Carlos Machado's (M.'s) fine book amasses a wealth of new and old archaeological and epigraphic evidence, along with a wide range of texts, to demonstrate how Late Roman aristocrats used urban space to both accrue and manifest power – political, social, and religious. His focus on urban space offers a coherent lens through which to explore the influence of the Late Roman senatorial aristocracy whose “social and political strategies … remained remarkably consistent over the three centuries covered in this study, in spite of violent political changes and radical religious developments” (2). Although the senatorial aristocracy has been the object of much study in terms of its religious choices, office-holding patterns, and political interactions, this book consistently focuses on their use of urban space. As such, M.'s study offers an important alternative path for considering Rome and its residents, elites and non-elites alike.
The organization of the book reflects M.'s aims. After an introduction that lays out major themes and evidence, M. divides his book into three parts. Part 1 (“The definition of urban space”) focuses on the evolution of relations between emperors, aristocrats, and the city, before turning in chapter 2 to their role in “Building Late Antique Rome.” M. is right to highlight the central role played by the city's chief magistrate, the urban prefect. This position was studied in great detail by the eminent epigrapher and historian André Chastagnol.Footnote 1 But new epigraphic finds, as well as a fresh appreciation that religion was not the key dividing force among senatorial aristocrats (as was once believed), allow M. to arrive at a sharper understanding of the evolution of this office. As a mediator not only between emperor and Senate, but increasingly, in the 5th c., as the representative of the Senate to the populace and to the Church, this office became newly powerful. So, for instance, the urban prefect gained dominance over the prefect of the Annona likely by the early 5th c. (47), leaving the urban prefect with the primary responsibility for the distribution of bread in centers scattered through the city. No wonder, then, that this office – which gave senators visibility and influence over the lives of the city's residents and visitors – came to be viewed as the pinnacle of a senatorial career.
In Part 2 (“The uses of space”), M. considers certain social dynamics in specific areas of the city that allowed Late Roman elites to act out their positions. Chapter 3 focuses on “Emperors and senators in the Roman Forum.” The growing presence of senatorial civic elites in the Late Roman Forum, as manifested by statues and inscriptions, coincides with the distancing of the emperors from the city in the 4th c. after Maxentius and for the early part of the 5th c., until the return of Valentinian III in the 440s.Footnote 2 In the later 5th and 6th c., the continued focus of senators on the Roman Forum demonstrates their commitment to the city. Chapter 4 expands this dynamic by considering the public, civic spectacles that had traditionally allowed elites and emperors to manifest their power in front of the populus. Here, too, the physical presence of the aristocracy and the movement away from a focus on emperors demonstrates the growing influence of Late Roman aristocrats in civic life.
A parallel development took place in the religious spaces in the city, which M. sketches in chapter 5, the last of Part 2, “The redefinition of religious life.” M.'s summary of a very rich and complex issue prompts more questions. What happened to the site of the Taourobolium celebrations (178–80)? What about the temples of the Great Mother in Rome? What role did wealthy priests play in the building of churches and in the patronage networks of senatorial families? Why were there so few constructions recorded by officials, both pagan and Christian (186)? Conflicts over baptismal rites are discussed, but what more can we say about the construction of baptismal fonts (186–87)? These fascinating questions deserve more discussion by scholars. Nonetheless, M.'s essential argument is convincing: senatorial aristocratic families were leaders in religion, as in politics, and they used their control of urban spaces to advance and shape the Christianity that developed in the city.
Part 3 (“Domestic spaces and the privatization of power”) is perhaps the most important part of the book. M.'s analysis in chapter 6 of how senatorial houses functioned as “Centres of power” offers surprisingly intimate insights into the lives of men and women. So, for example, we learn that the late 4th-c. Roman aristocrat Symmachus personally selected the Bithynian marble columns for the reconstruction of his father's home (207, Symm. Ep. 1.2). In chapter 7, “Aristocratic power and politics in the domestic sphere,” M. describes a number of excavations of exceptionally well-documented houses, focusing in one section on the houses on the Caelian Hill identified with the aristocratic Symmachi, their friend Gaudentius, and the Valerii (243–50). As M. explores the evidence for the large reception hall of Symmachus (245), richly decorated to impress visitors, I am reminded of Symmachus's expressed desire to build with the most lavish materials possible, one more detail that makes vivid the individuals who inhabited these spaces. But these elite houses were not just built to impress. Time and again M. demonstrates that they also served official, public purposes, as, for instance, when the senator and consul Faustus had the Senate meet in his home to receive and ritually acclaim the Theodosian Code on December 25, 438 (201).
The brief concluding chapter allows M. to return to his main argument: that the Roman senatorial aristocracy manifested their power through new and increased control over urban spaces in Late Antique Rome. But M. also develops a secondary theme. In his view, the donations of houses and properties by the senatorial elite to the Church not only represented “an important element in the relationship between members of the elite and their bishops” (261), but also led to the erosion of “part of the basis of their dominance over the city and its population” (262). I have doubts about this reading of the impact of the donations of elite houses to the Church. Most senators owned more than one urban residence. Hence, donations of houses did not necessarily mean a loss of hegemony in the city. Just as likely, the donations of elite houses could be a reflection, as M. himself observes, of “changing patterns of social interaction taking place in the domestic sphere” (268). These changes were likely the result of multiple factors, including, for example, the importation of new patterns of public giving used for manifesting dominance, new industries in the city with evolving needs, or a reduction in the number but not the influence of elite families.Footnote 3 The repurposing of some elite houses as charity centers provides another example of how aristocrats augmented the wealth of the bishop while simultaneously advertising their influence. Hence, the interpretation of these domestic changes calls for further research and wider analysis of the evidence.
But my questioning of this interpretation of such donations does not detract at all from the value of this book. M. has amply demonstrated that the Roman senatorial aristocracy came to shape the urban spaces of Rome from the 4th c. into the early 6th c., leaving a lasting impact on the city and its history. Moreover, aristocratic control of urban spaces reshaped the city, as the growth of private fora showed. Thus, as M.'s work underscores, the senatorial aristocracy deserves greater credit than is traditionally given them for forming and preserving the city's monuments and urban spaces in the face of the 5th-c. political and military disasters traditionally associated with the decline and fall of Rome.
