In 1673, John Eachard, a fellow of St Catharine's College, Cambridge, published a satirical pamphlet under the title Some opinions of Mr. Hobbes considered. The satire portrayed an audience of three distinct types of “Hobbists” who had gathered in the philosopher's theater: in the pit sat his closest admirers, indulging in the vices and lusts they thought he represented; in the gallery, the mediocre gentlemen, who had been easily convinced by Hobbes's fame and intricate scientific language; and in the back, hiding in their boxes, sat the serious believers, haunted by the idea “that no man but Mr. Hobbs has gone to the Fundamentals of Government or humane Nature” (291).
Jon Parkin retells this mocking satire with noticeable gusto in his Taming the Leviathan, a comprehensive and well-argued survey of the reception of Hobbes in England from the 1640s to the start of the eighteenth century. The sardonic portrayal of Hobbes's theater-audience is one of the many instances traced by Parkin that show how Hobbes had become, as the author says, “the bête noire of his age” (1), a reputation which the philosopher has indeed maintained until this very day. With his study, Parkin intends to reveal how this image of Hobbes has come about, and, at least as importantly, to counter the related claim, often expounded in modern-day academia, that Hobbes was an anomaly in his own time. Analyzing the wide range of critiques and appropriations of Hobbes's ideas throughout the seventeenth century, Parkin explains how the “Monster of Malmesbury,” to use the phrasing of a typically sympathetic sermon from 1679 (335), was interpreted, discussed, and adapted by his contemporaries—indeed, how the beast was tamed, as Parkin imaginatively describes the reception process with a metaphor borrowed from David Gauthier. Taming the Leviathan thus proves that Hobbes's philosophy was much more embedded in seventeenth-century political culture than often assumed, and the result is not only a welcome contextual reconsideration of Hobbes himself, but also an admirably lucid overview of the political and religious debates dominating some of the most heated decades in English history, from the Civil War to the Glorious Revolution.
Much of the merit of the book comes from Parkin's decision to discuss the reception of Hobbes not thematically, but as it developed through time. Accordingly, he is able to elucidate how the various interpretations of Hobbes were heavily conditioned by the (often highly capricious) political circumstances in which his work was read. Hobbes entered the center of the English public debate following the official publication of De Cive in 1647 and De Corpore Politico in 1650, soon claimed by both royalists and republicans. This paradox of being appropriated as well as condemned by both extremes of the political stage would repeat itself throughout the century, and many of the caricatured elements that were to characterize Hobbes's public image in the decades to come were already established in these years, from his allegedly arbitrary defactoism to his perceived heresy, later resulting in the charge of downright atheism. The publication of the Leviathan in 1651 would, surprisingly, at first not receive very much attention, yet following the establishment of Cromwell's Protectorate, Leviathan seemed a direct comment on the new status quo, and Hobbes became the eye of the hurricane.
Parkin describes with intriguing detail how the Leviathan went on to captivate the subsequent generations of readers, throughout the Restoration and its crisis until the advent of deism and the Enlightenment. Of course, all the usual suspects are passed in review, from Robert Filmer to James Harrington and from Richard Cumberland to John Locke. The author discusses their struggles with Hobbes with a sound grasp of all the theoretical issues at stake, yet most rewarding is his re-enactment of the colorful pandemonium of minor actors in the grotesque theater of Hobbism, populated by stubborn Anglican bishops, haughty Oxford professors, and best-selling witty romancers. And, of course, there is the old master himself, who tried to control his own fate yet could not prevent that a public caricature of Mr. Hobbes the vile libertine atheist took over—and indeed, trampled on his grave.
Nonetheless, as Parkin insists, “Hobbes's critics had had a more pernicious effect than Hobbes himself” (411): with their continuous condemnations they fueled ongoing curiosity for his ideas which thus steadily entered mainstream political thought. Parkin makes a convincing case that Hobbes's distinctive rhetoric played a pivotal role in this process of furtive appropriation. Deliberately casting his thought in ambiguous paradoxes and imaginative metaphors that lured the reader into unconventional conclusions, Hobbes gave his work a double-edged potential, attracting all sorts of agendas with his catching sound-bites. With this emphasis on the relation between the style and contents of Hobbes's thought, Parkin follows in the footsteps of Quentin Skinner's seminal Reason and Rhetoric in the Philosophy of Hobbes (1996), and he treads even further: Hobbes's rhetoric, according to Parkin, offered his English contemporaries an imaginative, versatile framework to cope with civil disorder and political insecurity, and “Hobbes's unusual combination of reason and rhetoric may well have played a role in the long-term pacification of the English polity” (414).
For all its compelling judgment, the book has one minor limitation, which is its strict focus on a purely English reading of Hobbes. The author does not address the question whether the appropriation of Hobbes's ideas in England could possibly have been conditioned by similar or contrary readings on the continent. Did the several French, German, Dutch, or Italian readers of Hobbes in any way influence their English counterparts? Parkin mentions some of the first continental responses to De Cive, and he notes in passing the parallels between the ways in which Cumberland, Locke, and Samuel Pufendorf tried to make sense of Hobbes. Yet he does not really engage in the possible linkages between, for example, the pan-European campaign against Spinoza and the portrayal of Hobbes as a debauched atheist—although, as the book makes clear repeatedly, Hobbes and Spinoza were also in England soon regarded as two branches of the same heretical tree. Arguably this particular portrayal of Hobbes had its roots in continental Europe, but Parkin overall stresses the English case in all its splendid isolation.
Yet this limited geographical focus does not detract from the overall quality of Taming the Leviathan, which reveals exemplarily how the various meanings of historical texts are not only constructed by their author but equally, if not especially, by their contemporary audience. As such the work stands out as an excellent contribution to the subdiscipline of the history of reading, and it will prove to be very useful for historians of political thought and to reception theorists. Given its detailed discussions of many forgotten figures and obscure past debates, it may be of less interest to a public of political scientists, although every modern-day Hobbist, whether sitting in the pit, gallery, or box, should read this book in order to realize how the stage was once built.
