Earth Matters on Stage: Ecology and Environment in American Theater by Theresa J. May is the first book-length study of North American theatre through an ecocritical lens. Its title comes from the Earth Matters on Stage (EMOS) Ecodrama Playwrights Festival, which May cocreated with Larry Fried in 2004, and reflects May's commitment to theatre as a civic practice. This commitment is evident in one of May's central arguments: “The stories we tell touch the land” by shaping policies, ideologies, and beliefs (2). Examining both canonical and grassroots North American theatre from the late nineteenth century to today, May argues that theatre has been an active participant in US environmental history by at times propagating “ecological violence” and at others refuting it (2). May's book is essential reading for anyone interested in theatre and the environment, and its breadth and accessibility make it an ideal introduction to the burgeoning field of ecotheatre.
The book is a work of ecodramaturgy, a term May first coined in 2010 to encompass theatre practice, history, criticism, and dramaturgy that focuses on ecological connections between humans and nonhuman nature and the ways in which both have been socially constructed. Ecodramaturgy has three primary aims: (1) to make visible the invisible environmental ideologies and messages in plays, (2) to create new plays that respond to pressing environmental issues, and (3) to consider how theatre can reduce its ecological footprint. The book largely moves in chronological order, mapping theatre's relationship with US environmental history by seamlessly integrating a broad historical perspective and several specific dramaturgical analyses. It heightens the significance of its historical findings by connecting ideologies like frontierism, Manifest Destiny, and extractive capitalism to environmental injustice today.
With a few exceptions, the first four chapters focus on theatre's perpetuation of destructive master narratives heralding US power, imperialism, and white supremacy. Through the example of the Public Theater's 2010 production of Bloody Bloody Andrew Jackson, which experienced massive success despite being protested by many Native American communities for its stereotypical and racist portrayals, Chapter 1 suggests that frontier mythology “continues to condone the genocidal and ecocide project of U.S. expansion from first contact into the twenty-first century” (19). May argues that theatre must examine its role in propagating frontier narratives through her analyses of two late nineteenth-century plays, Augustin Daly's Horizon (1871) and William F. Cody's The Wild West / The Drama of Civilization (1886), which successfully disseminated Manifest Destiny ideology through their claims to veracity. She concludes the chapter by connecting the frontier mythos in both plays to contemporary US politics, economics, and theatre, and urges readers to employ theatre to uncover enduring settler colonialism, champion reparations, and tell new stories.
Chapters 2, 3, and 4 build on the first chapter's examination of frontier narratives, especially that of Anglo-American entitlement. Chapter 2 focuses on the Progressive Era, particularly the debate between preservationists like John Muir who wanted to maintain America's “natural cathedrals”(63)—despite the fact that indigenous peoples had been forcibly removed to create the first US national parks—and conservationists like Gifford Pinchot and Theodore Roosevelt who argued for the efficient use of natural resources. Analyzing David Belasco's Girl of the Golden West (1905) and William Vaughn Moody's The Great Divide (1906), May shows how the frontier narrative and the preservation–conservation debate were further layered with the Edenic myth, whereby European Americans saw themselves as using labor and technology to reclaim the land on God's behalf. Chapter 3 builds on the utilitarianism of the conservation movement by analyzing popular 1920s theories of nature as either an organic machine or a replenishable energy source. However, it departs from the earlier chapters in its focus on two plays that resist, rather than propagate, then-popular socioenvironmental myths. Industrial capitalism is critiqued in Eugene O'Neill's Dynamo (1929), and ecological interconnections are explored in Arthur Arent's Triple-A Plowed Under (1936), produced by the Federal Theatre Project. Chapter 4 considers the jingoistic backlash that followed the “social and environmental policies of the New Deal” (122) through ecodramaturgical analyses of Oklahoma! (1943), a whitewashed, musical version of Green Grow the Lilacs (1931) by Cherokee playwright Lynn Riggs, and Death of a Salesman (1949), which, May argues, critiques frontierist values that result in expendability, violence, and tragedy. Although both plays have received attention from theatre historians, May's socioenvironmental lens sets her analysis apart from previous studies.
Chapters 5, 6, and 7 consider ecodramaturgy from the post–World War II era to today. They are connected through their shared focus on social and environmental justice theatre that exposes the ongoing effects of monolithic frontier myths and offers new, embodied stories about the interdependence of people and land. Chapter 5 recognizes that, in the 1960s and 1970s, “environmental and civil rights activism seemed to run on separate rails,” with the mainstream environmental movement maintaining conservation, preservation, and wilderness ideologies that treated social issues as separate from environmental issues (160). Though there was a dearth of explicitly environmental theatre, May argues that plays like Lorraine Hansberry's A Raisin in the Sun (1959), Luis Valdez's Bernabé (1970), and Sam Shepard's Buried Child (1979) anticipated the environmental justice movement. In Chapter 6, May notes the United States’ ecological turn in the 1980s and 1990s with the rise of environmental justice, ecofeminism, and ecotheatre. She focuses on three 1990s plays that she argues serve as models for how theatre can create ecological interconnections: Robert Schenkkan's The Kentucky Cycle (1991), Cherríe Moraga's Heroes and Saints (1992), and Anne Galjour's Alligator Tales (1997). In the final chapter, May examines the upswell of North American climate change theatre in the twenty-first century, specifically analyzing two plays by Canadian playwrights—Burning Vision (2003) by Métis dramatist Marie Clements and Sila (2015) by Chantal Bilodeau.
The book concludes by celebrating theatre as a site of “civic generosity” that has ecodramaturgical potential to reimagine and reinvigorate the interconnectedness of human and nonhuman communities (276). Overall, this book is a thoughtful, well-researched, and ultimately hopeful contribution to the still developing field of ecotheatre.
