Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-2n9c9 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-17T12:22:08.111Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Allies or Antagonists? Philanthropic Reformers and Business Reformers in the Progressive Era1

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  13 January 2012

Nikki Mandell*
Affiliation:
University of Wisconsin–Whitewater
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

In the early twentieth century, amid heightening industrial tensions, many large corporations introduced welfare work to co-opt their employees' loyalties and pacify public anger. Many of the techniques and ideas of what became known as “welfare capitalism” were adapted from charity aid and settlement work. Over time, however, labor relations moved from being identified as a social reform issue—bound up with other issues on which the new profession of social work concentrated—to a business management prerogative. This article argues that professionalization played a significant role in these developments. Philanthropic reformers initially claimed welfare work as part of their professional agenda. However, in the second decade of the century, the social work profession began to narrow its field of operations. As social work's ambivalent claims on the factory and shop floor atrophied, business schools were introducing elements of industrial social work into their new management curriculums. The burgeoning field of professional labor management incorporated welfare work as one of its essential tools.

Information

Type
Essays
Copyright
Copyright © Society for Historians of the Gilded Age and Progressive Era 2012
Figure 0

Figure 1.“With the Social Secretary at the Pilgrim Steam Laundry.” Resting rooms such as this were precursors of later employee lounges. In the early twentieth century they were designed to promote more than employee rest. The décor, Victrola, and supervising welfare manager (social secretary) conjured the atmosphere of a sedate Victorian drawing room. The image of well-attired laundry workers, quietly reading books and magazines, projects a learned Victorian femininity habituated to familial harmony rather than class conflict. Source: Social Service, Oct. 1905, 119.

Figure 1

Figure 2.Mastheads from Social Service, published by the American Institute for Social Service (AISS), with the full cover of the July 1904 issue devoted to social secretaries. Whereas historians have emphasized philosophical and strategic differences between social-welfare and industrial-welfare reformers, the AISS's notion of social and industrial betterment presumed a commonality of purpose. The cover of Social Service carried the Allied Printers Trades Council union label, a reminder of workers' engagement in this project of social and industrial betterment.

Figure 2

Figure 3.“The American Institute of Social Service—One Corner of the Library or Social Laboratory,” United Charities Building. A second photograph captured researchers studying materials in the French section. Large posters brought back from the French exhibit at the Liege International Exposition in 1905 hang over the French section, visible reminders that an international movement shared the AISS conception of social welfare. Source: Social Service, Oct. 1905, 107.

Figure 3

Figure 4.New York School of Philanthropy, announcement of courses and lectures, winter 1905. The list of speakers in the third course of lectures, titled Constructive Social Work, suggests the school's construction of this emerging profession: housing (Veiller), social settlements (Addams, Glenn), municipal government (Allen), charity aid (Devine), corporate welfare work (Filene, Beeks, Hirschler), play and sport (Tabor), boy's and girl's clubs (Forbush, Potter). Source: Charities, Sept. 23, 1905, 1106.

Figure 4

Figure 5.Final Exam, Welfare Work course at the New York School of Philanthropy, 1911. Instructor: Edwin Pratt. The workplace-specific information provided in each company scenario, combined with the requirement that students assume the role of welfare worker, indicate that Pratt's goal was to prepare students to engage in this type of work. Welfare work was neither an idea to be examined at a distance nor a distasteful labor practice. Source: Historical File, 1899–1936, box 2, Columbia University School of Social Work, 1898–1999, RG4, Acc.00-009, Columbia University Archives.