In his recent review of my book, Parable and Politics in Early Islamic History, in the August 2011 issue of IJMES, Fred Donner provides several opinions that are in need of correction. His initial impression that the “basic point of Parable and Politics” follows previous scholarship “in an attempt to work out how much is ‘fact’ and how much is literary invention” (p. 570) sets the wrong tone for evaluating studies on historiography. Far from being merely an opposition between true and false, the study of “fiction” in historiography is actually an analysis of construction not of truthfulness. The complexity of doing this lies in reaching for a multifaceted commentary that was originally intended not only in the individual reports but also through a process of intertextuality, which casts implications on a range of issues and on the representation of characters across a cluster of reports.
This error in regard to the aim and method of allusive reading is common among many who use the terms “narrative” and “report” interchangeably and lump all types of skeptical approaches to Islamic history into the same category. Donner's aforementioned comment is worth noting in full, however, for its additional caveats: “the basic point of the book Parable and Politics is not entirely new, of course. A number of earlier scholars have explored the literary shaping of various figures in early narrative reports in an attempt to work out how much is ‘fact’ and how much is literary invention.” He then cites two works on the life of the Prophet, by Tor Andrae and Uri Rubin, a book by E. L. Petersen on ʿAli and Muʿawiya, and a recent publication in 2008 by Khaled Keshk (Donner's student) on Muʿawiya and then hedges, “but El-Hibri's treatment is vastly more detailed and convincing than any so far dedicated to the rāshidūn.”
To read this introduction, one would imagine that critical biographies of the Rashidun caliphs have long been coming in abundance. Donner's comment seems to confuse the topic of the early caliphs with critical biographies of the Prophet, which have been significantly more available. An implicit distortion in comparing studies on the sīra with those on the Rashidun, however, is the suggestion that the same rules of skepticism apply to both. But while skepticism about the sīra should be obvious because of its miraculous nature, one may ask what kinds of miracles characterize the lives of the caliphs that would make historians skeptical. Had the works of Andrae and Petersen been inspirational or applicable to other phases of Islamic history, surely Wilferd Madelung would have held back from writing his famous synthetic history of the Rashidun, The Succession to Muhammad: A Study of the Early Caliphate (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1997), and Professor Donner himself would have found reason to write his much noted book on the first four years of the Islamic conquests with less credulity (The Early Islamic Conquests [Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press, 1981]). The reality in the field is that the history of the caliphs has not been subjected to sustained skepticism (biblical or literary) by medieval historians such as Donner, Hinds, Kennedy, Bosworth, and Crone (as per her God's Caliph: Religious Authority in the First Centuries of Islam [Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1986]) because the caliphal period is full of realistic information on leaders’ motives, policy decisions, and the motions of political and military history. That some previous critics have paved the way for my approach to the sources is of course true (and I have credited this in the preface and explained it in my previous book as well), but there are many names I would consider as having qualitatively advanced the field in method before I would get to listing the ones Donner favors. The reviewer could have done the general readership of IJMES a service by listing predecessors such as Stefan Leder, Albrecht Noth, John Wansbrough, Marilyn Waldman, and Jacob Lassner, not to mention outsiders to the field such as Robert Alter, Northrop Frye, and Hayden White.
Another pitfall in the review occurs when Donner wrongly surmises that the book argues for “no salvageable historical information in the narratives” (p. 571) and finds it difficult to draw the line between commentary on depiction versus commentary on what people actually said or did. This is a clichéd criticism usually made by traditional historians who seem to want a constant disclaimer of credulity in anecdotal literature and misread the potential for certain historical facts. It should probably be reaffirmed nevertheless that all is not invention. Certain key events must have happened, but the stories about them are largely fictitious. Expert readers of historiography are able to discern a rough boundary where history ends and literary embellishment begins even if those unexposed to the craft of stories may find the issue one of stark contrast.
