What do prospective parents in greater Hanoi experience when they encounter the image of a foetus on the screen of an ultrasound scanning machine? What if the sonographer tells them that the foetus has an anomaly? This powerful, heart-wrenching, and beautifully written ethnography shows how images of a foetal anomaly force prospective parents to confront a series of existential and ethical questions about humanity, social belonging, and the nature of life itself: What, they must decide, constitutes a full and complete human being? Who has the capacity to make decisions about whether or not life should be denied to this potential child? In addition to offering new views of a foetus, ultrasonography and prenatal screening in Vietnam also raise unexpected moral quandaries. As one of the fathers in the book put it, ‘it is a question of conscience’ (p. 8). As one of the mothers put it, ‘I think my child would have suffered. He would not have been able to enjoy the beauty of life. To be human means to be able to experience life, to love and to hate’ (p. 166).
Life, love, humanity, beauty, death, conscience, science, medicine and belonging — this book offers many things for many different readers. It is an invitation to ruminate on what it means to be human; it offers a window into the history and context of ultrasound scanning in Vietnam; it speaks to issues of state–society relations; it raises difficult and morally ambiguous issues about attitudes towards disability; it engages the legacy of Agent Orange; and it is an extraordinary contribution to medical anthropology. In this last respect, as anthropology, the book is also a fine example of the ethnographer's craft. Its arguments build carefully from vividly presented ethnographic details to show how human beings interface with medical technology and how patients interact with doctors and other experts in the course of making health-care decisions. The book shows how every decision about selective reproduction made in Vietnam is impacted by the larger social context of family, kin-networks, social expectations, and state policies. All of these levels of social interaction, furthermore, are carefully shown to be connected to the legacy of the Vietnam War, the lingering effects of Agent Orange, Vietnamese state commitments to population quality, the economic difficulties of raising children with disabilities in a country with limited infrastructure, as well as cultural understanding of intersubjective obligations, filial duties, and moral responsibility.
The book succeeds in weaving together all of these complex threads by focusing on thirty core cases in which there was a diagnosis of a deformed foetus. Although the research team conducted hundreds of interviews and carried out other surveys and extensive documentary research to support their findings, the great strength of the book lies in the way it makes its arguments through the fine-grained stories of select individuals. The ethnography, based on three years of collaborative fieldwork with Vietnamese colleagues beginning in 2003 and sustained over most of the decade to follow, is rich and convincing. The details provided clearly show the care and empathy that went into the fieldwork, and the descriptions show all the complex socially situated dilemmas these families face as they make their decisions. All of this contextualisation supports an important argument that the assumptions used to analyse selective reproduction in the West cannot be simply transferred to Vietnam. While reproductive decisions in the West are commonly individualised as matters of freedom and choice, in Vietnam these decisions are deeply embedded within the sociocultural community to which one wishes to belong. In this way Gammeltoft shows how decisions are socially structured and also opens up what she calls an anthropology of belonging. What seem to be individual choices are embedded in a process through which individuals establish themselves as members of their communities. Building from the philosophy of Levinas, she notes that subjectivity is not private; instead ‘subjectivity is structured in a relation of responsibility to the other’ (p. 20).
The other and the self belong together in a broader context, which the book analyses gracefully. The most striking context is the legacy of Agent Orange, which the book shows to have generated a pervasive social discourse that multiplies images of deformity throughout Vietnamese society. The result is that Vietnamese women and their families carry in their heads very disturbing images of what can go wrong with reproductive events. In this context, the government's focus on population quality tends to merge with deep citizen anxieties in the realm of reproductive choices, and the book describes people's readiness to give up a foetus if it is found anomalous. Images of Agent Orange literally haunt women; they form what one person called ‘pictures that stay on your mind’ (ám ảnh) (p. 93).
Gammeltoft's mature, sensitive, and well-paced narrative carefully avoids moralising. For example, in the book's discussion of the state's overt support for using selective reproduction to maximise ‘population quality’, it would have been easy to adopt the moralising tone familiar from studies of the topic in China. But Gammeltoft is more interested in contextualising the practice and helping readers understand it. In the process, it becomes clear that the focus on quality is not simply a top-down pronouncement foisted on the people, but is a moral dilemma all prospective parents face when confronted with a diagnosis. This observation should invite welcome debate within Vietnamese studies about the nature of state–society relations.
This book is highly recommended for readers in a wide range of fields such as science and technology studies; medical anthropology; the study of reproduction, population and health; research on the consequences of Agent Orange; and Vietnamese Studies. It could be especially valuable in public health programmes or medical schools teaching about the social dimensions of medical technologies in the developing world. While the questions raised about being, subjectivity, belonging and the nature of life itself will stimulate the mind of the most philosophically-minded social thinkers, the ethnography is so vivid and compelling that even undergraduate readers can be invited into the stories.
