Anne Wolf has written a political history of the Nahda (Renaissance) Party in Tunisia over the previous half century, drawing on four years of field research and hundreds of interviews. The party emerged first as an opposition group under Presidents Bourguiba and Ben Ali, later went underground and operated in exile, and then finally rose to prominence after 2011. At its core, this is a survey of people and events, a political history of the Nahda Party, the activities of its precursors, and the regime's response to it. It does not purport to offer an intellectual history or exploration of their ideology, or an ethnographic or social history of religiosity or piety in Tunisia, but describes a pluralistic movement, attentive to grass-roots demands, and with a leadership open to negotiation. With six chronologically organized chapters, a glossary, map, and biographical notes on the party's major figures, Wolf's book is accessible to non-specialists and non-academic audiences.
The first chapter provides broad historical background to contextualize the relationship between Islam, reform, and the political sphere in Tunisia since the nineteenth century. From the late Ottoman (and arguable nahda era) reform movement, through the period of anti-colonial nationalism, Wolf highlights a struggle between reform-minded secularists and traditional social circles that invoked Islam. Thus, her description of Bourguiba omits his authoritarian tendencies in order to emphasize how his secularism marked a continuation with earlier reformist battles against Islamic-based conservatism. Her story thus ignores how a utilitarian approach to religion fit with state centralization and the construction of a single-party regime that sidelined or coopted labor and the nascent women's movement.
In chapter 2, Wolf describes the politicization of Islam in Tunisia in the 1970s as standing in “sharp contrast with Bourguiba's secular reforms,” tracing its post-colonial origins to the “increase in literature from the Muslim Brotherhood,” the Iranian revolution, and activism at universities (27–28). Offering more background on the anti-colonialist movement, she describes Bourguiba's shifts from coopting religious authorities to later sanctioning religious study groups in an attempt to marginalize leftist students. Wolf is at her strongest in describing how a loosely organized group of individuals with similar interests and a range of ideological positions came together as the Islamic Tendency Movement (MTI). The chapter title “Tunisia's Muslim Brotherhood,” glosses over such nuance, and the retrospective testimonials regarding the Brotherhood model are unfortunately not rich in detail.
Wolf then turns to the increasingly oppositional political stance of the MTI as regime intolerance for political plurality increased in the 1980s. As she explains, some members of the MTI “sought to respond to the repression by plotting [coups],” though it is unclear whether any steps were taken, or how extensively such plots were supported within the movement (63). This is important because it was in the interest of both Tunisian presidents to inflate the threat and hence justify extensive surveillance and incarceration of MTI activists, sympathizers, their families, and at times devout Tunisians in general. Underneath this heading, she illustrates a movement whose policies developed over time and in response to the constraints of a shifting political climate where opposition parties – whether based in human rights, socialism, or otherwise – were neither tolerated nor legal. Operating underground was a logistical constraint and contributed to the local and regional autonomy of activists. While some sympathized with radical resistance, others collaborated with secular opposition movements and advocated for tolerance of the regime, trends that Wolf heuristically labels pragmatic and dogmatic.
Under Ben Ali (r. 1987–2011), the MTI was briefly legalized as the Nahda party, but more often was the target of continued policing. Wolf therefore charts the shifting political approaches of Nahda in tandem with Ben Ali's oscillation between accommodation and repression, resulting in the dispersal of the movement's more influential figures across Europe, which is covered in chapter 4. Their exile fragmented the leadership structure, making it logistically tenuous to organize the party's rank and file, and leading to greater divergences regarding overall political strategies, with leading figures such as Rachid Ghannouchi emphasizing Nahda's commitment to democracy and drawing attention towards the human rights abuses of the regime. In chapter 5, Wolf argues that as Tunisians wearied of Ben Ali and authoritarian rule in general in the 1990s and early 2000s, they became more pious. The regime thus attempted to mollify its public image in regards to Islam and make it appear more respectful, despite continued repression (fueled by the U.S.-led War on Terror) in an attempt to deny the Nahda party political influence.
The final chapter includes a brief overview of the 2010–11 protests that led to the ouster of President Ben Ali, describing Nahda's activities during those crucial weeks, the party's subsequent reorganization, and its relationship to the Troika government through the Quartet-led transition. Though they did not plan or broadly participate in the protests, Nahda sympathizers quickly mobilized, presenting candidates for the Constituent Assembly elections. Wolf attributes Nahda's success in 2011 to the willingness of party leaders to form coalitions. She depicts a multiplicity of opinions on political strategies, the party platform, and the interests of its supporters (to encourage piety on university campuses, promote charitable acts, reference shariʿa as a source of Tunisian law), heuristically framed under the rubric of a pragmatic leadership and a dogmatic base.
Wolf should be commended for conducting more than 400 interviews and informal conversations, which form the bulk of her source-base in certain chapters. However, Wolf is not an anthropologist; we learn little of how such interviews were conducted, nor does she consider to what extent personal memories of decades past have been reinterpreted by contemporary events. Despite having visited numerous archives and having access to personal collections, she refers only twice to documents from Tunisian archives, and only once to a newspaper from a private collection, whereas multiple chapters rely more heavily on insights from U.S. diplomatic personnel via Wikileaks, or popular western news outlets. MTI and Nahda publications are rarely invoked and the party statutes, declarations, and programs included in Appendix 1–4 are not discussed. Despite her invocation of “Talal Asad's notion of Islam as a discursive tradition,” there is very little discursive analysis (6).
Again, Wolf focuses heavily on a primary-source base of interviews, which appear voluminous, and include key political figures. In many ways the book constitutes a biography of the political movement that shies away from historical analysis and scholarly debates. For instance, basic questions such as whether the Nahda movement is synonymous with political Islam as the title suggests are not addressed. Wolf demonstrates that a number of political parties invoke Islam today, and that Nahda and the MTI never represented all political views on Islam. Some Nahda activists even reject the term “political Islam,” preferring “Muslim Democrats” (160). Additional political parties that invoke religion are lumped together as “jihadi,” without explicating the term, even though she notes that one such ultra-conservative group is mainly focused on charitable activities (144).
Tunisian nationalists and politicians, including members of Nahda, continue to reference the major figures of the national past and to reinterpret their legacies. Yet the suggestion that Tunisian politics today continues to revolve around a polarization between constitutional reformists and a religious trend is not convincing. In fact, contemporary public debates include a much broader cross-section of Tunisian society and are no longer the purview of an educated urban elite. They take place across multiple media platforms and coincide with questions concerning rural marginalization, unemployment, access to education, environmental degradation, the critique of nepotism, and calls for social justice and the rule of law. As a book that is widely accessible, it is unfortunate that much of the broader regional context of religious reform movements and Islamic activism across the Middle East is largely left out.
