In spite of the huge amount of scholarly research and published material devoted to early modern English drama, there are always topics that have previously been neglected or sidelined, and that require a fresh approach. McFaul's wide-ranging and thoughtful study of the often strained relations between fathers and their offspring in early drama is a welcome and important addition to our understanding of the striving for male identity in the period. McFaul locates fatherhood as central in the plays of the time and impressively uses the entire corpus of extant early drama to illustrate his views and augment his argument. McFaul carefully depicts the struggle between generations, more often between fathers and sons, but also occasionally between fathers and daughters.
Though he does not specifically quote such everyday phrases as ‘like father, (un?)like son’ or ‘the child is father to the man’, what McFaul reveals in his examination of both familiar and lesser-known plays is how close to the truth such platitudes often are. A father in Renaissance drama ‘possesses a dignity he cannot quite own’ (p. 2). There is, argues McFaul, a gradual, but perceptible, move away from the supposed power of fatherhood, but this shift ‘ultimately emphasizes the destructive tendencies of patriarchal ideas’ (p. 3).
Breaking the taboo of filial devotion – arguing with, disobeying, defying or even occasionally killing the father – points to the gradual attenuating of patriarchal influence, and in play after play McFaul demonstrates how this dynamic works. The father is a ‘figure of strange doubleness’ (p. 12). He is also a ‘stay’ in both senses – a restraint and a support. McFaul is at his most persuasive when he argues that in early modern drama ‘almost all direct paternal action is presented as disastrous’ (p. 14). Familial ties ‘come to seem the cause of conflict rather than as bulwarks against it’ (p. 52). Sins are ‘conveniently displaced onto the father’ (p. 79).
Fatherhood slips easily into tyranny. The preoccupation with fathers that many plays evince also sees the same fathers marginalized, as sons and daughters try to obey but eventually shun their parent. McFaul is particularly good in revealing the number of capricious fathers there are, culminating in Lear, but starting with more staid figures earlier in the period. If these earlier plays can be said to start with fathers as restraints on the sons, ‘it ends the other way round’ (p. 98).
The few cavils one might raise with McFaul's text only serve to emphasize the book's ability to provide fresh thinking on how paternity worked (or did not work) on the Renaissance stage. For example, one might also argue that some of the dramas he examines are given rather cursory treatment and that he does not pay enough attention to the political pressures on patriarchy in the period that themselves impacted the way paternity became even more problematic in the drama. Moreover, one of the more interesting arguments that McFaul presents, culminating in his analysis of The London Prodigal, is that ‘true patrilineal identity really depends on women’ (135). One feels that this fascinating claim, though argued cogently, almost merits a complete book of its own.
McFaul is to be congratulated on supplying a first-class, thought-provoking and almost entirely persuasive work on a subject which will surely now be given more prominence in future studies on patrilineal influence in early modern drama.
