Diego A. von Vacano begins his interesting new book by observing that race, though clearly and deeply relevant to politics, has not been satisfactorily understood by European and American political theorists. Thus, he turns to Latin American political thought, whence he derives a concept of race that serves as both a more cogent description of reality and a more attractive framework for normative analysis. In the process, he leads us through Spanish American intellectual history, providing introductions to four influential figures: Bartolomé de Las Casas, Simón Bolívar, Laureano Vallenilla Lanz, and José Vasconcelos. Both the theoretical and historical contributions of The Color of Citizenship are valuable, as is its innovative comparative approach.
Latin America, von Vacano argues, has furnished a uniquely fertile setting for thinking about race. He isolates among the region's several conceptions of race a “synthetic paradigm”: “a mode of thinking about the phenomenon of race and its tributaries in a way that eludes fixed, rigid notions” in favor of “those which are mixed and fluid” (p. 16). The synthetic paradigm differs from both the “domination paradigm” prominent in European thought, which arranges different races in a hierarchy topped by Europeans, and the “dualistic paradigm” predominant in Anglo-American thought, which even in its more egalitarian versions focuses on the binary of white and nonwhite. Von Vacano's paradigm is “synthetic” in several senses. Substantively, it positions racial mixture as the norm and treats race as artificial or illusory, a social construction rather than a biological fact. Methodologically, it incorporates a Hegelian account of the historical development of racial thinking, with successive formulations responding to and resolving the antinomies of their predecessors.
The original race “thesis” appears in the writings of Las Casas, an early colonial-era Dominican friar and court-appointed defender of the New World's indigenous peoples. Against the belief that Native Americans were insensati, subhuman creatures incapable of reason and thus naturally fit for Spanish rule, Las Casas insisted that though “essentially different from Europeans,” the Indians were “still within the human race and not necessarily inferior” (p. 34). This “proto-racialist” account of somatic and cultural variation within a universal humanity formed the cornerstone of his “paradoxical” simultaneous support for Spanish imperial expansion and critique of the conquest. Although Las Casas famously denounced the conquistadors' abuses of Native Americans, he nonetheless supported Spanish imperial expansion as a means of spreading the Catholic faith.
“Antithesis” arrives with the independence movements and ensuing state-building efforts, embodied in the discourses of Bolívar, the revolutionary ideologue, military commander, and founding father of several South American states, and in the writings of Vallenilla, a Venezuelan sociologist and philosophical positivist sympathetic to the early-twentieth-century dictatorship of Juan Vicente Gómez. In von Vacano's account, both Bolívar and Vallenilla rejected Las Casas's imperialism, the former as a republican and the latter as a nationalist. But both shared and elaborated upon Las Casas's synthetic racial thinking. Bolívar “saw the Latin American person [as] an entity in whom coalesced indigenous, European, and African lines of descent” (p. 57), while Vallenilla refuted pseudoscientific theories of degeneracy resulting from racial mixing. Von Vacano shows that for Bolívar and, following him, for Vallenilla, Latin America's racial heterogeneity posed a challenge to stable self-government and economic development. Both defended political centralization and strong executive authority as means of meeting this challenge.
Finally, “synthesis” is achieved by Vasconcelos, a postrevolutionary Mexican bureaucrat, educator, and writer, whose support for pan–Latin American unity combined elements of Las Casas's universalism with Bolívar's and Vallenilla's particularism. Von Vacano argues that Vasconcelos's well-known Raza Cósmica, usually treated as a political celebration of mestizaje, was in fact a “consequence of his philosophical aesthetics” (p. 113). For Vasconcelos, Latin America's history of racial mixing indicated its progress toward an era when taste would replace reason, and nation-states would give way to looser federations of diverse peoples drawn together in search of beauty. Von Vacano expands upon Vasconcelos's connection between racial and aesthetic categories, using a short excursus on Nietzsche to argue that “[r]ace and racialization are coeval with modernity … tied to the gradual incorporation of an aesthetic lens to make sense of the world … as modern flux, change, uncertainty, and disorder appear out of the discovery of new ways of living, new technologies, and new peoples” (p. 137).
Whether readers come to this book with a primary interest in the concept of race or in the history of Latin American political thought, they will find von Vacano's reflections original and insightful. They may encounter some difficulty, though, in drawing these two themes together. The author's argument for the superiority of the synthetic paradigm, vis-à-vis its European and Anglo-American counterparts, is cogent and convincing, but its relation to the historical account of racial thinking in Latin America that he provides is unclear. At some points, he seems to suggest that each of the figures he discusses thought within the synthetic paradigm; at others, that this paradigm only emerges with Vasconcelos; and at still others, that the “synthetic paradigm is this arc of intellectual history” as a whole (p. 155; emphasis added). Alongside this ambiguity, there is some tension between von Vacano's claims that the synthetic paradigm is a “definition of race that can have validity across space and time” (p. 19) or “a theoretical, not an ideological, apparatus” (p. 155) and his insistence that, like any other racial paradigm, the synthetic paradigm “must be understood in particular historical contexts and is largely shaped by political factors” (p. 144).
Moreover, von Vacano's exegeses are not uniformly convincing. His reading of Bolívar, in particular, raises several questions. In order to present Bolívar as an expositor of the synthetic paradigm, the author relies heavily upon a single passage that appeared twice in Bolívar's writings. In both his 1815 “Jamaica Letter” and his 1819 “Discourse at Angostura” Bolívar described the difficulties he and his fellow Spanish American patriots faced by noting that “[w]e are neither Indian nor European but a species midway between the legitimate proprietors of this country and the Spanish usurpers.” Von Vacano draws our attention to Bolívar's use of the term species, arguing that it signals Bolívar's intention to describe “a categorically new sort of people that emerges out of the mix of native Americans and Spaniards,” and reveals an “implicitly ‘biological’ … not merely cultural” understanding of how European and Indigenous peoples mixed in Latin America (pp. 60–61). But neither of these points is obvious. The Spanish term especie does not carry the biological connotations of its English cognate. It can convey “kind” or “type” as well as “species.” In fact, later in the “Discourse,” Bolívar uses the same term when he describes Athens as “the most brilliant example of an absolute democracy, and the most melancholy demonstration of the weakness of this kind of government [esta especie de gobierno]” (Obras Completas, 1950, III: 683). Thus, we could read the passage above not as a description of Latin America's racially mixed population, but rather the distinctive social position occupied by Bolívar and other criollo leaders of the independence movement. The next sentence, where he elaborates upon his point by noting that “being Americans by birth, and Europeans by right [Americanos por nacimiento, y nuestros derechos los de Europa] we are forced to dispute the claims of the Natives and resist the invasion of Foreigners,” seems to support this alternative (ibid., III: 676).
Von Vacano's presentation of Bolívar as a straightforwardly anti-imperial counterpoint to Las Casas is equally problematic. It is true that Bolívar made famous and ultimately successful efforts to dismantle the Spanish American empire, but he was also wont to “liberate by force” any communities whose patriotic fervor did not match his own (ibid., III: 541). In addition, he consistently sought, peacefully and otherwise, to unify ever more expansive portions of South America under a single government (ibid., II: 363–66). Thus, it would be difficult to conclude that Bolívar's political and philosophical relationship to empire was any less fraught than was Las Casas's.
Despite these issues, von Vacano makes many worthwhile contributions. The Color of Citizenship is an original intervention into ongoing debates on the concept of race, an important new account of Latin American political thought, and a welcome invitation to comparative political theory.
