I worked for this money and I'm going home.
Mexican migrant worker Francisco Medrano
Work, money and home: three concepts, sometimes contested, sometimes entangled, sometimes in outright opposition, which together form the backbone of Deborah Cohen's expansive, detailed and engaging study of post-war migrant labour. Braceros, literally those lending their arms to the United States, were Mexican migrant workers who operated under a scheme sponsored by both governments and managed by politicians, bureaucrats and law enforcement agents on either side of the border. The bracero programme ran from 1942 to 1964 and was in some ways similar to the German Gastarbeiter system. Cohen's book reveals the vast scope, the contradictory aims and the inconsistent operation of the scheme, analysed at a structural level but, crucially, illustrated with rich personal testimonies. It is a nuanced, post-revisionist account that successfully engages with a panoply of issues including machismo, masculinity, class and the experiences of labourers in a transnational context.
Cohen reconstructs scenes which seem incredible in the current context of anti-migrant bigotry and institutionalised discrimination across the US south-west. In 1948, for instance, and again on a larger scale in 1954, the frontier gates were flung open at the behest of the US agricultural sector in its hunger for cheap labour. The Mexican government found it extremely difficult to deal with this situation and in the latter case resorted to bribery to disperse the crowds of would-be migrants, promising work in northern Mexico along with highly targeted land reform. An asymmetric battle for labour was being fought between an economic powerhouse (which at the time could afford to accuse its neighbours of protectionism) and a corrupt, authoritarian regime which depended for its legitimacy on the plausible improvement of its subjects' material conditions. This asymmetry was not merely economic. Once the hemispheric spheres of influence were defined following the Second World War, Mexico's ‘waning diplomatic clout’ gave a despairing, plaintive air to the complaints of the Ruiz Cortines government.
Cohen is arguably a little kind in her interpretation of the imperatives driving the bracero programme, giving ample weight to the noble modernising impulses of the political elite. Yet whatever the thought processes of those steering the policy, Cohen returns consistently and powerfully to economic fundamentals. She notes that the ultimate aim was ‘economic sovereignty’ for Mexico, to be achieved by the transformation of the rural economy towards a model populated by ‘small capitalised yeoman farmers’. This aspect of the policy was a failure, for in the place of the imagined yeomanry the Mexican government instead found it had created a semi-proletarianised transnational labour pool.
This is perhaps the most significant aspect of Cohen's work: a casting of the bracero programme as an early experiment in the process which would lead, eventually, to an ‘integrated global capitalism’. Post-Marxian phraseology haunts the text as ‘reserve labour supply’ and ‘accumulated capital’ define the nuts and bolts of the bracero system: Cohen has skilfully knitted together a materialist economic history with an ethnographic survey of those living that process.
The uncomfortable image of the braceros as political and economic pawns is ever present. In one notable example, Cohen describes a 1947 dispute in which migrants came out in solidarity with local Californian labourers but were forced back to work, under threat of immediate deportation, by a troika of law enforcement, agriculture department and Mexican government agents. The braceros were then used simultaneously as strike-breakers and anti-immigration scapegoats, protected for as long as their labour was useful, but ejected once the ‘crops had been harvested and shipped to market unimpeded’. Modern resonances hardly need elucidating; indeed Cohen's sprightly, sensitive writing allows the reader to make such links in a way so often lacking in dry monographs written entirely in the preterite.
Cohen's heterodox interpretation is convincing, combining structural and economic factors with ideological and political drivers to lay bare the contradictions and inconsistencies of the programme. The voices of the workers themselves lend the work a tremendous force, and they illustrate perfectly the fascinating details which, when linked together, form some truly monumental stories. Time and again the sheer scale of what occurred rears up from the page; consider, for example, that between 1948 and 1952 the number of Mexican migrant workers in the United States rose from an estimated 70,000 to somewhere in excess of 1.5 million.
The freedom to migrate in search of work in the face of crushing local poverty was a genuine desire of braceros, yet it was ruthlessly manipulated both by Mexican politicians (as part of a national development strategy, if we interpret their actions kindly) and by US agriculture and its political allies. In addition to providing an extensive ethnography of the bracero experience, this volume is a highly valuable contribution to the broader analysis of twentieth-century labour in which growing demands for flexible working, both temporally and geographically speaking, were co-opted by employers and politicians. Much has been done to reveal the neat trick pulled by post-Fordist capital whereby workers, ‘liberated’ from the bondage of traditional hierarchical working structures, find confusion and anomie in place of the advertised freedom and agency. Cohen's work offers a glimpse of the parallel rural narrative, too often overlooked, which bypassed Fordist organisation altogether and moved from a shackled peonage directly to the modern transnational ‘grey’ economy. Mexico's migrant manual workers were, therefore, pioneers in many respects; their engaging stories show that while some braceros were able to manage such a life over long periods, few gained the economic independence that the scheme was supposed to bring.
