The title promises more than the book delivers. First, it is not a book on Amazigh arts in Morocco; it is a book primarily devoted to the description of weddings and marriage ritual among the Ayt Khabbash, a group of Ait Atta in the Tafilalet region of southeastern Morocco. Second, it is not a book about Berber identity; Amazigh identity and its symbolism are not specifically linked to gender but are shaped by a number of factors not examined in this book. The analysis lacks historical depth as well as political and economic dimensions. It also ignores the role and influence of Islam and religious ideology in the shaping of the mores and traditions the author attempts to present. All such factors are crucially important to understanding human relations in a region known for its extremely stratified society. From this book, the reader cannot form a clear picture of such a society.
Despite these deficits, the book offers excellent data and is obviously the result of close relationships over a period of time between the author and a number of Ayt Khabbash women. It also offers a welcome feminine perspective often lacking in anthropological studies about Morocco.
Cynthia Becker remarks in her introduction that “art, gender and ethnicity are the subject of this book” (p. 1). She gives primacy to the role that fertility and reproductive organs have in the comportment of Ayt Khabbash women and their artistic production, and she emphasizes this role often by the repetitive use of some key words throughout the book.
For the most part, she depicts marriage ritual in and around a village of the Tafilalet. Her book is solid when she describes those wedding ceremonies, the songs and dances around them, the brides' apparel and jewelry, and the customs that evolved around such events. The sole “artistic” activity described as being performed by the Ayt Khabbash women is that of weaving woolen mats and blankets, an activity on the brink of disappearance as sedentary life replaces nomadic pastoral existence. This does not constitute, and is far from constituting, a rich study of Amazigh arts in Morocco.
The author added a seventh chapter to the book on Amazigh and non-Amazigh Moroccan painters, who are, for the most part, male; the addition does not actually extend her prior study of a local Amazigh feminine artistic production to a national or international level. The chapter also fails to point to the wealth and variety of Amazigh arts in Morocco and elsewhere in Berber lands.
Becker argues at length that female fertility symbolism reigns throughout Amazigh arts. Such an argument is at best a limiting one. She does not situate the paucity of Ayt Khabbash textile production in the context of an overall richness of weavings coming out of various regions of the Berber land of Morocco. Some rugs produced by Amazigh women in the Atlas Mountains have achieved the status of international “art,” in opposition to the simple, local craft of making head coverings that Becker describes in the Tafilalet. She does not speak of the potters, wood carvers, metalworkers, and silversmiths who produce quality items throughout the Berber land of Morocco.
A few Moroccan studies of Amazigh traditions have detailed the formation of social categories in the region of the Tafilalet based on the control of water rights and agricultural resources and have explained how various ethnic groups relate to the land and those resources. In such recent studies, one can learn how the Ayt Khabbash invaded the region toward the end of the 19th century, confiscating most of the lands and property and establishing pacts of protection (tayessa) with local sedentary Arab groups. The more recent Arabization and Islamization of the whole region is minimized in Becker's depiction, which does not differentiate enough between Islamic practices and Amazigh traditions. One particular instance of such a lack of differentiation shocked me: weavings are said to have “soul,” which is translated as “rūḥ.” Here the author seems to offer as a Berber word one that is actually an Arabic word right out of the Qurʾan.
The region is also heavily inhabited by a group of Haratines who constitute the near totality (around eighty percent) of agricultural labor. Becker devotes a portion of her book to a category of dark-skinned people (Imskhan) who are considered descendants of former slaves from sub-Saharan regions and have adopted ways similar to those of the Ayt Atta although they are Arabic speakers. Yet she makes no mention whatsoever of the Haratines, a group of Saharan “free human beings” (ḥrār) who speak Berber and are an important element of the population of the Tafilalet. They are simply nonexistent in her book, a total cultural omission leaving a regrettable hole in the social tapestry she attempts to weave.
The book relates a personal and individual experience of a young American woman meeting with one aspect of the Amazigh world of Morocco, and it does that well. Given the scarcity of documentation on Amazigh life in the English language, it is an important testimony. Her central argument, however, that links the fertility power of Berber women to the maintenance of Amazigh ethnicity, although it surely has some validity, is overemphasized. She fails to analyze the extent of Islamic influence on dress, manners, and comportment of people living in an area known for its mixed culture. Finally, I expected far more on art, given the book's title, and was disappointed by the absence of information on many aspects of the rich Amazigh artistic production in Morocco.
