Over the last two decades, a renewed interest in the music of Franz Schubert has inspired a collection of work notable not only for its sheer volume, but also its diversity. This scholarship has brought to light new documentary sources, deepened our understanding of some of Schubert’s lesser-known pieces, developed new theories and analyses of his music, and broadened our knowledge of Schubert’s life, world, text-setting habits and historical reception.Footnote 1 As a result, scholars have at their disposal an unprecedented bounty of theoretical, historical, and documentary resources that have allowed for a host of new insights and perspectives to emerge about the composer, his music and his world.
Lorraine Byrne Bodley and Julian Horton’s recent book, Rethinking Schubert contributes to this growing literature by bringing together essays from many leading Schubert scholars, all of which were either presented at the 2011 conference Thanatos as Muse? Schubert and Concepts of Late Style or commissioned afterward.Footnote 2 The editors intended to differentiate this volume from other collections of essays on Schubert in two ways: by highlighting how Schubert reception and music analysis can influence one another, and by integrating French-, German-, and English-language Schubert research under one cover (p. xi). The latter goal is indicative of the editors’ larger desire to put forth a volume that intermixes a multiplicity of voices, methodologies, subjects, and perspective, and it marks a significant strength of the volume. Given this goal, Rethinking Schubert consolidates many of the recent disparate developments in Schubert research, allowing readers to easily witness the vibrancy and plurality of contemporary Schubert scholarship.
The book is organized in three main sections that loosely coalesce around the subjects of Schubert’s late style, harmony and form in his instrumental music, and issues of music and text. Moreover, within each section, the editors organized the essays so that, despite the book’s diverse array of approaches, repertoires, and subject matters, implicit dialogues take shape from chapter to chapter, meaning that the reader is rewarded for reading the book from cover to cover.
The book’s title implies a revisionist agenda that the editors clearly hoped to pursue.Footnote 3 Indeed, the stated goal of the volume is to ‘subject recurring issues in historical, biographical and analytical research to renewed scrutiny’ (p. 3). However, the introduction makes clear that the book’s titular concern with ‘rethinking’ Schubert should be interpreted broadly. On the large scale, the editors aimed for the essays as a whole to provide a re-evaluation of Schubert’s compositional legacy, by illuminating the ways in which Schubert has been historically misunderstood or misrepresented (p. 4). But they also clearly intend these chapters to individually lead us to ‘rethink’ both how we understand Schubert’s life and reception history as well as how we analyse and interpret his music.Footnote 4
Interpreted in this way, many of the chapters in this collection do accomplish the volume’s revisionist goal. Still, the use of the title for the current set of essays is not without its issues.Footnote 5 The following summary of Rethinking Schubert, therefore, highlights some of the essays that most exemplify the book’s titular concern, while also bringing out some of the implicit dialogues that emerge within each section. This summary is followed by a brief critique of the book’s broader aspirations of ‘rethinking’ Schubert.
Part I contains five essays written by Hans-Joachim Hinrichsen, Walter Dürr, William Kinderman, Susan Wollenberg, and Brian Black that explore the compositional features of Schubert’s late style. The section’s unified attention on matters of style within a small subset of Schubert’s oeuvre means that, although the essays do not explicitly respond to each other, implicit dialogues constantly emerge, making Part I of Rethinking Schubert the most cohesive of the volume’s three sections.
One question that threads through every chapter more or less explicitly is: how appropriate is the term ‘late style’ for a composer who died so young (p. 4)? Each of the chapters takes a stance. For instance, Hinrichsen’s essay, ‘Is There a Late Style in Schubert’s Oeuvre?’ notes a striking stylistic shift that occurred after 1824, marked by Schubert’s new focus on virtuosity, a use of features from his lieder in instrumental works and an emphasis on works for the public sphere. Furthermore, Hinrichsen also points out some specific compositional features that characterize this new style, including: 1) cyclic forms, 2) increased employment of contrapuntal techniques, 3) mediant relations, 4) symmetrical key schemes, and 5) the use of modulations that move through enharmonic keys.
Rather than call this a ‘late style’, though, Hinrichsen specifically describes this compositional transformation as a move to a ‘new style’, given that – in contrast to late Beethoven – it is ‘characterised not by serene consolidation and critical balancing, but by a euphoric departure on a journey which was broken off in mid-flight’ (p. 26). This latter point is key for Hinrichsen. He artfully uses biographical and historical data such as a letter from Schubert to his friend Leopold Kupelwieser in combination with music analysis to argue that Schubert began a process towards a new style in 1824 that culminated in his 1828 works. This new style, however, was abruptly cut off by his death, and should therefore be viewed as an interrupted mature middle style. Thus, it is only through biographical chance that we read elements of lateness in these final works.
By contrast, in her chapter, ‘From Song to Instrumental Style’, Wollenberg calls on the work of Martin CooperFootnote 6 to claim that three elements of lateness arise in Schubert’s music from 1818–1828:Footnote 7 (1) an accelerated compositional development, (2) a sense that Schubert stood on the cusp of a new phase in his compositional development and (3) an increased use of compositional techniques linked with purity of style such as counterpoint. To support the notion that Schubert’s post-1818 music constitutes a new, late style, she notes some common features of these works, all of which relate to the more general elements of lateness noted above. These features include, among others, a more sophisticated deployment of variation and contrapuntal techniques, a renewed predilection for symmetrical key relations and the inclusion of elements from his songs within his instrumental music such as ‘violent outbursts’ (p. 66). Interestingly, all three of these features were mentioned by Hinrichsen as traits of Schubert’s so-called ‘new style’, but were read instead as the crystallization of a mature middle style. Given the lack of explicit dialogue between the authors, however, the central question, ultimately, is left open.Footnote 8
Despite the lack of resolution, the points of agreement between the essays surrounding the characteristics of Schubert’s mature style means that any reader will come away with a good impression of this ‘new style’. For example, nearly every chapter mentions the composer’s more frequent use of contrapuntal techniques, the influence of lied on his instrumental works and his heightened attention to motivic integration. Furthermore, two essays, by Brian Black and Walther Dürr, note Schubert’s novel use of ‘sonority’ in his late works for both structural and expressive purposes. Finally, every essay notes how this late style deviates from but simultaneously challenges Beethoven’s looming precedent in various ways.Footnote 9
Part II comprises essays on style, harmony, and form in Schubert’s instrumental works, and can be divided into three subsections. It begins with two chapters on Schubert’s ‘Unfinished’ Symphony by Andrea Lindmayr-Brandl and Xavier Hascher, continues with four essays on the late piano sonatas by Cameron Gardner, Anne M. Hyland and Walburga Litschauer, Julian Caskel and David Damschroder, and concludes with a chapter by Leon Plantinga that examines Schubert’s broader instrumental practices. Of these essays, four particularly succeed in making the reader rethink some aspect of Schubert’s reception or compositional practice.
Lindmayr-Brandl’s chapter, ‘The Myth of the ‘Unfinished’ and the Film Das Dreimäderlhaus (1958)’, adeptly unravels the circumstances, myths and rumours that led to the fame of the ‘Unfinished’, while also uncovering the events and conditions that have kept those myths alive for over a century despite many of them having been proven false. In doing so, she discerns three main strands that together led to the symphony’s complex reception history: the myth of the ‘Hidden’ Symphony’s discovery, biographical relationships between Schubert and the symphony, and the tendency to emphasize Schubert’s supposedly mystical relationship to Beethoven. Lindmayr-Brandl concludes her chapter by showing how the final strand culminates in Ernst Marischka’s film Das Dreimäderlhaus – a movie about a young Schubert who falls in love with one of the three girls of the ‘Dreimäderlhaus’ that emphatically connects Beethoven’s loss of hearing to Schubert’s interrupted work on the ‘Unfinished’.Footnote 10 Moreover, she uses the film and its depiction of Schubert’s death during the symphony’s composition to show how difficult myths are to extinguish.
In ‘Records of Inspiration’, Anne Hyland and Walburga Litschauer detail what Schubert’s continuity drafts and autograph scores for the last three piano sonatas tell us about his compositional process at that time. Using these sonatas as exemplars, they show how most of Schubert’s changes to his fair copies fall into one of three categories: expansions of single parts, elaborations of transitions, and varying arrangements of repeated passages. Contrary to the myth that Schubert’s revision process mostly involved the cutting of supposedly improvised parts, Hyland and Litschauer show how Schubert’s typical revision process involved expansion, through literal and varied repeats, octave repetitions, writing in sequences, and the addition of silent bars. The authors’ observations connect well to recent research on musical form by Caitlin Martinkus on Schubert’s variation practice,Footnote 11 and begs the question of how the assorted variation techniques Martinkus identifies link with Schubert’s typical revision processes.
Their concluding case study of D. 960 stands out for bringing to light a number of specific expansions and alterations made to this sonata between the drafts and final copy. In doing so the authors draw out the many implications these changes have to both the structure and performance of this movement. For instance, they bolster the case for taking the expositional repeat despite some performers’ discomfort with the intrusive nature of the exposition’s concluding first-time bars by showing that Schubert’s revisions suggest that he, in fact, seemingly intended to heighten the passage’s dramatic effect with his revisions rather than lessen it.Footnote 12
David Damschroder’s essay, ‘Conspicuous 6-Phase Chords in the Closing Movement of Schubert’s Piano Sonata in B-flat Major (D. 960)’, also examines Schubert’s final piano sonata. This chapter concisely demonstrates how Schubert’s treatment of what Damschroder terms ‘6-phase chords’ – first-inversion chords that are interpreted as prolongations of previous root-position chords expanded through 5–6 voice leading motion – links to the various ‘intertwining’ of third-related keys throughout the finale of D. 960. Damschroder’s chapter stands out for the way he makes readers rethink their hearing of this movement in light of the highlighted voice-leading procedures. Particularly compelling is the way he links together every action space through Schubert’s use of ‘6-phase chords’.
Damschroder’s discussion of third-related keys in the S-space of D. 960/iv connects well to other research on Schubert’s use of tonally digressive passages with S-space;Footnote 13 specifically, he demonstrates one possible voice-leading mechanism that Schubert used to connect the two S-space key areas. Moreover, this discussion relates to Schubert’s three-key expositional procedures, given that many of these expositions feature second tonal areas that modulate to third-related keys.Footnote 14 Indeed, because of the prevalence of three-key expositions and tonally digressive S-spaces within Schubert’s sonata-form practices, contextualizing this analysis within the composer’s broader practices would have been a welcome addition to this chapter; for one wonders how often the voice-leading strategies discussed in this chapter instigate these two procedures.
Finally, in his essay, ‘Schubert, Social Music and Melancholy’, Leon Plantinga connects two disparate inherited views of Schubert with two opposing visions of Old Vienna. In doing so, he aligns our perceptions of a carefree Schubert with our understanding of the orderly Biedermeier era, and our notion of the pessimistic, despairing composer with our vision of the Metternich regime. Plantinga uses this connection to show how Schubert often blends aspects of domestic or social music into even his most venerated late music that often ‘[plumbs] new depths of pessimism and melancholy’ (p. 240). For example, he points out that characteristic textures from four-hand music as well as elements of Ländler often appear in more ‘elevated’ genres.
Such observations have profound implications on how we hear and perform this music. Indeed, the chapter’s conclusion discusses how most modern performances obscure the second movement of Schubert’s A Major Piano Sonata’s affiliations with dance by both playing its Andantino tempo marking considerably more slowly than intended and not performing the accompanimental articulations as Schubert may have intended. As Plantinga reveals, only by sensitizing ourselves to these features of the movement can we appreciate and bring out its stunning alternation of dance-like themes and sombre, angst-filled music.
Part III moves on to questions of text setting in Schubert’s vocal music in a variety of genres. The opening two chapters, by Michael Spitzer and Suzannah Clark, analyse some of Schubert’s less examined songs through differing analytical lenses. James William Sobaskie and Lisa Feurzeig follow with essays on his late sacred music and his final opera, Der Graf von Gleichen. The section continues with four chapters by Deborah Stein, David Ferris, Richard Giarusso and Benjamin Binder that bring renewed attention to two of Schubert’s famous song cycles: Winterreise and Schwanengesang. This quartet of essays is followed by two chapters by Lorraine Byrne Bodley and Susan Youens and a touching, concluding homage to Walther Dürr by Graham Johnson. Like Parts I and II, several essays stand out for engendering productive implicit dialogues or asking the reader to rethink either how we approach the analysis of Schubert’s music or how we hear Schubert’s songs.
For example, Spitzer’s and Clark’s chapters debate the strengths and weaknesses of a neo-Riemannian approach to analysing Schubert’s music. Spitzer’s essay, ‘Axial Lyric Space in Two Late Songs: “Im Freien” and “Der Winterabend”’, asserts that ‘neo-Riemannian mania’ (p. 253) has fostered a style of analysis that privileges harmony at the expense of other compositional domains, and argues for an analytic approach that engages other parameters, including melody, rhythm, and form. His two analyses of ‘Im Frein’ (D. 880) and ‘Der Winterabend’ (D. 938) demonstrate the benefits of a sensitivity to Schubert’s melodic constructions and foreground both the so-called axial tendencies of Schubert’s music and its tendency to drift upwards.
In contrast, Clark’s chapter, ‘Schubert through a Neo-Riemannian Lens’, presents an analysis of Schubert’s ‘Schwanengesang’ (D. 744) using both Schenkerian and neo-Riemannian theories to demonstrate the strengths and weaknesses of both approaches though a sensitive reading of Schubert’s lied. Though not in explicit dialogue with Spitzer, Clark’s chapter unwittingly mounts a supremely effective response to the former’s attacks on practitioners of neo-Riemannian theory. Despite the chapter’s titular harmonic concerns, Clark’s pluralistic use of harmony, text setting, form, voice leading, reception history, and melody in her hermeneutic reading of D. 744 directly counters Spitzer’s claim that analyses using a neo-Riemannian lens inherently privilege harmony at the expense of other musical elements.Footnote 15
Whereas the chapters by Clark and Spitzer presented diverging views on Neo-Riemannian theory, essays by David Ferris and Benjamin Binder put forth contrasting analytical readings of the same song: ‘Der Doppelgänger’. In ‘Dissociation and Declamation in Schubert’s Heine Songs’, David Ferris demonstrates how Heine depicted the theme of the doppelgänger in two of his Die Heimkehr poems – those which Schubert later set as ‘Der Atlas’ and ‘Der Doppelgänger’ – through a narrative shift that Ferris links to a process of ‘psychological dissociation’ (p. 385). Ferris then illustrates how Schubert responded both to the poem’s central doppelgänger theme and Heine’s unusual narrative technique through a variety of musical techniques including harmony, voice-leading structure, declamation and phrase rhythm and musical texture. In doing so, Ferris not only convincingly reveals a connection between the two songs, but also illustrates how Schubert’s text-setting sets these songs apart from the rest of the Schwanengesang cycle.
Binder’s reading of ‘Der Doppelgänger’ in ‘Disability, Self-Critique and Failure in Schubert’s “Der Doppelgänger”’ offers a welcome infusion of disability studies into the volume. In his analysis, Binder draws upon two conceptions of Schubert’s ‘late style’: Adorno’s understanding of late style as self-critique and Joseph Straus’s ‘disability style’ in which ‘late-style musical features might be … interpreted as representations of the “non-normative mental and bodily states” experienced by the aged or infirm composer’ (p. 420). Binder hears this song as an exemplar of both conceptions, using the notion of failure within three musical domains – repetition, dance, and song – to unite these two understandings.
Finally, Lisa Feurzeig’s ‘Elusive Intimacy in Schubert’s Final Opera, Der Graf von Gleichen’ stands out for making the reader rethink Schubert’s final opera in light of the original tale by Musäus. In her essay, she compares and contrasts Bauernfeld’s libretto for the opera with Musäus’s story, arguing that Baurnfeld’s authorial decisions in combination with the change in genre resulted in information being lost in the libretto that was in the original story. In particular, she notes that the opera’s finale does not adequately address the question of how the unusual three-way marriage between the Count, Countess, and Princess will work. Indeed, Feurerzeig postulates that the lack of resolution to this question perhaps explains why Schubert never wrote drafts for the finale.
Before closing I wish to return to the subject of the book’s title and offer a word of critique. As the above summary indicates, the editors of Rethinking Schubert have assembled a compendium of essays that often do ask us to ‘rethink’ how we hear and analyse Schubert’s music or understand his historical context. However, nearly every chapter focuses solely on Schubert’s final works, and the lack of any attention on Schubert’s earlier compositions makes the title ring somewhat hollow. Indeed, how can this volume be said to ‘rethink’ Schubert as a whole if it fails to consider a vast portion of his overall output? More pressingly, if Rethinking Schubert is to be ‘a mandate for future research’ (p. 10), how can nearly two-thirds of Schubert’s works be neglected? The lack of attention to the composer’s earlier compositions feels like a missed opportunity for an otherwise compelling tome.
Despite this minor critique, the editors of Rethinking Schubert should be commended for putting together a collection of chapters that clearly accomplishes their goal of ‘[yielding] new insights into Schubert, his music, his influence and his legacy, and [broadening] the interpretative context for the music of his final years’ (p. 3). As such, this compendium not only stands as a testament to the current vibrancy of Schubert scholarship, but also promises to be valuable resource to scholars for decades.
