No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 May 2004
Accommodating women's rights in high-context cultures has become one the most difficult challenges facing the modern world. Ending religious repression is an area of deep concern to many Islamic and Western publics. This issue has grabbed more attention in the context of globalization, which has generated contradictory processes and outcomes. Human solidarity and interconnection has, for example, increasingly been accompanied by rekindling of the forces of local identities and religious extremism. The rise of religious fundamentalism has unleashed two opposing trends: (1) the intensification of women's subordination; and (2) the emergence of a backlash in the form of women's legal rights in particular and women's rights to religious freedom more generally.
The book under review is organized into seven sections, and its chapters are built around four perspectives: international human rights, national law, grass-roots, and theological. The book's first section examines the link between religious radicalism and gender. John S. Hawley sees a use for the term “fundamentalism” to the extent that many militantly conservative religious groups focus on a “restoration of divinely sanctioned core values—fundamentals—that have been attacked, obscured, or overridden by the forces of modernity, often in colonial or imperial disguise” (p. 7). In the United States, Christian fundamentalists’ “abstinence-only” approach reflects parents’ rights over children's sex education, but it also demonstrates parents’ desire to control women's sexuality (chap. 2 [by Susan D. Rose]). In Algeria, respect for others’ culture and religion has strengthened fundamentalist ideology (chap. 3 [by Mari-Aimee Helie]). Jewish fundamentalism in Israel and in the diaspora is perceived as an empowering movement, given the larger political agenda of such movements (chap. 4 [by Nira Yubal-Davis]).
The second section explores the politics of difference and displays the flaw of cultural relativism. The authors here question the claim that local culture is superior to the global culture (Michael Singer); that a confrontational approach to setting women's rights against religious rights may be helpful (Christine Chinkin); that cultural relativity means the same thing in the West and the Muslim world (Mahnaz Afkami); and that state religious law could trump women's international rights (Radhika Coomaraswamy). All of these authors call into question cultural relativism, arguing that it has been used to prevent women's voices and rights.
The third section tackles the issue of the international legal framework. The role of the state in providing effective legal remedies for women abused under certain laws is crucial (Courtney Howland). In most Islamic countries, including Morocco, Kuwait, Pakistan, and Algeria, the state's political contingencies—not Islamic beliefs—are the reasons behind reservations that these countries have about entering into the Convention on the Eliminations of All Forms of Discrimination against Women, or CEDAW (Ann Elizabeth Mayer). Bahia G. Tahzib-Lie argues that international human-rights treaties forbid discrimination on the basis of sex. This means that women have an equal right to freedom of religion or belief. The same argument applies to girls’ right to education under international law (Geraldine Van Bueren and Deirdre Fottrell).
The fourth section deals with the issues that religious fundamentalism poses for national laws. Women's rights in the context of the rise of the Hindu right in India appear to be connected with the broader political program of cultural nationalism (Ratnar Kapur). The institutionalization of legal inequality for women in Israel is linked to the fact that the state delegates autonomy to different religious groups. This has resulted in patriarchal norms’ being enshrined into law (Frances Raday). In Belgium, the adoption of the choice-of-law rule of domicile (the law of the person's permanent place of residence) is an attempt to prevent discrimination against women under the family law of their nationality (Marie-Claire Foblets).
Especially problematic is fundamentalists’ attempt to control women's bodies, sexuality, and reproduction. The authors in the fifth section deal with this issue. Lynn Freedman argues that fundamentalists co-opt and redeploy the element of “choice” and that the link between reproductive health and social justice is threatened by fundamentalists. Sustaining reproductive freedom and social justice is the key to women's struggle. Frances Kissling discusses how the Roman Catholic church's opposition to abortion is caused more from the fear of women than for the purpose of protecting human life, even though its teachings may imply otherwise. To Muslim fundamentalists, Asma M. Abdel Halim writes, women's sexuality is destructive of society, family, and social norms. The male-centered Buddhist culture and monastic establishment in Thailand, according to Lucinda Joy Peach, provide an atmosphere conducive to the sex trade and trafficking.
The sixth section of the book looks at the alternative remedies and strategies of resistance for women. There is a broad consensus that the most effective way for women to resist fundamentalists is by attaining education. Sakena Yacoobi explains how her establishment of the Afghan Institute of Learning has contributed to women's educational attainment in refugee camps. Cecile Richards discusses how she formed the Texas Freedom Network, a non-partisan grass-roots organization of religious and community leaders, to provide an alternative to the religious right. Women's opposition to social religious norms is an expression of political belief, which is a legal reason for gender-based asylum in cases of religious persecution (Paul Nejelski). Women's resistance in Iran, according to Azar Nafisi, is historically demonstrable by the way in which women have resisted wearing the “veil.”
The book's final section addresses religious challenges to religious fundamentalism. The authors here provide alternative interpretations to fundamentalist readings and provide their own interpretations. Jewish feminists, Paula Hyman writes, have argued that patriarchy and the resultant subordination of women are not essential parts of Judaism. Hyman, however, fails to point out that all religions have developed in patriarchal settings; they are largely expressed in patriarchal terms; and they are heavily influenced by patriarchal values. Suwanna Satha-Anand discusses Buddha's allowing of women's ordination, a fact that could establish the rights of women to religious pre-eminence. Latin American women, Maria José Rosado Nunes points out, have reformulated women's rights as integrated into collective rights, including social rights and reproductive rights. Criticizing reformers for failing to articulate a theological basis for a secular state, Ghazala Anwar advocates a critical and historical interpretation of the hadith and Qur

an.
The task of textual re-interpretation, although it remains a crucial aspect of challenging religious fundamentalism, is inadequate in and of itself. Ultimately, reform in political economy and legal empowerment of women are imperative. Not all structures of dominance can be uprooted by re-interpretation of the religious texts. Granted that global solidarity among groups, non-governmental organizations, and individuals is an effective strategy against religious fundamentalism, it is also essential to examine politico-economic structures of dominance, both internally and externally. Furthermore, the archaic and fundamentalist application of Islamic law has forced women to resort to international law (e.g., CEDAW) to win their rights. If we seek to end human-rights abuses against women and girls throughout the world, we must develop strategies to counter religious fundamentalisms that are oppressive to women. This requires a multi-faceted campaign and cooperation by activists, policy-makers, and practitioners together, a point not fully elaborated in this volume.
This problem notwithstanding, the book is rich in perspectives and gives insightful overviews of the typical tensions characteristic of modernizing societies. The case studies chosen in this volume are significantly relevant and especially helpful in understanding gender issues in the context of modernization. The book is a valuable effort in outlining conditions necessary for the establishment of cultural and institutional bases for promoting the human rights of women.