Edited collections – especially when resulting from conference proceedings – are frequently haunted by the spectres of incongruity and unevenness. Focusing as it does on a relatively narrow period and a specific historical episode – the State of Emergency in 1959–60 Nyasaland (colonial Malawi) – the book under review happily steers clear of both pitfalls. A great deal, of course, has already been written about the State of Emergency and its significance in weakening Britain's commitment to supporting the settler-dominated Central African Federation. However – a few notable exceptions aside – the focus of much of the existing literature has been on official strategies and elite African politicians.
All of the essays included in the first part of the volume (‘Local Studies’) are intended to supplement such top-down perspectives by casting the spotlight on more marginal actors and the extent to which local specificities affected their experiences of nationalism and the Emergency. Owen Kalinga, for instance, attributes the intensity of political agitation in Karonga District to the success with which both primary school teachers and the leaders of agricultural cooperatives mobilized a peasantry irked by especially harsh soil conservation regulations. Resistance to post-Second World War agricultural regulations – and to the longer-established thangata labour rent system – is also central to Wapulumuka Mulwafu's chapter, devoted to the relationships between the rural agitation of 1953, the year of the inception of Federation, and the State of Emergency in Nyasaland's Southern Province. One of the advantages of the approach espoused by both authors is that it enables them to provide important detail on the role of African chiefs and the skillful ways in which some of their number negotiated their deeply problematic intermediary position. For his part, drawing mainly on interviews with ‘prison graduates’, Kings Phiri usefully complements the focus on grievances in the countryside by exploring the extent to which petty racial discrimination in the workplace worked towards radicalizing African civil servants in Zomba, the colony's capital. Towns, however, were easier to police than rural areas. And this, in Phiri's view, accounts for the comparative restraint with which Zomba-based supporters of the Nyasaland African Congress reacted to the Emergency and the arrest of hundreds of militants during ‘Operation Sunrise’ in March 1959.
The Emergency's broader imperial and regional contexts take centre stage in Parts Two and Three of the volume (entitled, respectively, ‘Colonial Violence and African Responses’ and ‘Central African Interconnections’). The violence of decolonization has recently been the subject of intense historiographical debate. Partly inspired by Caroline Elkins's controversial study of Kenyan detention camps during the Mau Mau war, John McCracken's excellent chapter eschews the tendency ‘to treat the Nyasaland Emergency in isolation’ (188) and explores the influence of Kenyan counterinsurgency practices on Governor Armitage and other Nyasaland officials. Making due allowance for the obvious differences in scale between the two colonies’ detention systems, McCracken ably demonstrates that key features of the organisation of the Kenyan camps were replicated in Kanjedza, the emergency prison where hundreds of Malawians were detained without trial in the months that followed ‘Operation Sunrise’. Such features included not only the resort to systematic brutality and military-style discipline, but also the pathologization of the camp's inmates and their classification according to the alleged extent of their politicization. As in Kenya, moreover, ‘confession’ was regarded as the necessary precondition for ‘rehabilitation’.
Worthy of some note among the essays included in Part Three is Zoe Groves's study of the workings of the alliance between the Nyasaland and the Southern Rhodesian Congress parties before and after the institution of Federation. While her focus on white-collar migrant workers as agents of inter-territorial coordination until the emergencies of 1959 is well taken, the very limited attention she gives to northern Rhodesia begs several important questions. Tangential to Groves's analysis, the relationship between Zambian and Malawian nationalists forms the subject of Ackson Kanduza's contribution, which, inter alia, discusses the formative influence of several members of the Malawian diaspora on early African political experiments in northern Rhodesia. The author, however, is perhaps guilty of ignoring the ease with which cross-border anticolonial linkages could be supplanted by much more inward-looking agendas. Kamuzu Banda, after all, retreated into an increasingly isolationist stance from the early 1960s; at the same time, a belligerently ‘nativist’, and openly anti-Malawian, message entered the propaganda repertoire of Harry Nkumbula's ANC following the ZANC/UNIP split of 1958–9. The personal testimonies included in the volume's fourth and final part (‘Memories and Memorials’) are one of its most arresting features, though some readers might wonder whether the recollections of young Salisbury-based historian Terence Ranger have really much in common with – or indeed deserve the same attention as – those of nationalist leaders and detainees Rose Chibambo and Vera Chirwa.
As this unavoidably selective summary makes clear, this is a volume with limited theoretical ambitions, but brimming with such honest, pain-staking primary research as must always remain at the heart of our discipline. As a summation of the state of current knowledge on the Nyasaland Emergency, it is difficult to imagine that its findings will be significantly transformed in future. Where the collection does not entirely live up to expectations is in exploring the long-term significance of the State of Emergency for postcolonial Malawi and Central Africa as a whole. Surely the word ‘legacy’ – explicitly mentioned in the title of the book – encompasses much more than the politics of public commemoration (the subject of the book's final chapter, by Bryson Nkhoma), and it is a pity that few of the authors saw fit to take up McCracken's own suggestion and reflect on the continuities and connections between postcolonial governance and the late colonial authoritarianism that manifested itself in the Nyasaland Emergency and other related regional crises.
