Writing biography is already difficult, but as the author notes in her foreword, it is more difficult and sometimes even impossible in the Middle East. The respect that must be shown to the subject, the belief that secrets should not be revealed, the tradition of not leaving any documents behind, and the subjective narrations of acquaintances are all hindrances. Academic biographies, which in Turkey generally have been limited to politicians, are penned usually to either defend or criticize the subject. Their quality and objectivity is debatable, and most are poorly written.
Celal Bayar, the second prime minister and third president of the Republic of Turkey, is a politician whose career spanned the transition from the Ottoman Empire to the Republic. He has been the subject of many studies, but few of high academic standard. Nurşen Mazici's Celal Bayar: Başbakanlīk Dönemi (1996) is one, but it deals only with the years when Bayar served as prime minister.
Politicians in Turkey generally neither write their memoirs nor keep diaries. The exception to the rule is İsmet İnönü, the second president of Turkey. Bayar wrote memoirs, but only a small collection has been published (Ben de Yazdim, 8 volumes, 1965–72), and it treats only his early years, through the beginning of the National Independence War. He probably wrote these memoirs after his term as prime minister, when he was not politically active. His later political adventures must have prevented him from continuing. His other memoir is his journal about life in prison with the legendary prime minister Adnan Menderes after the military coup of 27 May 1960 (Kayseri Cezaevi Günlüğü, 1999).
Dawletschin-Linder is the first academic to undertake Celal Bayar's biography. The author reconciles Bayar's life with the socioeconomic, political, and cultural phases of the late Ottoman and Republican eras, utilizing all possible sources. She makes use of not only Turkish archives but also German and British archives, all of which are being used in this manner for the first time.
The author begins by describing the milieu into which Bayar was born and his childhood. Bayar was introduced to political activity at an early age. He joined the Committee of Union and Progress while employed in a German Bank in Bursa and rose through party ranks. Right after the Committee of Union and Progress seized power in the summer of 1908 with a coup, he went to Izmir, a rather different city from Bursa.
Bayar's devotion to Unionist belief and policies during the World War I years led him to be at the very front of Turkey's subsequent struggle for independence under Kemalist leadership in Ankara. Bayar's major leap during the republican era was his gaining Atatürk's trust and becoming the general director of Īş Bankasi; in this capacity and later as a government minister, he became the brains of Turkey's economy. Prime Minister İnönü, who looked askance at Bayar's quick rise under Atatürk, was unable to stop this appointment. Despite their different economic views, Inönü and Bayar wound up having to work together for many years. Atatürk finally defined Bayar as the second most important politician of the country as a consequence of his disputes with İnönü and appointed him as prime minister.
Due to Atatürk's death, Bayar held this position only a short time, and his competition with Inönü continued. At the end of World War II, Bayar again found a place in the foreground of politics as chairman of the opposition Democratic Party. Unfortunately, the author only briefly mentions these short-lived but very difficult opposition years.
Bayar, who became the third president of Turkey in 1950, is the symbol of the ten-year Democratic rule. Much has been written about the ruling period of the Bayar and Menderes duo, and Dawletschin-Linder treats this era in detail. Internal and external political developments of the period, and Bayar's role in them, cover a large part of the book.
Like many members of the Democratic Party, which fell from power after the May 1960 military coup, Bayar was tried by a special tribunal and sentenced to death. He served time, was pardoned, and, through the efforts of his longtime nemesis, İnönü, had his political rights restored. He remained a prestigious figure in the Democratic Party until his death, although his impact in politics eventually diminished as new actors came to dominate Turkish politics.
The author highlights Bayar's political role “at the service of his state” both in power and opposition. The “spirit of the Unionist tradition”—from his early days as member of a secret revolutionary committee—formed the basic core of Bayar's political identity. His unbowed stand before the court after the military coup, in contrast to Menderes, exemplifies this. This attitude of putting the state first affected the spirit of the Democratic Party that he founded. Unfortunately, the author does not dwell on these issues enough.
Dawletschin-Linder presents the material in a very matter of fact manner. She has utilized all the major sources, however limited they may be, and places Bayar's life within the overall political history of Turkey. Her critical approach to Bayar is satisfactory. The long life story, one that spans the last era of the Ottoman Empire throughout much of the republican era, is balanced in coverage. The book presents little information that will be new to a reader familiar with the subject but blends existing information into a synthesis of high academic quality.
