Interdependency between women is the way to a freedom which allows the I to be, not in order to be used, but in order to be creative.
Audre Lorde (1979/Reference Lorde1984)The freedom to be, and to be creative, is a critical requisite for all scholars. For women of color who are early-career scholars, community spaces that foster relationships among women are one of the most meaningful ways that they can unearth their creativity. As Audre Lorde (1979/Reference Lorde1984) said, “Without community there is no liberation.” Accessing our creativity as political scientists seeking to uncover new theories and findings is an opportunity that all academics should be offered when venturing into a career as a junior scholar. However, higher education is not an inherently neutral space; this reality often precludes the research environment as a place where women of color can comfortably engage their intellectual creativity. Most often, autonomous political science departments across the country have additional paths of resistance, which serve as a hurdle for women of color scholars early in their career. Given this reality, community spaces are an important component necessary for the growth of women of color as junior scholars.
Community spaces have a critical role in the development of junior scholars as both people and researchers. Women of color are dynamic and embody distinct identities, and a plethora of differences may exist among the umbrella of individuals who identify as women of color. These differences should be celebrated (Lorde 1979/Reference Lorde1984). This type of space encourages differences as a generative process that can foster new ways of researching and putting forth our research agenda. The reality is that women of color in political science often are a numerical minority—one of few or the only to occupy such a role in their department. Moreover, they often are presumed to be incompetent in the academy, which may lead junior scholars to develop a negative self-concept in both their personal and professional identities. Although these identities have an integral role in their unique approach to research, this presumption can be delegitimized as less rigorous and biased by dominant epistemologies that privilege linear and universalized perspectives of science.
One resistive approach to combating this exigency is the implementation of workshop retreat spaces organized by women scholars of color. These convenings provide collaborative spaces for women to share their locally constituted lived experiences and build collective agency as a way to rethink top-down approaches to academic and disciplinary practices in political science. Building on the rich critique of previous work in this area (e.g., Combahee River Collective Statement Reference Statement1974; Lorde 1979/Reference Lorde1984), this article reflects on the power and potential of workshop retreat spaces for building the intellectual growth of women of color scholars. Community spaces curated for junior women of color are one of the few places where there is liberation for ideas to expand and for women to lean into the authenticity of the various dimensions of their distinctiveness. In many ways, it fosters growth as intellectuals. Women of color struggle with the realities of racism, sexism, homophobia, and the intersections of their different identities. Having a communal space that embraces these realities is necessary for development.
Such convenings provide collaborative spaces for women to share their locally constituted lived experiences and build collective agency as a way to rethink top-down approaches to academic and disciplinary practices within political science.
EXISTING REALITIES WITHIN THE DISCIPLINE
Women of color are acutely aware that the higher-education system was not designed for women, much less for them to join as a junior scholar or advance within the system. In myriad ways, the work environment at colleges and universities reminds individuals that they are, at best, an afterthought and, at worst, explicitly not welcome. Currently, degree-granting postsecondary institutions have a disproportionately lower number of women of color as full-time faculty members. At the assistant professor level, only 7% are Asian American and Pacific Islander American women, 5% are Black women, and 3% are Hispanic women (US Department of Education 2020). This disparity increases the higher one’s position is within higher education, where there are even fewer senior faculty members and full professors who are women of color (Whitford Reference Whitford2020). This means, for example, that there may be only one Black woman in the department.
Being the singular member of a minority group, or the “token member,” in a department not only creates an isolating experience; it also places additional responsibilities on a woman of color. The primary contractual obligations required of junior scholars are research productivity, teaching, and service. The service obligation entails a higher workload, especially for women of color, given the current racial climate. The resurgence of the Black Lives Matter movement and the increase in anti-Asian hate crimes and homophobic and Islamophobic incidents has left colleges and universities scrambling to address these challenges. Diversity committees, special lectures, and workshops have been convened in response to these events. For women of color on faculty, this means that they often are asked to lend their expertise to assist with these initiatives, typically in addition to rather than in replacement of work on which they already are focused. This can leave them with a significant emotional, intercultural, and administrative burden. Moreover, when there is only a single Black woman in a political science department, Black students at both the graduate and undergraduate levels may feel more comfortable approaching her with their challenges compared to other faculty members. This type of additional responsibility, although not explicitly defined in a work contract, may fall to the educator, who also may feel additional responsibility serving as a resource to students and, ultimately, the institution (Zamudio-Suarez Reference Zamudio-Suarez2021). The labor of creating an equitable workplace that considers the intersection of all identities becomes the presumptive burden of junior scholars, which often is produced as invisible labor.
The academic climate is not neutral, yet junior scholars are required to be objective in a space that views their existence within the subjective racial climate (Alexander-Floyd Reference Alexander-Floyd2015; Brettscheider Reference Brettscheider2011). In addition, the study of marginalized communities, which is one area of study for junior scholars, is treated with less respect in comparison to other subfields in the discipline (Seifert and Umbach Reference Seifert and Umbach2008). As McClain et al. (Reference McClain, Ayee, Means, Reyes-Barriéntez and Sediqe2016) highlighted, the discipline of political science in the United States is rooted in exclusionary practices that marginalize the ideas and contributions of Black intellectuals. The consequences are that race and ethnic politics research often is viewed as “me-search,” and the “top three” journals have a record of minimal acceptance of race and ethnic politics papers (McClain et al. Reference McClain, Ayee, Means, Reyes-Barriéntez and Sediqe2016). For junior scholars, realizing that the scholarship that they are committed to may be seen as inconsequential is another challenge to being comfortable with and expanding their research agenda. The women of color scholars who do not study race and ethnic politics are faced with the additional experience of faculty being surprised that they study anything other than race. Consequently, women of color are trapped by lacking a consistent avenue for their research to be viewed as valuable in the discipline. The study of issues related to our self-identified community is presumed as me-search and the exploration outside of our self-identity is met with skepticism or outright hostility.
WHAT WE NEED: THE CELEBRATION OF INTERSECTIONS
Given these challenges, communal spaces centered on women of color is a necessary requisite for ensuring our success as academics. The racialized patriarchy witnessed in the discipline of political science in many ways mirrors the realities in politics and in society. This patriarchal system leaves women—and especially women of color—in a quandary, which often produces an internal struggle that can be better understood in the community of other women of color. For example, research on American political development that touches on the inherently racialized nature of American history uses a top-down approach (Ming Francis Reference Ming Francis2018). The emphasis on this approach forces women of color to make difficult choices at the outset of their career. There are two options: (1) conform to researching in a material way, which often ignores the misogynistic patriarchal system in which we, in the discipline, are a part; or (2) research in the most desirable way, which is ideational. This compliance will result in the discipline’s acceptance and access to the top three journals. This struggle is experienced by women of color across the entire discipline and has shaped our approach to engagement in the discipline.
As a Black woman (Nelson), my choice was made with intention. Studying political action in an ideational manner is the way to advance the oppressed voice of Blacks originally excluded from political participation. This exclusion is the reality of the political landscape in the United States and internationally. Therefore, the need to be in a community that views this exclusion as fact with current political implications reinforces my existence. It creates a space in which I am not concerned that the critique of my work is centered in my choice to study through the ideational lens. It is a space in which critique is couched in this ultimate displeasure of the research topic or the methodology used in the research. The intentional creation of space for women of color as junior faculty is one in which my experiences are not discounted. The experiences of women of color often are viewed by the larger discipline as having no value or being less valuable because they do not align with the experiences of the majority. The isolationism felt by women of color in political science departments across the country made me intentional about looking for spaces that would acknowledge my humanity before critiquing my scholarship. More spaces that allow for liberation must be created if the discipline intends to retain women of color and promote them from the rank of assistant to associate and beyond.
Similarly, as a first-generation immigrant and a visibly identifiable Muslim woman (Sediqe), I am keenly aware that my gender and associated group identity are viewpoints through which I engage in the academic workplace. I also understand that each lens results in judgment by the majority of the discipline. For example, when I taught a summer course in a pipeline program focused on underrepresented minorities in the discipline, my teaching style was commented on by faculty outside of the program. These faculty members, who were not involved in my professional work, used my identities to justify misplaced ethnically motivated concerns. I was offered friendly collegial advice to be careful because I appeared to be “too nurturing” in a teaching environment. Given the stereotypes associated with my cultural background (my family is from Afghanistan), this type of behavior and attitude toward teaching may be “intuitive” but something I should be mindful to moderate. I suspect the term “nurture” would not have been used if this male colleague offered similar advice to a male graduate student that he observed teaching. Moreover, the colleague’s invocation of my “cultural background” was an immediate connection made after the gendered remark about how I maintained authority within the classroom. Muslim and Afghan women are commonly perceived as submissive and meek (Sediqe and Beydoun, Forthcoming). Many years after this uninvited advice was offered, I became keenly aware that the manner in which I research and teach provokes critique. My identity makes me hyper-visible in a traditional collegiate space, which invites stereotyped critique hinged on my gender and culture.
THE MOVE FORWARD
Our experiences recounted in this article parallel those shared across the collective of women of color that convened in San Juan, Puerto Rico. The retreat included women from different racial and ethnic backgrounds, sexual orientations, religious beliefs, and countries of origin. The commonality was a realization that our differences bind us closer together; we embrace our distinctiveness as a strength for one another. The retreat in San Juan provided an important space to process these types of reflections and to understand the emerging themes of challenges that exist for the different women in the space. As coauthors of this article, we came together with varying experiences as women of color—one a Black woman, the other an Afghan Muslim woman. Collaborations such as this one move women of color as well as the discipline forward in building the communities necessary to foster growth.
Building a community space of this caliber intentionally disrupts the scarcity model or “crabs-in-a-barrel mentality,” in which the current system is designed for us to work in competition. Rather, this space encouraged the understanding that one woman’s success was a success for all women of color. Our successes were celebrated at the dinner sessions; during discussions about collective triumph; and when we finished a course syllabus, produced substantial writing, and engaged in nonscholarly activities. These activities made us feel that we were more than just what we produced. Practical tools on how to manage the unavoidable conflict in the discipline and in our department were discussed. The honest acknowledgment that these instances, which are based on our unique identities, were viable conversations because impediments will not vanish in the near future. These experiences corroborate existing evidence that highlight how community spaces provide women the necessary space for upliftment in both personal and professional dimensions (Carter and Alexander Reference Carter and Alexander2019; Prins, Toso, and Schafft Reference Prins, Toso and Schafft2009).
Building a community space of this caliber intentionally disrupts the scarcity model or “crabs-in-a-barrel mentality,” in which the current system is designed for us to work in competition. Rather, this space encouraged the understanding that one woman’s success was a success for all women of color.
The ultimate goal of the space created through our collective experience in San Juan in January 2020 was to change the outcomes for women of color in the discipline of political science. We understand that to change the outcomes, we must change the methods. Instead of scholarship being a completely individualistic activity, a change through the foundational exercise of creating a collective is the way forward for women of color in political science. The creation of a collective space can improve the rates of attrition and promotion for women of color through collaborative research and community care. It is a tangible arena in which academics who publicly voice their support as allies of women of color can provide financial and logistical assistance to sustain and increase the curation of such spaces.
The value of a collective and the natural collaborative space it creates are exemplified by women who gathered at the Combahee River to form a collective in 1974. This meeting resulted in a statement in which the women said: “We are actively committed to struggling against racial, sexual, heterosexual, and class oppression, and see as our particular task the development of integrated analysis and practice based upon the fact that the major systems of oppression are interlocking” (Combahee River Collective Statement Reference Statement1974). The interlocking modes of oppression affect each life; therefore, the creation of community that cares about the commitment to fight against and change such oppression emerged in San Juan by those who participated. This collective was established to research in a collaborative manner that acknowledges intersections in our fields of study while simultaneously encouraging and supporting solo projects.
We know that such a commitment will increase the attrition rate because the building of community creates belonging, which often is unavailable at our own institution. This is evident across academic fields because women of color are more likely than white women to be employed in a non-tenure-track position and at a minority-serving institution; only 1.2% of these women become full professors (Rapporteur Reference Rapporteur2013). The creation of a collective committed to collaborative research at the beginning of our career can increase the amount of scholarship we produce. In turn, this makes promotion more viable. The promotion of scholars who value material as well as ideational political-action research is necessary to break the inequities that exist due to current disciplinary norms.
CONCLUSION
Spaces like the writing retreat in San Juan, Puerto Rico, in January 2020 demonstrate the discipline’s commitment to building a community for women of color at the beginning of their career. It is acknowledgment that community is necessary for liberation and for belonging. It affirms that women of color are worthy of investment and not merely filling a quota in the discipline. When thinking about inclusivity, the discipline must consider that the creation of a sacred community is a vital organism for the continued relevance of political science. As activism around ideational issues increases, scholars who typically are junior women of color need a community for critique, brainstorming, collaboration, and care.
When thinking about inclusivity, the discipline must consider that the creation of a sacred community is a vital organism for the continued relevance of political science.
This disputes the false narrative that competition is required for the development of junior scholars. Collaboration can be the much-needed scholastics respite and affirmation that women of color crave in academic spaces, despite their being advised against it for the advancement of their career. This ideation that collaboration is detrimental is rooted in a Eurocentric, Darwin-based value system and neoliberal models of the academy that commodify academic research and publication. This insular value system is promulgated without considering the experiences of women of color. In many if not most cases, the women of color who secure a tenure-track position at a four-year institution are the embodiment of “survival of the fittest.” The obstacles placed in our path are a direct result of the intersections of our very being in society and in the academy. The continued acknowledgment of such intersections lived and subsequently researched is the path forward in political science. Who we are shapes how we are, and for women of color at the commencement of their career, defining who we are as researchers and scholars requires sacred space.
