While avowing his concern for the “scholarly reputation of IJMES,” Michael Gunter is denouncing my lack of “common sense” and my “audacity to argue incongruously” in the debate about the general validity of the Naim-Andonian documents. To substantiate his argument Gunter once more resorts to the method of truncation through deletions; the essential part of my phrase is deliberately excised from the quotation he used. Here is the full text in question, with the deleted portion in italics:
Forgery presupposes skill, caution, and above all a measure of sophistication geared to avoiding mistakes. The presence and easy detection of such defects in the material under review mitigate against the charge [of forgery]. Indeed, no forger of any value would have produced material, so incomplete and so flawed with glaring imperfections; these could have been easily avoided by anyone disposed to forge.
Accordingly, if scholarly reputation should be made the central issue, the question that poses itself here is, Whose reputation is, in fact, at stake?
