This excellent volume brings together leading economic historians of the Great Depression of the 1930s to assess what we have learned from the most recent scholarship on that decade and the possible lessons for today. Of course, the reason for the volume's timely appearance is the recent financial crisis and the Great Recession, both of which have conjured up memories of the 1930s. Even before the crisis, however, economic historians had been working diligently on that ever-fascinating decade. The result is an impressive, up-to-date survey of the existing literature on the Depression with discussion about the implication for policymakers today.
The short space allotted to me does not permit a detailed discussion of the conclusions of every chapter. Let me just say that every chapter has nuggets of insight and interpretation that will enable even those readers who are very conversant with the literature on the Great Depression to learn something. No major topic is neglected. Nicholas Crafts and Peter Fearon, the editors whom we must thank for bringing this volume to fruition, contribute the first two chapters, one an overview of the Depression and recovery during the 1930s, and the other on the lessons for today. Nikolaus Wolf examines the legacy of World War I in setting the stage for the Depression and points out the obstacles (war debts, 1920s inflation) to coordinating European macroeconomic policies during this period. Albrecht Ritschl looks at reparations, monetary policy, and fiscal policy in affecting the course of the Depression in Germany. Forrest Capie surveys the disintegration of the world economy between the wars. Charles Calomiris takes a very critical look at banking legislation passed in the 1930s, while Michael Bordo and John Landon-Lane examine banking panics in the United States and review the liquidity versus insolvency debate about their source. Roger Middleton examines fiscal consolidation in Britain in the 1930s. Price Fishback looks at monetary and fiscal policy in the United States over the course of the decade. Alexander Field focuses on economic growth and recovery in the United States throughout this period, particularly on aggregate supply and productivity developments, while Timothy Hatton and Mark Thomas examine the shocks to U.S. and U.K. labor markets. Fishback and John Wallis analyze the panoply of programs that made up the New Deal. Kris Mitchener and Joseph Mason address the “exit strategy” of countries in terms of the policies they instituted to deal with the Depression and argue that sometimes the exit did not occur until the 1950s. Finally, Barry Eichengreen and Peter Temin discuss the gold standard ideology and relate it to the Euro today.
Overall, this volume sets and maintains an impressively high quality throughout. Some chapters are simply interpretive surveys, while others briefly present new empirical findings, but the emphasis is on the former. The book is conversant with the latest research findings, making it quite valuable as a reference for economic historians. And yet the chapters are accessible enough to use in undergraduate courses that deal with some of these topics. The book hits the sweet spot of being interesting and valuable to several different constituencies.
One general impression from the volume that strikes this reader is the importance of Eichengreen's work on the gold standard and the Great Depression in framing much of the subsequent research and analysis of the period. The notion that the gold standard is a key to understanding the origins, duration, and ending of the Depression permeates much of the book and is a focal point for many of the chapters, particularly those dealing with macroeconomics and monetary policy. It is clear that Eichengreen has had a tremendous influence on how economic historians think about the international dimensions of the Great Depression.
Another impression is the importance of politics and ideas, particularly the constraints (perceived and real) on economic policymakers at the time. This fascinating theme is touched on in various chapters, but much more could have been made of it. (Perhaps a political scientist could have been invited to contribute to the volume, given the importance of the issue.)
One might complain that the book focuses too much on the United States and Great Britain to the neglect of other countries, although some attention is paid to Germany. For the most part, however, this simply reflects the weight of scholarly research on the Depression, even though some important work has been done on economic policy in France, Japan, and Australia during the 1930s.
In sum, this collection has something of value for anyone interested in the Great Depression. Even established scholars of this era will learn something from its contents.
