Eric Lohr's Russian Citizenship is a formidable achievement. At only 190 pages long, the text is concise, yet comprehensive. The author manages to weave the subject of Russian imperial and Soviet citizenship policy into a clear chronological narrative, while identifying and concentrating on recurring themes, and offering instructive comparisons with the policies of other international powers. His study will appeal to specialists and more general readers in equal measure: it offers introductions to key policies, historical periods, and geographical regions in Russia, and although it contains much fascinating detail, it always uses the different case studies to illuminate the broader picture.
As the book adds the Russian sitiuation to the rapidly growing literature on citizenship, it fills an important niche. Moreover, it presents historians of Eurasia with an innovative contribution to the history of the shifting conceptual and physical boundary between foreigners and Russian subjects/citizens over the last 300 years. Although patterns of migration, the passport system, and, especially, minority policy have been addressed by previous studies, Russian citizenship has never been analyzed in such a clear and holistic manner. The fact that the investigation tracks “citizenship in practice” adds to its appeal: rather than focusing on laws, it tells the story from the perspective of lower-ranking officials, making ample use of archival records from the police, border guards, and local authorities.
Lohr takes the reader from the era of early modern Muscovy into the 1930s, identifying both striking continuities and dramatic policy shifts. He pays particular attention to changing laws and attitudes concerning naturalization and denaturalization, immigration, and emigration. By introducing the neglected concept of subjecthood/citizenship into the analysis of Russian society, he is not only in a position to track similarities and differences with neighboring powers but also offers a new point of entry into the study of imperial rule over a culturally heterogeneous population.
Although many authors have discussed inequalities in Russian society, examining the specific rights and obligations of ethnic and religious “others,” Lohr asks the important question of how groups and individuals became included in, or excluded from, that society in the first place. This question not only helps to chart the shifting boundary between foreigners and subjects/citizens, but also offers new insights into the field of imperialism and nationality policy. Crucially, the analysis shows that successive regimes used citizenship policy as a filter for keeping unwanted groups out and making desired segments of the population stay.
Seeking to identify a “Russian citizenship tradition,” the book documents that the key to subjecthood under the old regime was a policy of “separate deals”: separate arrangements were made with many different groups of subjects (divided by religion, nationality, and social estate) who received distinctive privileges, obligations, and exemptions. Although the Great Reforms of the 1860s pushed for greater legal equality and administrative uniformity, the system of separate deals was replaced only after the collapse of tsarist rule. The idea of modern, inclusive citizenship was turned into law under the Provisional Government in 1917; however, as the Bolsheviks soon reintroduced hierarchies and discriminations (this time on the basis of class), it was short lived. Stalin's closure of the citizenship border in the 1930s, which resulted from restrictive trends that began during the First World War and the October Revolution, amounted to a radical break with previous practices, perhaps “the most decisive break in citizenship history that any major country has ever experienced” (179).
Lohr juxtaposes his findings to scholarship on related developments in Germany, Britain, the United States, and the Ottoman Empire. He also traces some of the interactions and reciprocal influences among citizenship policies in these countries, not least the effects of German “guest worker” legislation on immigration and naturalization policy in late imperial Russia. Comparisons not only allow the author to challenge entrenched dichotomies (for example, the ius soli principle in the West versus the ius sanguinis principle in the East) but also help to identify Russian particularities: the keenness to “attract and hold” new subjects (which explains the automatic naturalization of entire populations after conquest), the persistent opposition to emigration and denaturalization, and the severe isolationism under Soviet rule, when “attract and hold” was reduced to “hold.”
It is difficult to fault a book so carefully researched and well written. The section on Soviet history would have benefited from further differentiation and a more detailed discussion of the post-1930s period (with greater emphasis on the infamous system of residence permits). Most importantly, however, the book's key novelty, the exploration of modern Russian history through the prism of citizenship, is also its greatest weakness, at least for historians of Russia. The author concedes that the number of non-subjects/citizens was small, and that other categories such as estate, religion, or guild were far more important. Although the focus on citizenship is new and insightful, the question remains as to how important a concept it really was for Russian society as a whole.
