Research produced over the past quarter century has greatly advanced our knowledge about the ways Ottoman imperial bureaucrats sought to tighten the central government's grip over peripheral parts of the Ottoman Empire during the Tanzimat, the reign of Abdülhamit II, and the second constitutional period. However, historians of the late Ottoman period have studied these attempts to bring the new institutions and practices to the empire's periphery primarily with regard to Ottoman Tripolitania, parts of the Arabian peninsula, and Bilad al-Sham. Moreover, their research has tended to focus more on the decades after the 1860s or 1870s than on the first twenty years of the Tanzimat. Finally, most authors have concentrated on the study of one particular region without attempting to place their findings into a larger comparative Ottoman framework. Among the few exceptions are a recent book by Isa Blumi and his doctoral dissertation, “The Consequences of Empire in the Balkans and the Red Sea: Reading Possibilities in the Transformation of the Modern World” (New York University, 2005), which focus on the period between 1878 and 1918.
It is these lacunae that Maurus Reinkowski seeks to address in the monograph under review. The Things of Order: A Comparative Study of 19th-Century Ottoman Reform Politics—as one might translate the title of his book—looks at efforts on the part of the Ottoman central government to extend its control over Mount Lebanon and the province of Shkodër in present-day northern Albania between 1840 and the early 1860s. More specifically, the author explores to what extent and how governmental practices and concepts in these two provinces changed in the context of the Tanzimat when the Ottoman central government and its representatives sought to implement a uniform system of administration, taxation, military recruitment, and education throughout the empire for the first time in Ottoman history. Both regions under study were part of what Reinkowski terms the empire's “internal periphery”: they were surrounded by Ottoman territory but for several centuries had enjoyed a large degree of autonomy vis-à-vis the imperial center. Because they were difficult to access from the outside and did not allow for extensive agriculture, the imperial government had been content to leave the governing of these regions to a number of local leaders against the payment of an annual tribute.
The main section of this study is divided into three parts. Chapters 2–5 (“Center and Periphery”) survey the history of the two regions during the period under study and discuss the methodological problems of studying them in comparative perspective. Chapters 6–12 (“Methods of Rule”) examine the elaboration of governmental practices and strategies toward the provinces of Shkodër and Mount Lebanon. Chapters 13 and 14 (“Concepts of Rule”) are a detailed discussion of official Ottoman terminology relating to these two areas.
This book makes a number of important contributions to our understanding of the Tanzimat period. First, Reinkowski shows within a comparative framework what scholars like Elizabeth Thompson (IJMES 25[3]:457–75) or Jens Hanssen (The Empire in the City, Arab Provincial Capitals in the Late Ottoman Empire, 2002) have demonstrated for individual provinces or in shorter surveys, namely, that governmental practices during the opening decades of the Tanzimat cannot be understood in terms of a “package” of measures that were uniformly applied throughout the empire. Rather, we are dealing with a broad range of practices and strategies that were elaborated in specific regional contexts through the interaction of members of local communities, agents of the Ottoman central government, and representatives of various European powers.
Second, Reinkowski breaks new ground in his discussion of the notion of a “civilizing mission” that a number of scholars have recently identified as a quintessential element of Tanzimat politics of centralization. He cautions against the assumption that Ottoman bureaucrats from the very beginning of the Tanzimat period viewed “tribal” communities on the empire's periphery as savages that needed to be civilized through the establishment of direct rule and the homogenizing institutions and practices of the modern state. For instance, during the 1840s and 1850s, government officials still pursued a policy of co-optation toward the tribal confederation of the Mirdites, in the northeastern part of the province of Shkodër. In return for providing the Ottoman military with fighters in times of war, the Mirdites were allowed to retain their autonomy. Moreover, they were often praised in government correspondence for their loyalty and bravery on the battlefield that they had shown “from of old” (ötedenberü). It was only from the mid-1860s that a shift occurred toward viewing the Mirdites as savages who had to be disciplined and eventually civilized through tighter government control.
Equally important is the author's attempt to place the sectarian (he uses the term “confessional”) politics that characterized Mount Lebanon from the 1840s onward in a larger Ottoman context. He convincingly demonstrates that the combination of measures of autonomy and sectarian representation in local advisory councils (mecalis) were not specific to Mount Lebanon but could also be found in other provinces, such as Crete. Insofar as sectarian representation in local councils is concerned, Reinkowski argues, we are actually dealing with the “confessionalization” of Ottoman politics in general during the Tanzimat period.
Of particular interest to scholars of the period is the author's emphasis on conceptualizing continuity and change. Reinkowski explores to what extent political concepts and institutions, such as the notion of a “civilizing mission” or advisory councils, which are often interpreted as reflecting European influence on the thinking of Tanzimat statesmen, may also have been informed by older concepts of governance. Were the mecalis, he asks, merely about introducing an element of political participation in connection with the novel concept of Ottomanism? Rather, he argues, they can also be viewed as an example of the broad range of forms of co-optation, coercion, loose control, or containment through which the imperial center had sought to manage diversity and order society. Very much like Benjamin Fortna in his study of Ottoman public education during the reign of Abdülhamit II (1876–1909) (Imperial Classroom: Islam, The State, and Education in the Late Ottoman Empire, 2002), Reinkowski makes a case for viewing supposedly novel concepts and practices as adaptations of foreign concepts to older Ottoman notions of governance.
Chapters 13 and 14 are probably the most in-depth study to date of official Ottoman political terminology of the Tanzimat. Like Selim Deringil in The Well-Protected Domains (1998), Reinkowski culls these terms from government papers, such as reports and memoranda of provincial governors and special commissioners or instructions for commissions of inspection. What we get then is the “everyday” language of power in which Ottoman bureaucrats expressed their notions of savagery, repression, co-optation, disciplining of populations, order, and sovereignty. Central to what Reinkowski calls “the universe of Ottoman political terminology” (p. 290) was the objective of an ideal state of security and order (asayiş) and welfare (refah). This order was always precarious and had to be periodically reestablished through advice, threats, and if need be, coercion. The author confirms the findings of Ussama Makdisi (“Ottoman Orientalism”) by demonstrating that this cyclical notion of order gave way to a new linear one in the 1860s. Now, the objective was to establish a state of order that was final. Of crucial importance in this context was the term terbiye. Its original meaning of “chastisement” was supplanted by those of “disciplining” and “educating.” The sultan's subjects were to be reformed through the intervention of the state that sought to establish security, order, and welfare once and for all.
Finally, a set of superb appendices makes this book an extremely useful research tool. In addition to an index and a bibliography these include an annotated list of the terms studied in Part III. For every term the author provides an English translation and references to the pages on which the term is discussed in greater detail. This is followed by German translations of three government documents that shed important light on the formulation of strategies toward the district of Shkodër between the mid-1850s and early 1860s. Finally, we are provided with a short biographical entry for each of those Ottoman officials who during the period under study served as governors and/or special commissioners for Shkodër and Mount Lebanon and as governors of Saida.
The Things of Order is a thoughtful and sophisticated study that allows for a more nuanced understanding of early Tanzimat reform politics. It is a must read for all historians of the Ottoman Empire's long 19th century.
