Shannon Bontrager’s ambitious new book, Death at the Edges of Empire: Fallen Soldiers, Cultural Memory, and the Making of an American Nation, 1863-1921, analyzes the commemoration of military dead in American cultural memory from the Civil War to World War I. During this period, the dead—in flesh and idea—became a powerful tool for shaping national identity at home and abroad. Bontrager grounds his interpretations in historian Jan Assmann’s theories of cultural memory, arguing that, in this case, cultural memory was built through the collaboration of government officials, elites, and middle-class white Americans. Bontrager argues that this collaboration began with the Gettysburg Address and Abraham Lincoln’s promise to commemorate the dead, a promise that enlisted both the government and its citizens to actively remember the sacrifice of fallen soldiers. However, Bontrager does not simply revisit the well-trodden ground of Civil War commemoration. Instead, he carefully follows the development of this new “Lincolnian tradition” of obligation toward the dead to demonstrate how Americans unified the nation and pursued the country’s imperialistic goals in the decades after the Civil War. According to Bontrager, the work of handling the dead (both materially and metaphorically) allowed Americans to adapt “the canonical obligations of memory that Lincoln uttered at Gettysburg and [apply] them to new locations on the frontier to soften the violent legacy of an imperial history that often invalidated memories of republicanism” (25).
To document the work of empire-building, Bontrager analyzes a range of commemorative practices that vary in form, scale, and location. He takes readers through such diverse events as the establishment of national cemeteries after the Civil War, including one in Sitka, Alaska; the funeral of General George Custer; the raising and re-sinking of the USS Maine in Cuba; the repatriation of soldiers’ remains from the Philippines; and the dedication of the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier in Arlington National Cemetery. He organizes his chapters chronologically, dividing the book into three sections that align with Assmann’s techniques of cultural memory: storage, retrieval, and communication. This added layer of structure to the text points to one drawback: While the scope of Bontrager’s study is fascinating, the analysis is so tightly bound up in multiple layers of theoretical framing that it can overwhelm the historical narrative. This is especially distracting in Chapters 6 and 7, which analyze, respectively, the experiences of a single Jewish American soldier killed in World War I and the creation of a World War I archive in North Carolina. The narrow focus of these chapters requires an extensive articulation of the theoretical relationships between these case studies and the book’s larger argument, hindering their full integration into the narrative of the text.
Other chapters in the book, however, offer a compelling analysis of how cultural memory intersected with America’s imperial aspirations. Chapter 4, which analyzes the USS Maine, details how the 1912 recovery of the ship and its human remains activated a cultural memory that reinforced a belief that the 1898 Cuba invasion had been a moral expansion of American republicanism, rather than an imperialistic power grab. At the same time, the raising of the ship allowed for a full investigation into the cause of the sinking, potentially threatening the accepted narrative that Spanish explosives were to blame. Such narratives reveal the paradoxical power and fragility of cultural memory “at the edges of empire.” Bontrager offers a similarly thoughtful analysis of President Harding’s dedication of the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier in 1921. Although grieving families and government officials held potentially conflicting claims to the memory of the dead, Bontrager’s close reading of Harding’s dedication speech (a skill he applies to several political speeches throughout his book) demonstrates how its rhetoric adapted the Lincolnian promise to World War I. Harding successfully brought together disparate local memories “into a single harmonized national memory” that celebrated republican virtue while masking the government’s aspirations for global power (287).
Bontrager is careful to acknowledge that cultural memory was inherently exclusionary, especially for Native Americans, African Americans, Cubans, and Filipinos. Military practices of handling and remembering the dead articulated whose lives and deaths mattered. The federal government colonized indigenous lands, using the blood of slain American soldiers to symbolically claim the West. It also erased a village of emancipated freemen at Arlington to create an imperialistic “Valhalla” that reframed the Civil War as a conflict of reunification rather than emancipation. Abroad, the military tried unsuccessfully to claim the Philippines through the burial of slain soldiers (their bodies were eventually repatriated). Bontrager shows the domestic and colonial politics of race and citizenship to be one and the same, highlighting why historians need to be clear about who is included in the term “American.” The complexity of Death at the Edges of Empire, however, means that stories of alternative cultural memories (or even contests over memory) are only occasionally discussed.
Still, Bontrager’s wide sweep means that scholars with different specialties will find this book valuable. Military historians will benefit from Bontrager’s tracing of the ideological link between Lincoln’s Gettysburg promise and the imperialistic successes and failures of the Spanish-American War and World War I. Methodologically, the book also highlights how memory studies allow us to locate new relationships between war, national identity, citizenship, and imperialism in the late-nineteenth and early-twentieth centuries. Finally, scholars in death studies will be especially interested in the debates and struggles that accompanied the military’s physical handling of soldiers’ remains and the debates that surrounded the decision to bury World War I soldiers in France.
