Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-wxvwp Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T15:58:53.540Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Taylor–Couette flow of polymer solutions with shear-thinning and viscoelastic rheology

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  30 October 2020

Neil Cagney
Affiliation:
School of Engineering and Materials Science, Queen Mary University of London, Mile End Road, London E1 4NS, UKDepartment of Mechanical Engineering, University College London, Torrington Place, London WC1E 6BT, UK
Tom Lacassagne
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical Engineering, University College London, Torrington Place, London WC1E 6BT, UKIMT Lille Douai, Institut Mines-Télécom, Univ. Lille, Centre for Energy and Environment, F-59000 Lille, France
Stavroula Balabani*
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical Engineering, University College London, Torrington Place, London WC1E 6BT, UK
*
†Email address for correspondence: s.balabani@ucl.ac.uk

Abstract

We study Taylor–Couette flow of a glycerol–water mixture containing a wide range of concentration (0–2000 ppm) of xanthan gum, which induces both shear-thinning and viscoelasticity, in order to assess the effect of the changes in rheology on various flow instabilities. For each suspension, the Reynolds number (the ratio of inertial to viscous forces) is slowly increased to a peak value of around 1000, and the flow is monitored continuously using flow visualisation. Shear-thinning is found to suppress many elasticity-controlled instabilities that have been observed in previous studies of viscoelastic Taylor–Couette flow, such as diwhirls and disordered oscillations. The addition of polymers is found to reduce the critical Reynolds number for the formation of Taylor vortices, but delay the onset of wavy flow. However, in the viscoelastic regime (${\geq }1000\ \textrm {ppm}$ concentration), the flow becomes highly unsteady soon after the formation of Taylor vortices, with substantial changes in the waviness with Reynolds number, which are shown to be highly repeatable. Vortices are found to suddenly merge as the Reynolds number increases, with the number of mergers increasing with polymer concentration. These abrupt changes in wavelength are highly hysteretic and can occur in both steady and wavy regimes. Finally, the vortices in moderate and dense polymer solutions are shown to undergo a gradual drift in both their size and position, which appears to be closely linked to the splitting and merger of vortices.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2020. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Table 1.Rheological properties of each of the solutions of xanthan gum in glycerol–water studied. The mean effective flow index, $\overline {n_e}$, is obtained by averaging the value of $n_e$ (2.3) found over the range $Re = 50\text {--}1000$. The suspension regime is characterised based on the trends in $\mu _0$, $\lambda _c$ and $\lambda _r$, as shown in figure 3.

Figure 1

Figure 1.Variation in the measured viscosity with strain rate for each of the eight fluids examined, with varying concentrations of xanthan gum. The lines represent the best fit to the Carreau model, with the various Carreau parameters listed in table 1. Data points where the measured stress was less than 0.02 Pa were neglected.

Figure 2

Figure 2.Variation in the storage ($G'$) and loss ($G''$) moduli with oscillations frequency for each of the eight polymer solutions. The open symbols denote the loss moduli, and the closed symbols denote the storage moduli. The relaxation time is defined based on the oscillation frequency at which the magnitude of the $G'$ exceeds that of $G''$, which only occurs for $c \geq 100\ \textrm {ppm}$, (c,d). The tests were performed using a maximum applied strain of 5 %.

Figure 3

Figure 3.Variation in the zero shear viscosity $(a)$ and the relaxation and Carreau time scales $(b)$ as a function of polymer concentration. The dashed grey lines indicate the approximate boundaries between the dilute (D), semi-dilute (SD) and concentrated (C) regimes, based on qualitative comparison with the rheological measurements of Wyatt & Liberatore (2009) for xanthan gum in pure water.

Figure 4

Table 2.Experimental conditions used in the measurements for each polymer solution. The mean quantity of $De/Re$ is found by averaging the values in figure 5 over the range $Re = 50\text {--}1000$. The number of tests, $N_{tests}$, refers to the repeated measurements in which the Reynolds number was slowly increased (i.e. it does not include tests in which the cylinder was decelerated).

Figure 5

Figure 4.Sketch of the test section and flow visualisation system used, showing the flow cell, the axis of rotation of the inner cylinder, the light source and the camera.

Figure 6

Figure 5.Variation in the effective flow index, found using (2.3) and the Carreau parameters listed in table 1$(a)$ and the elasticity for each fluid $(b)$. Fluids for which the relaxation time was very small ($\lambda _r \ll 0.063\ \textrm {s}$) are omitted from $(b)$.

Figure 7

Figure 6.Critical Reynolds number for the onset of Taylor vortex flow, as a function of polymer concentration $(a)$, effective flow index $(b)$ and elasticity $(c)$. Each data point corresponds to a single test run, as detailed in table 2. The effective flow index is defined in (2.3) $(b)$.

Figure 8

Figure 7.Flow maps for solutions of xanthan gum in a glycerol–water solvent for various concentrations. The vertical dashed white lines denote the critical Reynolds numbers for the onset of Taylor vortex flow and the wavy instability, while the large white circles indicate merger of neighbouring vortices. The corresponding frequency maps are shown in figure 8. $(a)$ 0 ppm. $(b)$ 20 ppm. $(c)$ 50 ppm. $(d)$ 100 ppm. $(e)$ 200 ppm. $(f)$ 500 ppm. $(g)$ 1000 ppm. $(h)$ 2000 ppm.

Figure 9

Figure 8.Frequency maps for solutions of xanthan gum in a glycerol–water solvent for various concentrations. The dashed line represents the rotation speed of the inner cylinder (which does not vary linearly with Reynolds number for the non-Newtonian cases), while the dark regions indicate frequencies at which significant energy is occurring. The scales are arbitrary. See text for a description of how the frequency maps are calculated. The corresponding flow maps are shown in figure 7. $(a)$ 0 ppm. $(b)$ 20 ppm. $(c)$ 50 ppm. $(d)$ 100 ppm. $(e)$ 200 ppm. $(f)$ 500 ppm. $(g)$ 1000 ppm. $(h)$ 2000 ppm.

Figure 10

Figure 9.Comparison between the flow regimes observed in the current study (as seen in figure 7), and the boundaries identified by Groisman & Steinberg (1998) for a viscoelastic fluid with negligible shear-thinning. The black lines with circular markers denote the regime boundaries measured by Groisman & Steinberg, and the thick lines are from the current experiments, with line style and colour denoting the different regimes encountered. The nonlinear relationship between viscosity and strain rate means that as $Re$ is increased, the experiments follow a curved path through the $Re_c/Re_{c,0} - De/Re$ plane, starting from the bottom right of the graph.

Figure 11

Figure 10.Critical Reynolds number for the onset of wavy vortex flow, as a function of polymer concentration $(a)$, effective flow index $(b)$ and elasticity $(c)$. Each data point corresponds to a single test run, as detailed in table 2.

Figure 12

Figure 11.Variation in the dominant frequency of the wavy instability with polymer concentration $(a)$, effective flow index $(b)$ and elasticity $(c)$. The frequency was measured over the range $Re_{c,w} \leq Re \leq Re_{c,w}+200$. Each data point corresponds to a single test run, as detailed in table 2.

Figure 13

Figure 12.Brief ‘snapshots’ of the flow maps at $Re = 700$ for four suspensions of xanthan gum; 0 ppm $(a)$, 50 ppm $(b)$, 100 ppm $(c)$ and 500 ppm $(d)$.

Figure 14

Figure 13.Brief ‘snapshots’ of the flow maps at various Reynolds numbers for a solution of 2000 ppm xanthan gum. $(a)$$Re =250$. $(b)$$Re =350$. $(c)$$Re =500$. $(d)$$Re =600$. $(e)$$Re =800$. $(f)$$Re =1000$.

Figure 15

Figure 14.Frequency maps found in four repeated experiments for the solution of 2000 ppm xanthan. The distribution of energy in each map is similar, indicating that the various transitions described here and in previous figures are not the result of random processes, but are a manifestation of the complex fluid dynamics of the system. The corresponding flow maps are shown in figure 17 and are discussed in § 3.4. $(a)$ 2000 ppm, test 1. $(b)$ 2000 ppm, test 2. $(c)$ 2000 ppm, test 3. $(d)$ 2000 ppm, test 4.

Figure 16

Figure 15.Variation in the wavelength of the flow maps as a function of Reynolds number for the eight fluids tested. The wavelength was determined using the peak of the FFT calculated from the flow map (averaged into bins of $\Delta Re = 10$), as described in the text.

Figure 17

Figure 16.Flow maps for four concentrations of xanthan; 20 ppm $(a)$; 50 ppm $(b)$; 100 ppm $(c)$ and 200 ppm $(d)$. The flow maps in (a,c,e,g) were acquired as the cylinder was accelerated (and are the same data as presented in figure 7e–h), after which the Reynolds number was held constant for approximately five minutes, before the cylinder was decelerated using the same magnitude acceleration rate to acquire the data presented in (b,d,f,h). (a) 200 ppm – increasing $Re$. (b) 200 ppm – decreasing $Re$. (c) 500 ppm – increasing $Re$. (d) 500 ppm – decreasing $Re$. (e) 1000 ppm – increasing $Re$. (f) 1000 ppm – decreasing $Re$. (g) 2000 ppm – increasing $Re$. (h) 2000 ppm – decreasing $Re$.

Figure 18

Figure 17.Flow maps found in four repeated experiments for the solution of 2000 ppm xanthan. The white circles indicate the points where vortex merger occurs. The corresponding frequency maps are shown figure 14. $(a)$ 2000 ppm, test 1. $(b)$ 2000 ppm, test 2. $(c)$ 2000 ppm, test 3. $(d)$ 2000 ppm, test 4.

Figure 19

Figure 18.Summary of the axial locations and Reynolds numbers at which merger or splitting of vortices was observed. All tests were performed under identical conditions, with the exceptions of the open symbols in which the Reynolds number was decreasing with time. $(a)$ 200 ppm. $(b)$ 500 ppm. $(c)$ 1000 ppm. $(d)$ 2000 ppm.

Figure 20

Figure 19.Detail of the flow maps for two cases of vortex merger in a $c = 2000\ \textrm {ppm}$ solution; before the onset of wavy flow $(a)$ and when the flow is unsteady $(b)$. $(a)$ 2000 ppm, test 5. $(b)$ 2000 ppm, test 2.

Figure 21

Figure 20.Detail of the flow map for the 1000 ppm solution in which the Reynolds number is decreasing, showing the splitting and formation of new vortices. The entire flow map is presented in figure 16(h). Note that $Re$ decreases from left to right.

Figure 22

Figure 21.Variation in the maximum cross-correlation coefficient calculated for successive segments of the flow maps (averaged into segments of $\Delta Re = 25$) with Reynolds number. The magnitude of $R_{max}$ provides a measure of the consistency of the flow structure, with a decrease in $R_{max}$ indicating that drift is occurring.

Figure 23

Figure 22.Variation in the Reynolds number at which significant axial drift of vortices is observed as a function of polymer concentration $(a)$, effective flow index $(b)$ and elasticity $(c)$. The onset of drift is determined from the cross-correlation signals in figure 21, as outlined in the text. Each data point corresponds to a single test run, as detailed in table 2.

Figure 24

Figure 23.Variation in the non-dimensional acceleration rate (2.2) with Reynolds number for two experiments performed with a $c = 2000\ \textrm {ppm}$ solution. The higher acceleration case (dashed grey line) has been discussed in the previous sections.

Figure 25

Figure 24.Flow maps for a $c = 2000\ \textrm {ppm}$ solution, with in which the cylinder rotation speed is increased quasi-statically $(a)$ and at a faster rate $(b)$. The white stripes in $(a)$ correspond to the periods where no images were recorded as the data was loaded from the camera. The corresponding non-dimensional acceleration rates are shown in figure 23, and the data in $(b)$ has also previously been presented in figure 7. $(a)$$(\textrm {d}Re/\textrm {d}t^*)_{mean}=0.0317$. $(b)$$(\textrm {d}Re/\textrm {d}t^*)_{mean}=1.81$.

Figure 26

Figure 25.Frequency maps for a $c = 2000\ \textrm {ppm}$ solution, with in which the cylinder rotation speed is increased quasi-statically $(a)$ and at a faster rate $(b)$. The white stripes in $(a)$ correspond to the periods where no images were recorded as the data was loaded from the camera. The corresponding non-dimensional acceleration rates are shown in figure 23, and the corresponding flow maps are shown in figure 24. The data in $(b)$ has also previously been presented in figure 7. The black and white dashed lines represent the rotation speed of the inner cylinder. The rotation speed increases linearly with time; however, aliasing effects in $(b)$ cause the rotation frequency to appear to decrease at high $Re$. $(a)$$(\textrm {d}Re/\textrm {d}t^*)_{mean}=0.0317$. $(b)$$(\textrm {d}Re/\textrm {d}t^*)_{mean}=1.81$.