Marlène Laruelle has clearly established herself as the foremost Western expert on the Eurasian idea. Most of Russian Eurasianism will quickly establish itself as the indispensible English-language historigraphical text on the subject. What will not stand as well is her attempt to maintain the title's argument that Eurasianism is an ideology of Russian imperialism. Indeed, by page 2 of the introduction, she is already posing three irreconcilable questions about the nature of the Eurasianist idea: is it Russian, is it more broadly post-Soviet, or is it an even broader phenomenon of the cultural fundamentalism she thinks has been resurgent since the end of the Cold War?
These questions are all excellent, but in the end she skirts them in favor of the historian's penchant for detail at the expense of risking explanation and getting it wrong—or at least only partially right.
What follows in the first two chapters is a kind of summary of her earlier works on the subject, of which Russian Eurasianism is the final part. These earlier works, appearing in French under the titles L'idéologie eurasiste russe, ou, Comment penser l'Empire (1999) and Mythe aryen et rêve impérial dans la Russie du XIXe siècle (2005), give a sense of the vastness and uncategorizable nature of the subject. This difficulty in establishing a clear pathway through a subject with so many side roads is the central weakness of the book. Its attempt to proffer up an argument about the imperial nature of the Eurasianist movement (which, she acknowledges readily, was really a series of such movements stretching back to Peter the Great's attempt to redraw the map of what constituted Europe) only loosely adheres.
Chapter 1 focuses on the interwar exile movement's most important precursors to the present generation of Eurasianist ideologues. The central problem posed for this group was the impasse faced by the intelligentsia-in-exile as they grappled with their own personal identities in the midst of both physical exile and the metaphysical let-down of the failure of the 1905 and 1917 revolutions to establish what they saw as a suitable national identity. Therefore, personal and national identity becomes one theme. As she shows in her 2005 Mythe aryen, the movement takes on a fin de siècle eschatological and racial tone. It also splits into two groups.
One, the “idealists” promoted a literary, philosophical exploration of the idea of Eurasia. In contrast the “realists” wanted a politically engaged movement that would address the subsequent evolution of the new Soviet experiment. Here her scholarship on the internecine battles between the editors of the main Eurasianist journals, Evraziiski, Versty, Put', and others is absolutely comprehensive. The fine grain of her accounts is astounding, but also exhaustive—in the sense that it will tire all but the most committed reader. Yet there is no doubt that her command of this kind of historical element is what makes this single-volume work the indispensible reference on the subject.
Her next chapters are organized around the pantheon of figures making up the contemporary movement. Chapter 2 looks at Lev Gumilëv and his theory of “ethnogenesis.” Gumilëv's theory is that “ethnoi” emerge from bursts of energy “coming from the creatures that inhabit the surface of the earth” (66), including geological and mineral activity (whatever that means—Laruelle never quite explains) and the additional circulation of energy among plants, animals, and the sun. We also get some of the most impenetrable prose of the book in this section.
By way of an explanation of Gumilëv's extended theories, we get “Chance is but a disturbance of the higher logic of nature, and any contradiction must be overcome through a dialectic principle of the synthesis of opposites” (61). This is simply academese at its worst, even if it is in translation. Large sections of the book read this way—it is as if Laruelle has been so immersed in the language of Marxist-Leninist science that she cannot extricate herself from its contorted argot. Perhaps this is why the dust jacket blurb from John Dunlop of the Hoover Institution says the importance of the book is found in its extraordinary depth of scholarship. Indeed. But what goes unsaid speaks volumes.
She continues the biographical structure with chapters on the other two key figures in the contemporary, or neo-Eurasianist, movement. Much has already been written on Alexander Panarin and even more on the ubiquitous Alexander Dugin, both by Laruelle and others. Panarin and Dugin form the heart of the imperial thesis. Laruelle dutifully provides the reader a full recounting of Panarin's theory of civilization.
For Panarin, the separating factor between civilization and primordialism is religion. Of course, religion is broadly understood in the Tocquevillian sense of mores. Nonetheless, because post-Soviet Russia has emerged as a deeply Orthodox state, it is Russia that is poised to be the center of a resurgent Eurasian empire despite the large and nominally Muslim population along its southern rim. Both religions share central ideals of asceticism, which set them apart from the industrial, consumerist West.
Dugin represents the living, leading edge of the Eurasianist movement today. He has produced a whirlwind of pamphlets, TV shows, books, journals, and websites. His The Foundation of Geopolitics (1997) outlines a very predictable melding of Sir Halford Mackinder's works on geopolitics, Alfred Thayer Mahan's The Influence of Sea Power upon History, 1660–1783, and the Nazi theorist Carl Schmitt's ideas of “rimland” and “heartland.” From this he syncretizes a worldview not unlike Samuel Huntington's The Clash of Civilizations.
Put plainly, Eurasia occupies the heartland space of the steppe regions between the great bowl of mountains formed variously by the Carpathians, Alps, Caucasus, Altai, Himalayas, and the jagged eastern highlands of Russia. Inside this rim, a distinctly Eurasian culture formed (whether by ethnogenesis, religious tradition, or geopolitical history) that is neither Asian nor Western (“Atlanticist” as Dugin calls it). Dugin's importance is buttressed by the impression that he is wielding a central influence on the Putin government (at the book's writing, but no less so under President Medvedev one assumes). Laruelle traces much of Dugin's philosophy to the ideas of the traditionalist thinkers of (again) the 1920s, in particular the formalization of it under René Guénon. Only for Dugin the traditional is not Guénon's early Catholic phase, but a “clericalization [otserkovlenie] of everything” (124).
Finally, Laruelle steps outside Russia to expose a form of “panturanic” Eurasianism, which is mostly confined to Kazakhstan and a few writers in Turkey. In itself, this begs the question of whether Eurasianism is a Russo-centric imperial philosophy. However, the paucity of the Kazakh and Turkic contributions to the Eurasianist narrative makes it plain that they are fringe elements, at best.
Laruelle begins the book by portraying it as a study of nationalism in a constructivist context (12). What bedevils her throughout is that she is inevitably dealing with personalities that are largely trying to hide the constructivist nature of their projects under the guise of primordialist approaches. But Laruelle never makes this point explicit, and it binds her into writing a valuable history, but a markedly less valuable exegesis of this movement's political meaning. She ends with a claim with which she should have begun: Eurasianism, especially in its contemporary forms, uses cultural fundamentalism as “a way to avoid politics” (222). That theme should have been enunciated from the beginning and brought out through the brilliant historical examples she gives us.
This is really a book about a philosophical system. What we get instead is an account that mostly focuses on the biographies and personality clashes of the major figures of twentieth-century Eurasianism. What we do not get is an answer to the political question of whether or not it is, in fact, the basis for a serious ideology of empire. In a sense, the book ends where it started, describing a group of thinkers undecided between political and literary approaches.
