The Moroccan “years of lead” began in the early 1960s with the development of a pervasive and ruthless security apparatus that arrested and jailed thousands of Moroccans for activities deemed subversive or dangerous to the state. It was not until the early 1970s that the then king Hassan II began to bend to international pressures to democratize and respect human rights. He made numerous administrative and legal changes, including the establishment of the Advisory Committee on Human Rights in 1990 and the Ministry of Human Rights in 1993, as well as the ratification of the UN Convention Against Torture, also in 1993. Upon King Hassan II's death in 1999, his successor Muhammad VI made it clear that respect for human rights would be an important issue of his reign. He had the Advisory Committee on Human Rights establish the Moroccan Indemnity Commission, which was followed by the establishment of the Moroccan Forum for Truth and Equity. These reforms were positive steps and showed citizens of Morocco and the world that Morocco was serious about changing the way the police and security forces did business, or at least appeared to do business—moving from opacity to transparency, and from brutality to upholding and following the rule of law.
There were also changes outside of the political and legal realms. In this meticulously researched and groundbreaking study, Jonathan Smolin shines a light on how beginning in the early 1990s reforms within the Moroccan security apparatus were reflected in and driven by newspapers, tabloids, advertising campaigns, novels, and television shows. Moroccan Noir deftly shows how each of these genres relied on one another for models of language, style, and form. As Smolin states, “[m]any of the changes in Morocco since the early 1990s have been examined, such as economic policy, political contestation, and human rights, among others. Nonetheless, the transformations that have taken place in the mass media—and the Arabic mass media in particular—remain one of the most understudied aspects of contemporary Moroccan society” (p. 4). This is the first in-depth study of the mass media's important role in the radical changes that occurred in Morocco during the 1990s and early 2000s.
Smolin begins with the Tabit Affair, a 1993 case that involved a high-ranking Casablanca police commissioner named Hajj Mustapha Tabit who was accused and convicted of kidnapping and raping hundreds of women and minors over a three-year period. The case marked the beginning of a new era of public scrutiny of the police and of crime coverage by the press. Until then, the police had been a symbol of brutality, operating above the law and largely in secret. In this case, however, a Moroccan police officer was shown not to be above the law. Moreover, “the press, which had operated under heavy censorship since independence, was free to write about the police, an institution considered utterly taboo” (p. 15).
In subsequent chapters, Smolin draws on newspaper and tabloid coverage of a number of high profile crimes, as well as detailed analysis of police téléfilms, to argue convincingly that crime writing—both fictional and “true crime”—played an important role in the development of Morocco's independent press, in shaping print and television portrayals of the police, and in shifting how Moroccans viewed the police. None of this occurred without the state's own involvement: in the case of the press, the police provided access to crime scene photographs and reports; in the case of television police dramas, production teams were allowed into the previously closed police stations and medical examiners’ rooms. This collaboration served both the media and the state. Through state-sanctioned sensational coverage of previously unheard of (or at least not publicly discussed) crimes such as rape, murder, and serial killing, Moroccans were put into a state of fear that, as Smolin points out (quoting David L. Altheide's Creating Fear: News and the Construction of Crisis [New York: Aldine de Gruyter, 2002]), “increases audiences for the mass media [and] also helps justify expenditures for the police” (p. 78). All of this was done with an eye toward presenting the “new” police to the Moroccan public in a much more positive light than had been the case during the “years of lead,” as well as selling newspapers. Whereas the old police were brutal, corrupt, and acted above the law, the new police were rational, bound by legal precepts, and answerable to the people whom they were meant to serve. Smolin deftly shows that, whether in party or independent newspapers, in the tabloid press, or on television, the Moroccan police force aimed to present itself in the period following the “years of lead” as modern, incorruptible, competent, and truly engaged in maintaining public safety and security. It is important to note that, despite some real positive changes in the way the state and its security apparatus dealt with an increasing depiction and expectation of a police force that works “at the service of the people” (fī khidmat al-shaʿb), abuses did not remain solely a thing of the past.
The final chapter of the book (“From Morocco's 9/11 to Community Policing”) deals with the aftermath of the 2003 Casablanca bombings as well as the establishment and relatively quick discrediting of Urban Security Units. This new security force, equipped with uniforms, vehicles, and even a slick magazine of its own, was meant to be “the visible part of the iceberg of reforms that the police has instituted recently in order to resituate the police in the role of protecting and serving citizens” (p. 210). Unfortunately, it quickly became clear that, despite the new exterior, the Urban Security Units operated under a familiar pattern of brutality and corruption. After just three years, they were disbanded. The chapter shows that, despite certain advances in the 1990s and early 2000s, many of the police reforms were merely cosmetic and literally made for prime time television.
My one issue with this fascinating book is the connections to which Smolin alludes, but upon which he does not elaborate fully. In the first chapter, for example, the author points out that “Morocco was not the only country at the time that was experiencing a radical transformation in depictions of sexuality in the media” (p. 28), and then goes on to discuss the rise of the “tabloid decade” in the 1990s in the United States. While interesting that this change in crime coverage occurred in the United States and Morocco simultaneously, I was left wondering why this was the case. Was media changing on a global level? Similarly, in the last chapter on the Urban Security Units, Smolin mentions how the Casablanca bombings resulted in new Moroccan antiterrorism laws that quickly overreached their stated goals of maintaining national security, similar to what occurred in the United States following 9/11. Smolin does connect the attacks and the subsequent legal changes. However, his later discussion of police reforms and the establishment of the Urban Security Units left me to wonder what further links could be made between the U.S.-led “Global War on Terror,” the boom in police and security funding in the United States and abroad, and other security agreements struck between the United States and Morocco during this time, such as the one that allowed the United States to use so-called black sites for “enhanced interrogation.”
These minor criticisms aside, Smolin's research is impressive for its scope and attention to detail. Through archival research, interviews with key players, and media analysis, he has produced an invaluable study that will be of interest to anyone working on Morocco's recent history of human rights abuses and moves toward reform, the role of fictional writing, media, and television in these reforms, and the way that the state both controls and reacts to the shifting terrain of security and human rights. He brings together a number of previously separate fields (human rights, media studies, literary criticism) to vividly tell the story of the Moroccan state, police, and media during a period of critical change.
