State Violence and Punishment in India explores the relationship between punishment, state violence and the state during the period 1919–1956. It argues for an expansion of our understanding of colonial punishment and the state by opening up the idea of the ‘coercive network’, and exploring institutions, laws and practices in new ways. The ‘coercive network’ included prisons and corporal punishment, to be sure, but it also encompassed firing into crowds, bombing from the air, dismissal from work, expulsion from school, detention without trial, and collective fining. A range of intermediaries enforced these penal sanctions, and they became sites of negotiation and confrontation. This made the state in India “vulnerable, fluid and replete with tensions” (p. 1). In significant ways, this challenges an historiography which, Taylor C. Sherman argues, has “long taken the strength of the state for granted” (p. 2).
This book has an evident appeal to historians and political scientists interested in the history of empire, decolonisation and punishment. But it also addresses the late colonial and early post-colonial period, in order to think through questions, which are relevant now, with respect to the apparent weakness of the contemporary Indian state and its failure to meet its development goals. Sherman argues that this can be explained only if we re-evaluate the almost-taken-for-granted power of the colonial state during the middle of the twentieth century. But her argument goes further still, and she connects her view of the state to a range of government institutions and practices.
The book addresses its subject matter through a series of case studies drawn from archives in India and Britain, including government records, private papers, newspapers and vernacular publications. Many of the book's studies will be familiar to readers. But they are grounded in theoretical ideas about the ‘everyday state’; the idea that the state comes into being and is constantly reconfigured and imagined through everyday practices, including disciplinary governance but also “corruption, coercion, violence and failure” (p. 3). These studies are: the Jallianwala Bagh shootings (1919); the non-co-operation movement (1920–25); the civil disobedience movement (1930–34); the ‘goonda’ and ‘whipping’ acts in the United Provinces and Bombay respectively (1929–38); the hunger-striking Lahore ‘conspiracy’ prisoners (1929–39); World War Two (1939–45); the partition of India (1947–48); various police actions in Hyderabad (1947–56). The book's subject matter also extends over the ‘quit India’ campaign, communal riots in the 1930s and 1940s and communist insurgency. It is unusual in bridging the colonial/postcolonial divide, and it also brings the princely state of Hyderabad (often excluded from colonial histories) into its historiographical framework. It draws attention to three principal contradictions within the colonial state: its desire to rule collectives and to govern individuals; the tension between the punishment of colonial subjects’ bodies and the promotion of their medical well-being; the investment-hungry civilising mission and the economic extractions of the colonial economy.
It is possible to situate the broad arguments of the book within a longer historical literature, and to trace the ambivalence of the state for at least a century before 1919. Indeed, the issues can all be found in early to mid-nineteenth century debates. These include discussions on prisoners, convicts, flogging, penal tattooing, and prison labour, as well as about how to deal with tribal and other anti-colonial insurgents, including, of course, those convicted in the aftermath of the 1857 rebellion. Neither did the problem of state intermediaries (or negotiation and resistance) emerge out of nowhere. As I read State Violence, I was reminded of early nineteenth-century colonial investigations into jail uprisings (including during the cholera epidemic of 1816), the indiscriminate shooting dead of prisoners in the early 1850s, and ongoing corruption and violence on the part of jail warders. I thought also of nineteenth-century complaints that a huge report into jails, the 1838 Prison Discipline Report, was left subsequently to languish on a dusty shelf; and that other records were little more than vermin-chewed, disorganised bundles of paper, written by near-illiterate prison clerks. In this broad sense, historians might like to think through Sherman's arguments about the ambivalent ‘everyday state’ for a much earlier period, and give added depth to her insightful approach.
Given recent work on colonial networks, I was especially interested in Sherman's (brief) effort to consider the nature and range of state violence in India within a broader, colonial context, including Kenya, British Malaya, French Indochina and Algeria. Given the extent of extra-institutional punishments in evidence across empires well into the twentieth century, I am persuaded by her conclusion that there was no smooth transition to institutional penal confinement, but that other types of sanctions and punishments operated outside (and perhaps sometimes within) the criminal justice system. State Violence pushes us to carry out further comparative research, as well us work on other areas of governance (as well as resistance and negotiation) that constituted the ‘everyday state’. If we are to understand important aspects of the world today, this task is nothing short of urgent.
