One of the key features of the history of science since 1945 has been the enormous effort put into publishing high-quality scholarly editions of the correspondence of various scientific figures. Starting with Marin Mersenne and Henry Oldenburg, those vast clearing houses of seventeenth-century science, there are now a lot of them. Among others, the letters of Isaac Newton, Robert Boyle, Albert Einstein, Charles Darwin, Michael Faraday, André-Marie Ampère, Joseph Henry, John Flamsteed, Joseph Banks, James Clerk Maxwell, Marcello Malpighi, Macedonio Melloni, Marc Pictet, Jöns Berzelius, Henry Fox Talbot and Ferdinand von Mueller are now easily accessible, whilst those of Humphry Davy and John Tyndall are in active preparation. Furthermore, there are number of two-way correspondences such as that between George Stokes and William Thomson (Lord Kelvin). This long-awaited edition of the letters of Joseph Black (1728–1799) is a welcomed addition to these texts, the more so because science in the Scottish Enlightenment is not especially well represented by editions of correspondence.
While the intention of the early editors of correspondences was to provide evidence for the internal development of science, especially during the seventeenth century, this idea was, ironically, undermined by the commitment (in most cases) to publish all the extant letters of a particular individual. As a consequence of such completeness, areas relating to individual lives, which would have previously been thought too irrelevant or inappropriate to their science to warrant study, became available. In turn, such access radically altered how historians approached their subject, since, for instance, they could view the construction of scientific knowledge in a whole range of interrelated contexts, from the home to the study, to the laboratory, to the lecture hall, to publication, dissemination, reception and legacy. Furthermore, and, in my view, of supreme significance, correspondences plot quite precisely how scientific practitioners and their knowledge relate to other key areas in culture and society, especially religion, imperialism, industry and business, as well as the state and its agencies, including the armed forces.
In these terms, Black's letters are a valuable addition to our understanding of the place of science in the broader culture and polity. Edited by Robert Anderson (a former president of the BSHS) and the late Jean Jones (who died in 2009), a historian of the Scottish Enlightenment, they cover Black's life from his late teens until his death at the age of seventy-one. In terms of knowledge of the natural world, Black's contributions can be summed up in just five words: carbon dioxide and latent heat. Yet as the editors point out in their useful and informative introduction (part of an excellent and comprehensive critical apparatus), Black made both of these discoveries before he was appointed professor of chemistry at the University of Edinburgh in 1766, at which point he ceased research in chemical philosophy. In terms of his correspondence, by 1766 only fifty-four out of a lifetime's total of 835 letters survive. Also Black was not particularly good at publishing his research – for instance, in 1783 his protégé, James Watt, whom he taught at the University of Glasgow, urged Black to publish his work on latent heat. As Peter Jones has pointed out, Black was regarded as being discourteous to the republic of letters in not publishing. His reluctance to publish doubtless accounts for Black not being elected to the Royal Society of London, though he was a founder of the Royal Society of Edinburgh.
Many of the luminaries of the Scotland of the second half of eighteenth-century and beyond corresponded with Black. They include, in addition to Watt, William Cullen, Adam Smith, Lorenz Crell, Josiah Wedgwood (both Sr and Jr), Thomas Beddoes, Antoine Lavoisier, Jan Ingenhousz and James Macie (later Smithson). There are, however, gaps, since, for instance, there are no letters between Black and his friend James Hutton. Their close institutional and geographical proximity in Edinburgh doubtless accounts for this lack, which is partially made up by a large number of references to Hutton in many of the letters published here. On the other hand there are a significant number of letters between Black and his extended family.
What all these letters tell us is that what Black was doing while at Edinburgh, aside from teaching, was undertaking an enormous amount of work in providing chemical advice for those businessmen and industrialists who needed it, for example in processes such as glassmaking and bleaching. Letter 301 exemplifies this perfectly. Written in March 1783 by the otherwise little-known Hammersmith brewer George Blake, it discusses the possibility, stemming from a very brief meeting with Black, of establishing a brewing industry in Russia using the contacts Black had made when he was invited to teach chemistry in St Petersburg. The editors have thus provided a resource which will be invaluable in the continuing endeavour to understand how in practice, rather than in theory, scientific knowledge affected and was affected by the processes of industrialization of the eighteenth century.
