The individual who provides the leitmotif of this excellent catalogue is named in the subtitle: Kutsuki Masatsuna (1750–1802), eighth Kutsuki daimyo of Fukuchiyama domain in Tanba province. Masatsuna was a renowned numismatist and the British Museum acquired over 2,500 coins from his collection in 1884. These important coins form the backbone of the Museum's collection. The catalogue of the British Museum's pre-Meiji coins is by itself an extremely important contribution to Japanology. But it is the interpretation and analysis of the collection in the sections that precede the catalogue that elevates this work. The analytical part of the book is a collaborative endeavour, with different essays contributed by leading numismatists and Japanologists. The whole project was coordinated by Helen Wang, the British Museum's curator of East Asian money. The result is a magnificent publication.
As detailed in this book, coins from Kutsuki Masatsuna's collection form the core of the British Museum's holdings, although their origin was obscured for many years. Tickets gave coins the mysterious provenance “Wills (ex Tamba)”. In the 1990s Helen Wang was able to establish that these coins were from Masatsuna's collection, “Tamba” being a nineteenth-century romanisation of the daimyo's landed title. Wang rightly points out such use of landed titles was once commonplace in numismatic parlance, although these can be sometimes perplexing nowadays. A parallel example is the collection of Masatsuna's Scottish contemporary John Stuart (1713–92) which is always designated “Bute”, of which Stuart was the third earl.Footnote 1 The book's “Acknowledgements” (p. iv) notes the attention given in 1999 in the Japanese Press to the announcement that a substantial portion of Masatsuna's collection was in the British Museum. The attention is testament to the ongoing significance of the life and work of Kutsuki Masatsuna.
As detailed in the “Forward” (p. v) by Joe Cribb, Research Keeper of the Department of Coins and Medals, this book is significant as the first catalogue of the British Museum's collection of Japanese coins. The book covers the British Museum's collection of coinage produced in Japan from the introduction of Chinese-style coinage in the seventh century ce to the final issues in this tradition in the early years of the Meiji Period. (A European-style coinage was inaugurated in 1870, a few years after the Meiji Restoration.) On the following page there is a short but useful section, “Japanese Numismatics – Bibliographic Sources” (p. vi), which provides details of more extensive bibliographies and published surveys of literature.
The first two essays are by Helen Wang and concern the British Museum's collection. The first, “A History of the Japanese Coin Collection at the British Museum” (pp. 1–12), includes an appended section that reproduces archival material relevant to the collection. The essay surveys the British Museum's collection from its inception in 1753, but emphasises the late nineteenth century – and the 1880s in particular – as the high point for acquisitions and work on the oriental collections. Interestingly, moves were made to catalogue and publish the Japanese coin collection as one of three catalogues on East Asian coins projected in 1881 by Reginald Stuart Poole, the Keeper of Coins and Medals. Poole engaged the services of A. Terrien de Lacouperie, but only the first volume, on Chinese coins before the Tang dynasty, was published. As the archives reproduced by Wang reveal in delicious detail, the project became stymied by inaccurate estimates and cost overruns. (The Minutes of the Dept. of Coins and Medals record a letter from H.M. Treasury received in 1887 in which it declined to provide further financial support and, with all diplomatic nicety, took the view that the proposal to catalogue the Japanese coins was “somewhat premature”.) Wang's essay details how significant nineteenth-century numismatic scholarship depended on a coincidence of events and individuals – skilled, interested and on hand – and how easily opportunities were lost. By the mid-1890s both Terrien de Lacouperie and Poole had passed away and with them the impetus to publish catalogues of East Asian coins or further substantially augment the oriental collections.
Wang's second essay, “How did Kutsuki Masatsuna's Coins Come to the British Museum?” (pp. 12–16), provides biographical information on three principal European individuals involved in the acquisition of the coins, as well as information on how remaining parts of Masatsuna's collection ended up in the Heberden Coin Room of the Ashmolean Museum, Oxford. With regard to the latter events a series of archives held in Oxford are reproduced.
Professor Shin'ichi Sakuraki of the University of Shimonoseki has contributed “A Brief History of Pre-modern Japanese Coinage” (pp. 17–25). This essay is an extremely important one for monetary history. The essay is not a descriptive survey of the coins, but a synthesis of scholarship on bullion flows, circulation, mints, mining and metallurgy. This concise English-language survey will doubtless be of immeasurable use to scholars and collectors who do not read Japanese but who are interested in the monetary history of Japan before the Meiji Period. (On a related point, it is stated in the “Acknowledgements” (p. iv) that Professor Peter Kornicki translated the essays by Professor Sakuraki and Professor Furuta. This information is not detailed in the book's contents page or on the title pages of the essays, where one might have expected it.)
Following Sakuraki's essay there are three essays that complement Wang's contributions and resonate themes laid out in her papers. All three examine interest in Japanese coins before the acquisition of coins from Kutsuki Masatsuna's collection by the British Museum.
Professor Peter Kornicki of Cambridge University explores “European Interest in Japanese Coins before 1853” (pp. 27–32). Interestingly, as this essay details, it was for early visitors to Japan that coins were one of three key areas of interest; the other two areas were botany and books. The importance of the year 1853 is, of course, that it was the beginning of the Late Tokugawa Shogunate, when Japan became more open to foreign trade. It is thus a more significant date for the acquisition of Japanese coins and Japanese numismatic scholarship by Europeans than the Meiji Restoration. The prospect was short-lived, however. By the late nineteenth century both coins, along with botany, had increasingly become the preserve of specialists and no longer drew the interest of visitors to Japan, even though there may have been increased opportunities to encounter them.
Another Japanologist, Professor Timon Screech of the School of Oriental and African Studies, has contributed the first of two biographical pieces that complete the analytical section of the book. Screech's essay, “Kutsuki Masatsuna – A Life” (pp. 33–47), begins by examining Kutsuki Masatsuna's family, both his ancestors and descendents. The essay seamlessly moves on to Masatsuna's interest in coins and concentrates on the contacts that he had with Europeans who visited Japan. The details of many of the interactions are fascinating and these included exchanges of coins. Moreover, Masatsuna's interest in the coinages of other nations was as scholarly as his interest in Japanese coins. As well as his publications on Japanese coins, Masatsuna published books on the European coins that he had in his own collection.
The second, shorter biographical piece by Shin'ichi Sakuraki and Nobuhisa Furuta, former Chief Researcher at the Institute for Oriental Currency in Sapporo, provides details about “Kutsuki Masatsuna as Collector and Numismatist” (pp. 49–50). The section shows Kutsuki Masatsuna in context by highlighting the numismatic circles in which he moved and his particular interests as a collector in the various coinages that had been produced in Japan.
The catalogue occupies two-thirds of the work and was produced by collaboration. There are two important introductory sections. Helen Wang has provided information on “Sources of the Coins” (pp. 51–58) and Nobuhisa Furuta on “Dates and Places of Production” (pp. 59–64). Both sections expand on matters that are pertinent to a proper understanding of the catalogue, which are rightly dealt with separately out of consideration of the catalogue format. The catalogue (pp. 65–131) was compiled by Shin'ichi Sakuraki and Nobuhisa Furuta and is divided into twenty-six sections. Each section has a clear title in bold font that is aligned to the left-hand margin, which makes them simple to locate. The catalogue is a table that occupies each verso and recto. As the eye may stray across the two-page spread, the catalogue numbers given in the verso first column are helpfully repeated in the recto final column. The whole catalogue was edited by Helen Wang, Joe Cribb and Peter Kornicki. The illustrative plates are numbered according to the pagination (pp. 133–218). All of the coins and other monetary objects (e.g. no. 1119, a bag of gold dust) are illustrated in full colour at actual size – except for the large counting board (no. 1325) shown at half actual size. The “Acknowledgements” (p. iv) state that the coins were scanned, a method of reproduction that has proved to be very impressive in this case.
As a whole, Catalogue of the Japanese Coin Collection (pre-Meiji) at the British Museum: With Special Reference to Kutsuki Masatsuna is an immensely impressive book. The catalogue, in both its arrangement and presentation, is first-class. Moreover, this book sets high standards for how scholars can elucidate the background to a collection. By highlighting the interests and concerns of past scholars, both in Asia and Europe, as well as the institutions that acquired their collections, much of importance and significance can be learned. All involved in the project and the production of this book deserve to be warmly congratulated.
