In his 313 page overview (excluding appendices and bibliography) of the over 4 decades of evolution of the Canada Pension Plan, Bruce Little covers most of the technical, political, and economic issues involved in originating, managing and sustaining, for an unknowable future, a national mandated defined benefit system in a modern confederated democracy. Complexities of program design, financing, assumptions both economic and demographic and the inevitable cost projections are set out in clear and detailed fashion. No important story in the struggle to sustain the program has been left untold, and the technical and political contexts are carefully interwoven.
For the student or practicing professional in the sphere of pension economics, especially that space occupied by defined benefit contributory mandated systems, efforts to digest the text will be amply rewarded. The reader will find plenty of opinions by experts and others to challenge and, occasionally, entertain.
Of particular interest are the following.
The flaws in the original system design, and the reasons for those flaws, are cogently treated, notably the deliberate setting of the initial contribution rate (3.6%) at a level much below the originally projected ‘paygo’ rate (5.5%). One important result was the postponement of the amortization of the initial unfunded liability; another was the embedding of intergenerational inequity in the scheme, themes that Little returns to on a recurring basis throughout the text.
A useful discussion is provided regarding the implications of the investment management of the initially positive cash flows of the original design – the provinces borrowed at favourable rates pro-rata to contributions made by their workforces – for provincial and federal finance. We learn that, while the federal government was technically merely the administrator of the system, and not theoretically responsible for its liquidity or solvency, there were severe potential implications for the wider economy and the federal government of the drying up of flows to the provinces creating the potential for replacement borrowing and driving up interest rates. The author makes clear how the peaking and decrease in the cash flow resulted from the initial design and ultimately served as a key driver of the push to make the system more sustainable.
Also noteworthy is the treatment of the rather cavalier management of the system in its early formative years and those repairs that were necessary in order to ensure the emerging financial stress was rigourously addressed by federal and provincial politicians. Of special interest is the discussion of the mechanics of the contribution adjustment schedule approach, its relationship to the projections made in the periodic actuarial reports and its critical role in bringing about the reforms that ‘fix’ the future.
The text strongly focuses on the various emerging problems, some foreseen from inception, many not. New benefits were routinely added to the system without sufficient consideration of their cost implications. Particularly instructive is the discussion of the relaxation of the eligibility conditions for disability benefits and the consequent effects of recession compounded by court rulings that were given wide interpretations by administrators and adjudicators.
Similarly, Little includes interesting material based on official actuarial cost projections that reveal how the key factors of changed demographics (lower fertility and mortality), economics (slowed productivity growth), benefit improvements and worsened disability incidence and recovery rates affected subsequent cost projections. These showed an alarming ‘unsustainable’ projected ‘paygo’ contribution rate of 14.2%, sparking the drive to reform the system.
Little comprehensively reviews the public debate over the future of the system that arose out of the release of the official projections reporting on the outlook for the system and the dawning awareness of the ‘new’ future contribution escalation. He shows how the debate spanned the political spectrum and produced recommendations ranging from increasing contributions and benefits to scrapping the system in favour of a Chilean-style reform. He carefully explains how the debate was framed by bureaucrats and politicians and ultimately was resolved by recognition that the prevailing views of experts and the general population was to ‘fix’ things, not set out on experimentation. Readers familiar with the Chilean approach will be interested in analysis of its suitability by various Canadian experts that Little recounts.
Little is painstaking in his approach to describing the process whereby the ‘sustainable’ contribution rate is determined; it turns out to be as much political as scientific. The reader thereby comes to an appreciation of the fundamentally chimerical nature of the system; a defined benefit wrapped in a defined contribution. Little guides us through the extensive research, evaluation and national consultative process that eventually ‘fits’ the benefits – actually this means cuts the benefit – to the ‘sustainable’ or ‘steady-state’ contribution rate. The deliberations over what such a rate could be are equally well discussed. It turns out to be 9.9%.
As a case study in the analysis of the economic and political factors favouring or disfavouring various reform alternatives of a national defined benefit pension system in the context of multi-level government negotiations, the text is a success. However, in this reviewer's opinion, much of the voluminous detail (meetings, dates, participants, media reports etc.) is tedious, of little benefit, might tend to repel the international readership, and could well have been relegated to the appendices.
Little emphasizes that a key ingredient of the reform, one that was expected to make a major contribution to reducing projected costs to the steady-state rate (by pursuing an expected real rate of return of the order of 3.8% p.a.), is the decision to invest the increasing cash flow resulting from the reform in the private markets. He explains in detail the process whereby political and stakeholder agreement on the principles was achieved. He also provides useful insights into the mechanics whereby the governance and investment operations of the emerging fund (which would become the largest pension fund in Canada) would be structurally and legally separate from government or political influence via the creation of an independent board which would engage professional management. Expert views on the merits of alternative investment policies are not neglected including argumentation on the feasibility of pursuing active management vs. index replication approaches.
The text deals with a complex system and its dynamics over its relatively short, but turbulent history, and Little does a commendable job of providing a comprehensive account. This reviewer would like to have seen more tabular displays and charts of the data, assumptions and projections that serve to inform and crystallize the narrative. Also, I found the frequent discussions of the jousting and posturing of political personalities, and the detailed accounts of a multitude of meetings, and interviews etc. a distraction, notwithstanding their relevance to the unfolding of the story. Also, in my view, there is room for much more in the way of analyses of the sensitivity of the various projections to drifting off course due to shocks to or parameter shift in respect of the more significant of the assumptions. Without these, it is difficult to assess the likelihood of the outcomes discussed throughout the text.
Fixing any future is a daunting challenge. This book looks at the Canada Pension Plan and the efforts to make it sustainable. Have they done so? In my opinion, it is too soon to say. Keep an eye open for the projections yet to come.
