 For instance, chlorine, a common disinfectant in swimming pools, can be weaponized. Thiodiglycol, found in pen ink, is also a precursor for mustard gas, and organophosphates, which are widely used in agriculture, can be modified into nerve agents like sarin. The sarin gas was manufactured and used by a non-state organization in terrorist acts against civilians in 1994 and 1995 in Japan.Reference Sugiyama, Matsuoka and Sakamune8 Other notable industrial dual-use chemicals include the 1984 Bhopal gas tragedy in India, where methyl isocyanate leakage caused thousands of deaths and hundreds of thousands injuredReference Murthy9; the 1976 Seveso disaster in Italy,Reference Bertazzi and di Domenico10 which released toxic dioxins; the 2015 Tianjin explosions in China, resulting from improperly stored chemicalsReference Li and Tian11; the 2005 chlorine gas release from a train derailment in Graniteville, South CarolinaReference Wenck, Van Sickle and Drociuk12; the 2020 Beirut port explosion caused by improperly stored ammonium nitrateReference Al-Hajj, Dhaini, Mondello, Kaafarani, Kobeissy and DePalma13; and the recent April 26, 2025, chemical incident in Bandar Abbas, Iran,Reference Nilo Tabrizy, Torbati and George14 involving the release of toxic gases. These incidents collectively underscore the persistent and global threat posed by industrial and dual-use toxic chemicals. They also highlight the pressing need for stringent international regulations, robust legal frameworks, and comprehensive medical emergency preparedness.
The severity of effects following exposure to CWAs and toxic dual-use chemicals depends on multiple factors, including the type of agent, the route and duration of exposure, environmental conditions and protective barriers, but access to medical disaster preparedness and robust, sustainable health care services might significantly influence the outcomes, not just in the acute phase but in the long term, although the knowledge is limited. For example, the 1995 Tokyo subway sarin attacks led to 11 deaths, and more than 5,000 persons required emergency medical evaluation.⁸ Immediate access to medical facilities, rapid decontamination, and availability of antidotes contributed to limiting casualties and long-term health effects. Even the 1987 mustard gas attacks on the Iranian Kurdish city of Sardasht, a city similar to Halabja, which killed an estimated 130 people and injured over 8,000, resulted in fewer casualties compared to Halabja, partly because there was at least some access to primary medical care and basic treatment.Reference Rabiee, Ghanei and Amini15 In contrast, the 1988 chemical attack on Halabja under conditions of limited medical preparedness, delayed evacuation, and poor access to treatment resulted in up to 5,000 deaths and around 10,000 injuries. Another example is the sarin attack on Ghouta on August 21, 2013, in Syria, which led to an estimated death toll of 1,144 and injured 5,000.Reference Moniz Bandeira and Moniz Bandeira16 The high casualty rate may be attributed to the very poor access to medical treatment and the lack of possibilities for evacuation, as the area was under siege at the time of the chemical attacks. A comparable example from the industrial sector is the 1984 Bhopal disaster in India, which killed over 3,000 people within days and caused long-term health effects in hundreds of thousands.Reference Murthy9 This highlights how lack of preparedness and inadequate medical infrastructure can increase the consequences of toxic chemical exposures.
Furthermore, studies on survivors of the Tokyo sarin attacks show a decline in long-term health complaints over time; researches on Halabja and Bhopal survivors indicate persistent or worsening health conditions in the years following exposure.
While the research and development of technologies for detecting CWAs has gained significant attention, studies on long-term health impacts of CWAs remain limited. Previous studies have documented an increase in self-reported health problems and reduced social functioning among populations residing near contaminated areas, suggesting that the ecological toxicity of these chemicals continues to affect residents over time.Reference Tanyanont and Vichit-Vadakan17, Reference Dworkin, Prescott, Jamal, Hardawan, Abdullah and Galea18
Despite international prohibitions, the threat posed by the development and use of chemical weapons persists and continues to undermine human security. However, progress in developing effective countermeasures is hindered by limited access to populations exposed to CWAs,Reference DeLuca, Chai, Goralnick and Erickson6 particularly within Western academic research communities, resulting in a notable gap in clinical research. This article aimed to discuss these gaps, particularly the lack of studies framed within the biopsychosocial model, a theoretical framework that explores the interconnections between physical symptoms, psychological burdens, and socioeconomic conditions in shaping patients’ quality of life.Reference Wenck, Van Sickle and Drociuk12, Reference Engel19–Reference Runkle, Zhang, Karmaus, Brock-Martin and Svendsen21 Moreover, there is a critical need to evaluate the current research approaches and to propose a roadmap for survivorship-centered studies that can guide future investigations and foster international collaboration. Strengthening regulations and improving global preparedness are essential to mitigate the persistent threat of CWAs.
International treaties have failed to prevent the use of CWAs in numerous regional conflicts, civil wars, and terrorist attacks, as well as in industrial incidents that caused mass casualties. This underscores the urgent need for effective medical countermeasures. However, ethical, legal, and humanitarian constraints prohibit experimental clinical research on CWAs in human subjects. Exposing healthy individuals to toxic and potentially lethal substances is universally deemed unethical and morally unacceptable. International frameworks such as the Chemical Weapons ConventionReference Thakur and Haru22 and the Geneva ProtocolReference Baxter and Buergenthal23 strictly prohibit the use of chemical weapons on humans, even for research purposes. From a humanitarian perspective, such exposure would violate fundamental rights to life, health, and dignity and would contravene the ethical standards outlined in the Declaration of Helsinki.Reference Salako24
The small number of known survivors living in Western countries also poses a significant challenge, rendering these individuals a “hard-to-reach” population for long-term studies. To overcome these limitations, it is imperative to study the thousands of Kurdish civilians in Iraqi Kurdistan who were exposed to CWAs, including mustard gas and nerve agents.Reference Moradi, Söderberg, Moradi, Daka, Olin and Lärstad25 These individuals, many of whom are now around 50 years of age, suffer high mortality rates due to the severity of their injuries. Studying civilian survivors from regions such as Iraqi Kurdistan, Iran, and Syria presents an ethically sound approach and practical opportunity to conduct structured, survivor-led research. Such studies could generate valuable findings while respecting ethical boundaries and contributing to the development of reliable and robust data.
In late May 2024, a conference held at Sulaimani University in Iraqi Kurdistan focused on genocide prevention and peacebuilding. It addressed the legacy of the Anfal military operations, during which CWAs were deployed against civilian populations. Presentations at the conference emphasized that these chemical attacks were not only historical atrocities but also ongoing public health crises with severe, enduring consequences. While several qualitative studies were presented, a significant gap in medical and quantitative research was evident.26
The chemical attacks on the city of Halabja and other regions of Iraqi Kurdistan in the late 1980s remain among the most tragic and well-documented instances of chemical weapons deployment against civilian populations in modern history.Reference Hilterman27 Documenting the long-term and far-reaching impacts of these attacksReference Moradi28 through comprehensive research is not only essential but also urgent. Such efforts are critical for achieving a more inclusive understanding of the enduring consequences of CWAs and for providing meaningful, sustained support to affected communities now and in the future. Previous studies have shown that survivors of CWAs exposure face a multitude of enduring challenges that persist decades after the initial incident. These include physical complications such as small airway damage potentially indicative of future respiratory risks like cancer,Reference Amini, Solaymani-Dodaran and Mousavi29 as well as persistent psychological illnesses and significant social burdens. Many survivors express uncertainty around marriage and family life, reflecting profound emotional and societal impacts. Additionally, survivors often face employment challenges, lower educational attainment, and experience stigma, discrimination, and social abandonment. These ongoing issues demonstrate the complex interconnected nature of the consequences of CWAs exposure, affecting nearly every aspect of survivors’ lives and underscoring their long-term vulnerability.Reference Moradi, Söderberg, Moradi, Daka, Olin and Lärstad25, Reference Moradi28–Reference Moradi, Moradi, Söderberg, Olin and Lärstad32
Although the immediate effects of CWAs exposure are well documented, there remains a critical gap in understanding the biopsychosocial complications that emerge over time. Although conducting comprehensive research on the effects of toxic chemicals on civilian survivors is essential for the classification, understanding, identifying, and addressing specific long-term impacts on physical, psychological, and socioeconomic factors, typically referred to as the biopsychosocial model,Reference Engel19 emerges many years following exposure to CWAs. Consequently, research on the effects of chemical weapons exposure in regions such as Iraqi Kurdistan and others regions in the Middle East holds significant implications for expanding our knowledge of the toxicological effects of these weapons, particularly among civilian populations, who are generally unprotected due to the absence of personal protective equipment against CWAs. Evidence-based research is also crucial for informing international legal frameworks, especially those concerning dual-use chemicals, and for holding perpetrators accountable for their actions. Moreover, investigating the socioeconomic consequences of toxic chemical exposure can help develop targeted support programs that address survivors’ long-term needs, while also promoting community resilience and recovery.Reference Dworkin, Prescott, Jamal, Hardawan, Abdullah and Galea18, Reference Snodgrass20, Reference Moradi, Moradi, Söderberg, Olin and Lärstad32
Another underexplored area is the long-term environmental contamination resulting from CWAs deployment. There is an urgent need for further research in this domain to guide public health interventions and decontamination strategies. Interventions may include health care provision, environmental remediation, and community-based rehabilitation programs. Such efforts can serve as the foundation for advocacy aimed at securing sustained international support and resources for affected populations in Halabja and other impacted regions.
To strengthen research, improve survivor care, and inform global preparedness, the following actions are recommended:
1. International Research Collaborations.
Establish collaborative studies among institutions in Iraqi Kurdistan, Syria, and Western academic centers to enhance data collection and create a centralized survivor database. This initiative would facilitate long-term clinical and observational research, strengthening preparedness for chemical incidents, and improve disaster response strategies. Research efforts should incorporate a gender-sensitive approach and address the broader social context beyond military frameworks.
2. Targeted Funding.
Encourage international bodies, including the EU, WHO, UNDP, and OPCW, to provide dedicated grants for research on the long-term biopsychosocial and ecosystem impacts of CWAs.
3. Environmental Decontamination.
Support scientific studies on the long-term environmental impacts of CWAs and fund the development of effective decontamination and rehabilitation strategies in contaminated areas.
4. Legal Restrictions on Dual-Use Chemicals.
Advocate for the OPCW to revise and expand the Chemical Weapons Convention to classify substances such as white phosphorus and pharmaceutical-based agents (e.g., aerosolized fentanyl) as controlled chemical weapons, tightening restrictions and oversight.
Conclusion
CWAs and dual-use chemicals remain a significant threat to global human security, not just limited to battlefields but also to civilian populations and the environment. The current lack of long-term, survivor-focused research continues to hinder the development of effective countermeasures. Clinical studies, particularly those conducted in regions such as Iraqi Kurdistan, Iran and Syria, are essential to bridge critical knowledge gaps. These efforts can improve survivor care, inform policy and legal responses, and contribute to global medical disaster preparedness.
Acknowledgments
The author gratefully acknowledges Dr. Stefanie Bognitz for her valuable comments on the manuscript.
Competing Interests
The author has no competing interests to declare.