Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-7pwfn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T08:34:22.982Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Voters’ Left–Right Perception of Parties in Contemporary Japan: Removing the Noise of Misunderstanding

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  10 February 2015

HIROFUMI MIWA*
Affiliation:
Graduate School for Law and Politics, University of Tokyo, and the Japan Society for the Promotion of Sciencemiwahirofumi@gmail.com
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The prevailing theory states that either Japanese voters have stopped ideologically distinguishing parties or that the main political parties in Japan have become more centrist in recent years. These arguments are based on survey questions asking citizens to locate parties on an ideological scale. However, these questions may suffer from noise caused by respondents who misinterpret the question wording or answer the questions inappropriately to mask their misunderstanding of the terms ‘left’ and ‘right’. To address this problem by extracting only the views of those who know the meaning of left–right terms, this article develops a mixture model. Applying the model to an opinion poll conducted after the 2012 Japanese general election, I confirm that those who comprehend the left–right terminology – slightly over half of all voters – largely perceived parties’ ideologies in the same way as experts. Additionally, I find that even these voters face difficulties in placing ambiguous or new parties on the political spectrum. This study has implications not only for understanding trends in Japanese political ideology, but also for survey design and analysis of heterogeneous survey responses.

Figure 0

Figure 1.Histograms of responses to the question on ideological perception in UTAS 2012 Notes: White bars on the far right show the non-response rate. Abbreviations of parties are as follows: DPJ, Democratic Party of Japan; LDP, Liberal Democratic Party; TPJ, Tomorrow Party of Japan; CGP, Clean Government Party (Komeito); JRP, Japan Restoration Party; JCP, Japanese Communist Party; YP, Your Party; and SDP, Social Democratic Party.

Figure 1

Figure 2.Answer sheet for UTAS 2012 question on ideological perception Note: This figure was created by the author based on the UTAS 2012 survey questionnaire. The original version was written in Japanese.

Figure 2

Figure 3.Predicted effects of changing explanatory variables in the first stage Notes: In each simulation, only one explanatory variable is varied, while fixing the other variables at their observed values. The predicted change in probability is calculated based on the logit model in the first stage, and the predicted change across all respondents is averaged. While all samples are used for simulations of ${\bf \zeta} $, only samples classified as uninformed respondents are used for simulations of ${\bf \eta}$ in each MCMC iteration. Selected values are 0 and 1 for dummy variables and the first- and third-quartile values for continuous variables. Dots denote posterior means, and horizontal lines are 95% HPD intervals.

Figure 3

Figure 4.Predicted ideological perception of the Liberal Democratic Party by grade evaluators Notes: The feeling thermometer for LDP was set at 0 (left panel), 50 (center panel), or 100 (right panel), the predicted probability of selecting each category was calculated based on the ordered logit model in the second stage, and the predicted change was average across all respondents. Dots denote posterior means and vertical lines are 95% HPD intervals.

Figure 4

Figure 5.Effect of proximity on the perceptions of informed respondents on the Democratic Party of Japan Notes: Respondents’ ideological self-identification were set at 1 (left panel), 3 (center panel), or 5 (right panel), and the feeling thermometer for the DPJ was set at 0 (black dots and lines) or 100 (gray dots and lines). The predicted probability of selecting each category was calculated based on the multinomial logit model in the second stage. Dots denote posterior means and vertical lines are 95% HPD intervals.

Figure 5

Figure 6.Results of classification Notes: The left panel shows the estimate of the composition ratio of the three groups. The black dot shows the posterior mean and the gray dots are composition ratios in each MCMC sample. The right panel shows the distribution of posterior probabilities of respondents’ types based on sampled ${\bf \kappa} _i$ and ${\bf \lambda} _i$ by semitransparent dots. Estimates from only 300 random samples are shown to improve figure clarity.

Figure 6

Table 1.Characteristics of the constituents of the classified groups

Figure 7

Figure 7.Predicted distributions of ideological perception for informed respondents Notes: The feeling thermometer and proximity were fixed at their observed values, the predicted probability was calculated based on the multinomial logit model in the second stage, and the predicted change was averaged across all respondents. Samples classified as informed respondents were used in each MCMC iteration. Differences between parties were derived from party-specific constants β. Solid lines denote posterior means of predicted probability and dashed lines denote distributions of the raw data for comparison. Shaded areas denote 95% HPD intervals. Abbreviations of parties are as follows: DPJ, Democratic Party of Japan; LDP, Liberal Democratic Party; TPJ, Tomorrow Party of Japan; CGP, Clean Government Party (Komeito); JRP, Japan Restoration Party; JCP, Japanese Communist Party; YP, Your Party; and SDP, Social Democratic Party. ‘1’ refers to the very left, and ‘5’ refers to the very right.

Figure 8

Figure 8.Parties’ left–right ideological location perceived by experts Notes: This figure shows the average left–right perception of parties by experts based on the expert survey conducted by Junko Kato after the 2012 election (Kato, 2014). Horizontal lines are 95% confidence intervals. Abbreviations of parties are as follows: JCP, Japanese Communist Party; SDP, Social Democratic Party; DPJ, Democratic Party of Japan; PLP, People's Life Party (the successor of TPJ); CGP, Clean Government Party (Komeito); YP, Your Party; LDP, Liberal Democratic Party; and JRP, Japan Restoration Party. ‘1’ refers to the very left, and ‘20’ refers to the very right.