This second edition of Rob Baggott's book has been revised and updated, reviewing public health challenges and strategies over the decade since it first appeared. There are extended accounts of the impact of globalisation and climate change (and the increasing influence on public health policy of international agencies), partnership working, essential for addressing the inter-sectoral nature of complex public health problems, and policies for improving the health of children and young people and for tackling inequalities in health.
The focus is on political debates surrounding public health and the often tortuous routes leading from awareness of a public health threat to policy formation and (sometimes) to policy implementation. It underlines the perennially contested nature of the boundaries of public health and forensically unpicks the political context of a plethora of policies and strategies related to population health.
Analysis is informed by three frameworks described at the outset: ideological perspectives, theories of risk and models of the policy process − returned to, albeit briefly, in the last chapter. The interplay between political ideologies and public, professional and corporate interests is traced from the Victorian era to the advent of the UK coalition government in 2010, and is also explored in detail for topics of public health relevance, ranging from climate change to illicit drugs. The book charts the blossoming of the ‘new public health’ in the 1970s and the changing fortunes, and often low morale, of a public health workforce subject to repeated NHS reorganisations, and uneasy relationships with primary care and local authority services, typically dominated by a concern with health care services and downstream interventions.
The main emphasis is on public health policy in England: the second edition describes numerous initiatives adopted by the Blair and Brown governments only to herald the abandonment by the coalition government of certain policies (such as traffic light approaches to food labelling), targets (including Local Area Agreements and Public Service Agreements) and organisations (including the Sustainable Development Commission). While an element of built-in obsolescence is unavoidable in policy analysis of this kind, certain themes endure: the public health function is to be reorganised once more and conflicts have re-emerged over the balance to be achieved between voluntary and regulatory approaches to public health challenges, such as alcohol misuse.
While the main focus is on public health strategy in England, there are summaries of approaches adopted in the devolved administrations (for example, in relation to public health nursing, partnerships, mental health promotion and health inequalities), a welcome reminder of the disparate approaches adopted in relation to health policy.
Chapters on public health services and lifestyle topics include reviews of epidemiological and other evidence: on occasions a discursive approach is adopted where an assessment of the methodological rigour of studies quoted or a review of the evidence base would be more appropriate. In the section on vaccination (in Chapter 8), it is noted, for example, that ‘the evidence base for vaccination has been challenged’, although references quoted for this statement largely refer either to specific vaccines for specific groups (rather than vaccination in general) or are personal accounts.
One of the difficulties facing commentators on public health is its all-encompassing nature: most policy areas (and many lifestyle choices) exert an impact on population health. In the same way, many occupations outside the health field can influence health, although their potential for doing so often remains unrealised. While there are arguments for bringing together so many topics in one text, not least the value of a compendium and reference guide to the political context of key public health strategies, there is a price to pay in terms of a loss of focus and perspective. For example, five ideological approaches relevant to public health strategy are identified at the outset. Paternalism, the liberal individualist perspective and collectivism are followed by the rather less iconic ‘Third Way’, while the final category combines both ‘green ideology’ and feminism but without a discussion either of eco-feminism or of social movements which could provide a link between them. Chapter 10 on ‘health and the environment’ spans a disparate group of topics, including accidents and violence, pollution policy and health in the workplace. Given the eclectic and contested nature of public health, a conceptual framework for inclusion or exclusion of potential topics is needed, and arguably the rationale for the choice and order of topics could be made more explicit. While Chapter 1 notes that equity in health is a key aspect of social justice, the WHO Commission on Social Determinants of Health (2008), an important text linking social justice, public policies and health, is not discussed in any detail until the penultimate chapter. The emphasis is on political debate and policy processes surrounding a series of topics related to public health rather than on developing an overarching framework or typology of the wide spectrum of policies with a potential impact on public health and health inequalities.
Despite these issues of balance, the depth of detail and comprehensiveness of this book make it an invaluable resource for students of public health and those interested in the political underbelly of public health policy.
