Constance Areson Clark's choice of the 1920s is perfectly suited for her brilliant study of evolutionary imagery, for the decade saw significant social, economic and political changes along with growing tensions over the question of where humans came from – tensions famously displayed in the Scopes ‘Monkey’ trial of 1925. As Clark notes, ‘Monkeys were everywhere in the 1920s – monkeys, apes, ape-men, cavemen and all manner of missing links … populate[d] newspapers, newsreels, magazines, and metaphors’ (p. 1). Many scientists were constantly on the defensive or on the attack, forever battling those who, considering science one of the ‘acids of modernity’ (p. 43), wished to equate evolution damningly with the trappings of the modern world. What better way to denigrate science and evolution than to characterize them as monkey business!
She begins with a look at museum exhibitions, and specifically that cathedral of science, the American Museum of Natural History, then led by the palaeontologist Henry Fairfield Osborn. Osborn, as Clark nicely puts it, ‘held a secure place in the media as a representative of the scientific point of view’ (p. 18). Even more importantly, Osborn's representations of ancient life at the museum, in the lively exhibits on display, and also in such books as Men of the Old Stone Age (1915), were regularly seen and widely distributed to the lay public. Clark successfully situates the American Museum of Natural History and Osborn in the wider context of the era's promotion of science and evolution to the masses, via written but also visual means (more illustrations here would have been welcome). Next Clark turns to the period just before the Scopes trial – the years around 1922 – in order to explore the ways that scientists either chose to defend evolution, ignored the debate or became increasingly intolerant. A vivid example of the latter tendency was Albert Edward Wiggam's The New Decalogue of Science (1923), which Clark quotes as proclaiming, ‘Science lies at the basis of all morals. You cannot be truly righteous until you find out how. Science alone can teach you how’ (p. 56). Here we can see elements of our own culture's debate about evolution.
The seventh chapter, ‘The pictures in our heads’, is the heart of the book. In 1925, Clark notes, ‘evolution’ meant human evolution. Views of human-culminating evolutionary progress appeared everywhere in popular culture, from films such as Evolution (1923) to the tree diagrams that William King Gregory and others used to portray the history of life. Whether in the form of charts or branching trees or sculptural representations of fossil hominids, visual representations of evolution all – depending on the view taken of the chain of life – either placed humans near to their primate relatives or distantly separated them. Clark expertly discusses the role of these representations in the debates between evolutionists in the period. In the hands of the likes of Osborn, trying hard to afford ‘humans a noble place in the scheme of things’, evolutionary illustrations incorporated ideas of progress, the dynamic nature of evolution and, in Clark's judgement, ‘misunderstandings about how science works’ (p. 161). All of this, however, would soon be overshadowed by the Scopes trial, with its abundance of primate imagery and zoo-like atmosphere.
The final chapters of God or Gorilla focus specifically on the period during and after July 1925. While other texts have offered a comprehensive view of the trial, Clark attends to the associated imagery and its usage. Visual language and visual imagery were conjoined to ridicule or mock serious scientific views. ‘No matter how often scientists objected to monkey imagery’, Clark observes, ‘monkeys, apes, ape-men, and cavemen proliferated during the Scopes Trial’ (p. 193). Hence the trial's permanent moniker as the ‘Scopes “Monkey” trial’. After the trial, and the serious beating that visual and textual images of evolution took throughout, it was, she argues, necessary for scientists to redeem the caveman. Osborn, for his part, had the previously sculpted busts of human ancestors rearranged in a sequence from ‘Java Man’ to Piltdown to Neanderthal to Cro-Magnon, and then had them photographed in angles that clearly revealed their differences. Why? Because, Clark argues, Osborn wanted to combat public opinion that ‘the caveman bore, and still bears, an evil reputation of being a brute’ (p. 201). Yet despite such efforts to ‘banish the popular caveman’ (p. 208), by Osborn, Charles R. Knight and others, stereotypes continued to promote club-wielding Neanderthals with stooped shoulders. This imagery persists today, in television commercials and newspaper cartoons.
Overall, Clark's study of the imagery of the 1920s in relation to attitudes about evolution, science and modernity is a wonderful work, of relevance not only to historians of science but also to students of American history, anthropology and cultural history. I only wish that Clark had looked a little more closely at the possibility of connections – hinted at in her subtitle – between popular attitudes to jazz music and the imagery discussed in God or Gorilla. With that avenue explored, music historians could also have been added to the list of scholars that will benefit from a careful read of her book.
