Carl Braaten and Christopher Seitz, editors of I Am the Lord Your God, preface the collected essays in this tome with the following: ‘The authors contributing to this book are calling the church to be the church, and not succumb to the temptation to serve as an agent of popular religion. The Ten Commandments are an indispensable part of the substance of the Christian faith’ (p. x). From the disciplines of biblical studies, theology and ethics, fourteen scholars from five different church traditions – Catholic, Orthodox, Anglican, Lutheran and Methodist – met in 2003 at three theological conferences to discuss the Ten Commandments in order to address the need to revitalise the essential place of the Decalogue in the dual realms of church and society. Many of the essayists turn their attention to (1) the misguided notions that the Ten Commandments should be relegated to the sphere of private religion and (2) antinomianism, a pervading heresy in the contemporary Western church. The thrust of all combined essays is an attempt to recover one very fundamental aspect of the Christian life, the true worship of God fulfilled in obedience to the Decalogue. This volume sheds new light on the continuing discussion of how objective standards, universal norms and authoritative judgements have been displaced by the popular postmodern appeal to the sovereign self.
The book is divided into four main sections: (I) The Decalogue in Church and Society; (II) First Table of the Law; (III) Second Table of the Law; and (IV) The Divine Command. The principal methods and approaches of all essays are not consistent throughout the volume primarily because each essayist employs his own academic discipline in his particular essay. The two articles in the first section set the tone for the remainder of the book. Philip Turner remarks in his opening article, ‘The Ten Commandments in the Church in a Postmodern World’, that the current Western culture has great disdain for any commandments in general and the Ten Commandments more particularly. In the current postmodern milieu, Turner writes,
The notion of commandments, in short, cuts across the very way in which we now describe ourselves as moral agents; i.e., as individuals, persons, and selves who are free agents with rights rather than embodied beings with intellect, conscience, and will, placed by God in a morally ordered universe in which we are to live in obedience to a moral law. (p. 4; Turner's italics)
Christopher Seitz' aim in the second article, ‘The Ten Commandments: Positive and Natural Law and the Covenants Old and New’, is twofold: to explain why the Ten Commandments are Christian law and to identify the rationale by which Christians have employed some of Israel's positive or moral laws outside the Ten Commandments.
The focus of the bulk of the volume, found in the second and third sections, is upon the individual Ten Commandments. Thomas Oden's article, ‘No Other Gods’, tackles the first commandment (following the Protestant/non-Lutheran demarcation in this review). Oden tracks the interpretation of this commandment ‘first back through the consensus documents of the magisterial Reformation tradition, then comparing this to the Fathers, and then back to references to the “no other gods” text in the New Testament itself, letting its relevance for today speak for itself’ (p. 42). The next article, David Hart's ‘God or Nothingness’, also analyses the first commandment but from a different angle. He argues that current post-Christian Western culture is faced with two major options of belief: a belief in the salvific work of Jesus Christ or a belief in nihilism. Hart asserts that if Western Christians are going to obey the first commandment, then they must renew their acceptance of ‘self-abnegation, contrarianism, and a willingness not only to welcome but to condemn, and a refusal of secularisation as fierce as the refusal of our Christian ancestors to burn incense to the genius of the emperor’ (p. 74).
Next in this tome, Ephraim Radner's essay, ‘Taking the Lord's Name in Vain’, specifies how the third commandment has often been domesticated into an issue of oath-taking rather than about the reverence for the revealed name. Markus Bockmuehl's article, ‘Keeping it Holy’, addresses the fourth commandment and particularly issues of holiness and purity. Bockmuehl's major premise is that ‘the stress on God's transcendent holiness cannot be dismissed as the obsolete expression of a primitive mythology. It is instead the very starting point for any human encounter with Israel's God in the Old Testament – and indeed in the New’ (pp. 108–9).
William Cavanaugh addresses the sixth commandment in the next article, ‘Killing in the Name of God’. Cavanaugh argues that killing in the name of God versus in the name of the secular nation-state is the only type of killing that could be legitimate. With a bit of a twist, he contends that the killing of Christ has put an end to killing in the name of God; otherwise, ‘it is difficult to see how the cross could be construed as a victory’ (p. 144). Bernd Wannenwetsch also addresses the meaning of the sixth commandment but from a very different perspective in his essay entitled, ‘You Shall Not Kill – What does it Take? Why we Need the Other Commandments if we are to Abstain from Killing’. Wannenwetsch asserts that the Ten Commandments have a ‘perichoretic’ nature in which the interpretation and application of each commandment is dependent upon the meaning of the other commandments in the Decalogue; he demonstrates this nature by indicating interpretative relationships between the sixth and fifth commandments (or fifth and fourth using the Roman Catholic/Lutheran demarcation). In ‘Male and Female He Created Them’, Robert Jenson attends to the seventh commandment and the need of the Western church to heed the commandment. According to Jenson, the disregard for this commandment provides the chief arena for antinomianism to display its heretical head in the Western church.
The next two essays, ‘The Tongue – Fallen and Restored’ and ‘Sins of the Tongue’, written by Reinhard Hütter and Carl Braaten, respectively, examine the ninth commandment. Hütter's essay indicates how the commandment encounters Christians in what Lutherans have called the political use of the law, the theological use of the law and the parenetic use of the gospel; Braaten reminds his readers that a major affront to the ninth commandment is the popular notion that truth is ‘something we construct out of our imagination, not what we discover in the way things really are’ (p. 210). The last article to address an individual commandment is written by R. R. Reno, ‘God or Mammon’. Reno argues that avarice provides the single most powerful attack on the tenth (and eighth) commandment, and the best way to subdue it is by renouncing this world, practising charity and nourishing a love for the kingdom of God.
The fourth and final section of the book contains two essays, ‘Keeping the Commandments’ by Robert Wilken and ‘Hearts Set to Obey’ by Gibert Meilaender. Wilken provides his perspective on the appropriateness of the Ten Commandments in the public sphere with analysis of a current contentious American debate – the display of the Ten Commandments in the rotunda of the Alabama Supreme Court building. The aim of Meilaender's essay is to critique theological constructs, particularly in Lutheranism, which have led to practical antinomianism and hampered obedience to God's instructions.
Readers of this volume will note its impressive wide-ranging perspectives concerning the clarion call for Christians to reclaim the proper place of the Decalogue in church and society. On the whole, these fourteen essays are thought-provoking, scholarly and engaging. Seitz' essay is particularly noteworthy because it elucidates the way in which a flawed understanding of Jesus' relationship to the Old Testament is the primary cause of almost all dwindling of the concept of law in the church. Essayists Jenson and Hütter do a superb job accentuating the major thrall of postmodern thought (being a captive to one's supreme self) and indicating the way forward for the church (remaining faithful to the Lord God particularly through obedience to his Ten Commandments). Wannenwetsch's article is particularly instructive by demonstrating how the Ten Commandments should and must be interpreted in relation to each other if the church is going to understand more fully the significance of the commandments for interpretation, evaluation and application.
Several improvements would have made the book even more powerful and delightful. First, I was disappointed that there was no direct treatment on the commandment not to make for yourself a graven image. Furthermore, I was disappointed that the commandments on honouring your father and mother and not stealing were relegated to cursory comments of articles dealing with other commandments. In regards to the structure of the volume, the editors might have reversed the order of the two essays dealing with the commandment ‘You shall not kill’ because the second essay deals not only with not killing but also with the previous commandment, ‘Honour your father and mother’. The flow of the volume could have been further enhanced if all essayists had followed a consistent tradition for enumerating the commandments. Consistent enumeration is a larger problem for the readers of this written work than it might have been for the listeners to the original individual lectures. Finally, the flow of essays on the particular commandments would be less disruptive to the reader if all writers had followed a similar, more cohesive, outline in their treatment of the commandment.
All negative appraisal aside, this volume is refreshing to read because it admirably attacks the prevailing heresy of antinomianism in the church. Like a cautery, these articles might wound some in order to heal some. Ultimately, all of God's torah is a healing balm when we learn to delight ourselves in it. I would like to see every seminarian and all serious laity read and evaluate the claims in this volume.
