Part of Palgrave's ‘Theatre &’ series, Lucy Nevitt's Theatre & Violence is a cogent and comprehensive, yet approachable, investigation of violence and performance. Nevitt widens the scope of her book to encompass discussions of performance outside the theatrical realm as well as actual violence in the real world. As an introduction to the area of study, Nevitt grounds her discussion in precise and varied examples, including dramatic (predominantly British) plays, WWE wrestling, historical reenactments, video games and body art. She also situates her study amidst the academic theories of Judith Butler, Terry Eagleton, Adriana Caverero and others. The result is an in-depth analysis of the intersections and correlations of violence and performance, with emphasis on spectatorship, actuality and simulation, and ethical questions surrounding performed violence.
Nevitt cites two examples of witnessing violence – a scene from Sarah Kane's Blasted, and filmed footage of 9/11 – to prompt questions regarding real and simulated violence and the role of the spectator. These questions permeate the text, and Nevitt uses them to complicate causal arguments that suggest that simulated violence provokes acts of real violence. Paradoxically, she notes that simulated violent images can be more viscerally affective than real violent images due to their phenomenological immediacy.
Employing studies of performativity, Nevitt argues that simulated violence cannot be reduced to the visual act alone; attached to the performance are ideological and contextual implications that are manifested through the attitudes of the work. Analysing acts of violence not as what they are but what they do onstage, Nevitt cites different productions of Kane's Phaedra's Love to demonstrate how stylistic conventions and choices of productions guide the audience to specific experiences that are arguably as influential as the violence itself.
Stage combat, video games and body art are used to depict collisions between simulation and actuality. Video games collapse the spectator/performer distinction but performance artists like Mike Parr and Marina Abramović problematize the duality of real/pretend violence. Rather than discrete categories, Nevitt posits instead a continuum wherein performed violence is considered through its ideological ramifications.
Perhaps the most compelling part of the book is Nevitt's conclusion, which analyses actual acts of violence, including 9/11 and hunger strikes, through theories of performance. Interestingly, she discusses the embodiment of pain and suffering to argue for the value of performing violence onstage. Performance is able to tell a narrative and is thus able to embody pain instead of verbal descriptions. The role of spectators as witnesses allows them to engage with the pain through violence, and ‘experience the story themselves’ (p. 70).
Theatre & Violence acts as a persuasively written and accessible text arguing the value of performing violence onstage. Although Nevitt cites Yael Farber and Duma Kumalo's South African play He Left Quietly, drawing upon other international examples might have enriched her investigation. Nevertheless, she provides an insightful inquiry into the nature of violence and theatre.
