In Crooked Paths to Allotment, C. Joseph Genetin-Pilawa challenges the dominant historical interpretation of American Indian policy development during the Reconstruction Era and the Gilded Age. Instead of portraying the decline of Indian sovereignty over the decades after the Civil War as insidiously linear, Genetin-Pilawa argues that the debate over Indian Policy was more contentious than generally accepted. Though the debate over nineteenth-century Indian policy may seem abstruse to economic historians, there is a growing body of research on the long-run effects of nineteenth-century Indian policy by both economists and political scientists (for an economic perspective, see Christian Dippel, “Forced Coexistence and Economic Development: Evidence from Native American Reservations,” forthcoming in Econometrica and for a qualitative approach, see the various papers by The Harvard Project on American Indian Economic Development). For reasons explained below, I see this book as an excellent contribution to this growing interdisciplinary literature.
The book is essentially split into two parts. The first two chapters provide an overview of Indian-federal relations from the emergence of discovery doctrine to the removal era with a detailed regional case study on the attempted removal of the Tonawanda Band of Seneca Indians. The case study provides a backdrop for the first countercultural reformer emphasized in this book: Ely S. Parker, a Tonawanda Seneca whose many careers included being a Civil War veteran, a diplomat for the Seneca chief, and the first indigenous Commissioner of Indian Affairs in 1869. The second part of the book is devoted to the career of Thomas A. Bland, a Quaker who founded the only reform organization in the late 1870s and 1880s who advocated Parker's views on tribal land management and the pace of acculturation. Genetin-Pilawa's overview of the lives and ideas of both reformers suggests that these relatively unheralded figures in the historiography of Indian policy development deserve more attention and appreciation for their promotion of counter-mainstream ideas towards Indian acculturation.
While these two individuals’ political careers did not overlap, the commonalities in their reforms did. Both Parker and Bland supported protecting Indian land titles, internal sovereignty, and a liberal-arts-based curriculum in Indian schools. However, some reforms, especially Parker's support of ending treaty making with Indian tribes, can be viewed as coinciding “with larger trends and trajectories of American colonialism typified by an ever-increasing confinement of Indian nations” (p. 93). Since Indian policy during the post-Civil War period was an assault on Indian sovereignty, culminating in land dispossession and allotment, these two reformers saw few victories; yet, John Collier and his Indian New Deal reforms of the 1930s eventually repealed allotment and supported Parker's reservation government reforms.
I do wish the author spent more time discussing the potential consequences of both Parker's and Bland's reforms. For example, one of Bland's recommendations was for the federal government to protect Indian land title by granting patents in fee to the entire tribe. Interestingly, this is precisely how the government conveyed land to the Five Civilized Tribes in Indian Territory. Seemingly, the author could have used this similarity to investigate the potential historical impact of Bland's policy alternative. As history has proven, common ownership did not provide a mechanism to solve “the problem of civilization for themselves and in their own way” (p. 126). The federal government aggressively negotiated to allot land in Indian Territory and the resulting Curtis Act of 1898 stripped the power of tribal courts and government, broke up these tribal reservations, and ushered Oklahoma into statehood. Thus, it is unclear whether late-nineteenth century policy alternatives would have been effective methods of sustaining Indian sovereignty during the larger American project of state building.
This book, however, makes a compelling case that in order to understand the development of Indian policy, it is essential to learn about the critics of rapid assimilation and the tactics used by mainstream assimilationist to suppress this movement. This view is a welcome change to the traditional trope of the inexorable decay of Indian sovereignty, forced assimilation, and land dispossession.
