Angus Fletcher can kill a joke stone-cold dead. But that is not his fault—if writing comedically is difficult, writing comedically about comedy is well-nigh impossible. And when one attempts to do so syncretically and over a two-millennium history, little room is left for the actual funny stuff. Given those limitations, Fletcher has wisely chosen to track humor's effects; he traces these effects across the political history of the West (with particular attention to ancient Greece, modern England, and the United States) rather than trying to develop a theory of political humor or attempting to replicate what has drawn audiences to satirists from Aristophanes to John Oliver—which is to say, Fletcher takes humor very seriously. By doing so, he is able to outline long lines of political work and humorous writing and to note some startling convergences among them.
This differs from the more common question of “how comedy works,” a probably unanswerable complexity upon whose shoals other analysts have foundered. In the contemporary ethno-nationalist world, comedy would seem to offer today's democracy very little. Satire appears toothless in the face of radical racialism; parody offers little leverage against totalitarian tendencies. Yet the unpleasant nature of the particular limitations of representational politics offers hope for Fletcher, as it may lead us back to what made comedy so efficacious in the first place.
Fletcher warns that the electoral model of democracy has become sclerotic and insufficient. While it purports to represent a unified will of “the people” through a commitment to constitutional norms expressed by occasional ballots, in truth its formal commitments have limited and constrained the democratic potential of politics. Fletcher suggests an alternative, an older and more robust concept of democracy, taken from the Greeks, which draws on the “practical dimensions” (18) of Athenian democracy. The ethos of such a demokratia, he convincingly shows, shares considerable overlap with a successful comedic form.
Primary among these overlaps is a set of attitudes toward authority, traditions, unity, and problem solving. Comedy punctures the first, destabilizes the second, pluralizes the third, and pragmatizes the last. From its oldest written form, the comic foil is committed to the systemization and rationalization of the world, only to find himself (all of the book's examples are male) tripped up by the vagaries of human nature and the world. Comedy, Fletcher argues, provides a much more robust and equitable series of approaches, in which a successful hero must recognize the multiple points of view and practical workings of the universe in order to navigate it with a minimum of humiliation. Such an approach, not coincidentally, underpins truly successful democratic approaches.
Old Comedy—which Aristophanes embodies, defines, and brings to its conclusion—plays a central role in this analysis. The temporal and geographic coincidences between this dramatic form and working demokratia are unlikely to be accidental. But Fletcher avoids the presumptions of a causal mechanism; rather than democracy's emerging from humor or vice versa, he asserts, it is more probable that it takes a similar mindset to produce, enjoy, and reinforce both. To laugh at yourself, a skill of both George Washington and Abraham Lincoln, closely connects to the ability to see yourself as others see you, rather than assuming that the world reflects your own self-perceptions.
Fletcher addresses wide-ranging and various comedic writers, including Euripides, Menander, Cervantes, Fielding, and Shadwell. Less convincingly, he includes Shakespeare, Congreve, and Douglass. For Shakespeare's comedic ability, Fletcher surprisingly turns to the latter Henry plays; Falstaff may well be a funny figure who teaches the audience something about leaders and followers, but the kings Henry lack the joyous admixtures of A Midsummer Night's Dream or The Tempest, let alone the pure madcap foolery of the marriage comedies. His argument for Machiavelli as an author steeped in the comic proves more robust: moments when slaves become masters in La Mandragola, for example, show the political realism that more idealistic renditions of politics miss.
Also questionable is Fletcher's inclusion of Aḥmad il-Fār, a relatively little known (at least outside of turn-of-the-century Cairo) playwright and actor. Though he could have discussed more commonly referenced examples of Islamic humor (e.g., the common stories of Ashʿab, the eighth-century entertainer), Fletcher chooses instead a farce that he can contrast to G. B. Shaw's John Bull, both of which address the historical specificity of British colonization. In some ways, the comparison is inapt: though many non-theater-goers would read a Shaw play, il-Fār's 1909 work was solely performative, published only in the late twentieth century when the original actors’ script was discovered in a Dutch library. But insofar as il-Fār addresses politicized citizenry, evoking an Egyptian everyman in a comically rebellious mood, his play does point to the potential distilling of laughter's affective power.
The form itself proves important, too, and Fletcher is best when embedded in the genre he clearly knows and loves: theater. As the birthplace of our idea of comedy, the stage literally embodies its figures. Unlike the tragic tradition, which destroys its flawed protagonist, the comedic chastens and humiliates its own figures repeatedly, but ultimately leaves them standing and fully human. This focus on the theater likely explains the relative absence of authors such as Chaucer, Swift, or Twain. But it also means that Fletcher stretches when finding the comedy in nontheatrical forms. For an audience member to “laugh some” with Frederick Douglass (131) or have “chuckled ruefully” with Caleb Bingham (121) is a far cry from the riotous hilarity that Aristophanes, Shakespeare, and Stoppard provoke.
None of these absences, however, detract from the force of the book's central insight that a comedic sensibility is critical to demokratia. Political theory loves the tragic: its splendor, its moral certainty, its central concern with justice. Fletcher points us toward another critical and capacious tradition, and we would do well to follow. Especially in times of high seriousness, the comedic proves potent. Comic Democracies invites its readers to note the leaders and people who are willing and able to laugh, with and at themselves, and take them as seriously—more seriously, even—than those filled with grandiosity and self-serving conviction. Our political life may depend upon it.
