No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 29 March 2004
This useful book is a publication of the Pension Research Council of the Wharton School. It provides an analytical history of public-sector pensions in the United States, which had important differences in their management, distribution, and investment funding and which offer important lessons for recent proposals to restructure Social Security and to expand defined contribution, employer-provided pension plans. There are 11 chapters, an appendix of historical price and wage indices covering various periods from 1720 to 1939, and detailed references to the history and economics of public- and private-sector pension systems.
The book has three objectives: to provide the first basic reference volume on the history of public-sector pensions in the United States; to identify policy lessons for modern day pension analysts; and to provide a chronology of the theory and practice of pension fund management. As the authors state there is no disentangling the history of public-sector pensions from that of the financial management of the monies in the pension funds and the evolution of finance in the United States. Accordingly, pension history offers insights into the development of American financial markets as well.
Chapter 1 summarizes the evolution of public pensions in the United States that predated private-sector arrangements. Military pensions were the first to appear, and for a while, navy and army pension systems were quite different. Both were aimed at providing replacement income for soldiers and sailors injured in battle, to offer performance incentives, to arrange for orderly retirements, and to respond to political pressures. Naturally, these objectives were not always mutually consistent. A major difference between the navy and army plans, however, was that the navy plan was financed with monies from the sale of captured prizes. Revenues were very erratic, fluctuating with the fortunes of war and peace. As a result, Congress established the navy pension fund and allowed the trustees of this fund to invest in a wide range of assets, including private equities. The history of the management of the fund reveals the many problems that arise when public pension monies are used to purchase private assets. One problem was investing in politically favored firms that did not offer the highest returns, weakening the fund. There also were other moral-hazard issues. Congress expanded benefits and coverage, and along with low investment returns, these actions caused the fund to become bankrupt. Congress then was required to shift financing to the treasury's general fund and government debt. Contemporary proposals to allow the Social Security trust fund to be invested in private equities are likely to encounter similar problems. The army pension plan has a much smoother history. It was always financed on a pay-as-you-go basis from general revenues. Other government pensions began with disability and retirement benefits to some city employees, beginning in 1850. The first state retirement system was inaugurated by Massachusetts in 1911, and the Federal Employees Retirement Act of 1920 systematically provided federal employee pensions. The authors point out that private pensions began later and were less generous than were government programs. Private pension systems did not expand dramatically in coverage and benefits until after World War II, but were influenced significantly by public pension practices.
Chapter 2 summarizes pension economics to provide a framework for the subsequent discussion. Chapter 3 reviews the history of military pensions from Roman times through feudal practices in Europe and on to their use by the British government to develop the navy. American colonial practices are described, and the chapter ends with a comparison of the army and navy systems. Chapters 4–7 present the development and management of the American naval pension system. Very useful data series are provided in the chapter tables, including numbers of pensioners, outlays, key dates, benefit payments, and the value and investments of the naval pension fund. Problems with the administration of the fund and its ultimate bankruptcy are described. The authors also suggest how the naval fund relied upon and at the same time stimulated the growth of broader U.S. financial markets. Chapter 8 presents the army's pension development from the Revolutionary, Civil, and Indian war pensions through more modern conflicts. Once again, the data tables are very complete and informative. Chapter 9 turns to the development of federal employee pensions and describes the growth of public-sector unions in influencing the timing and nature of the plans. State and local worker pensions are discussed in Chapter 10. These began with police and fire department pensions and spread to teachers and other municipal and state employees. Key inaugural dates and state plan provisions are summarized. Funding arrangements also are detailed. Chapter 11 draws some useful lessons from these pension histories to the current policy debate. The authors summarize four points: monitoring costs affect the timing and characteristics of public sector pensions; moral hazard and administrative problems plagued the plans and in some cases were only recently, if ever, overcome; the pensions grew dramatically, pushed, in large part, by politics; and the growth of public pensions and their generosity had effects on labor markets throughout the economy.
All in all, this is valuable economic history that informs current debate. The book serves as an important reference for all scholars who work on U.S. labor market issues, as well as those interested in the provision and financing of certain government services.