While it has become commonplace to decry the supposed demise of the traditional two-parent nuclear family, in fact societies have long had to deal with the absence of parental care for children. As this excellent collection of essays underscores, this was a persistent problem in colonial and antebellum North America. A common approach employed by many local communities in North America prior to 1860 was to bind out children who would not otherwise in the judgment of community authorities receive proper care to masters in exchange for some claim on the children's labor. The specific arrangements could vary across communities. And the core of this volume consists of ten case studies of particular communities based primarily on very careful analysis of indenture agreements. The coverage of the studies ranges chronologically from the seventeenth century to the antebellum era and ranges geographically from Montreal to New Orleans.
The editors have identified three basic binary social relationships in the process of binding out which they employ for grouping the ten studies. Under the master-servant relationship, they place Ruth Herndon's study of eighteenth-century Southern New England indentures, T. Stephen Whitman's analysis of nineteenth-century Baltimore and rural Maryland orphans, and Monique Borque's examination of antebellum Chester County, Pennsylvania community networks. For the parent-child relationship, they feature Adriana van Zwieten's study of seventeenth-century New Netherland, John Murray's analysis of an early nineteenth-century Charleston orphanage, Paul Lachance's paper on literacy in early-nineteenth-century New Orleans, and Timothy Lockley's piece on antebellum Savanannah. Finally, under the family-state relationship, they include Jean Russo and Jean Elliott Russo's study of orphans and illegitimate children in colonial Maryland, Gillian Hamilton's piece on Montreal apprentice's in the early nineteenth century, and Holly Brewer's essay on colonial and Republican policies towards apprenticeship in Virginia. These case studies are bookended by first an initial set of overview essays, one a general introduction by the volume's editors and another comparing English and North American arrangements by Herndon and Steve Hindle and then with a concluding essay by Gloria Main on the demand and supply for child labor in North America. The first part of Main's essay on the pervasiveness of child labor during the colonial and early Republican period provides quite informative historical context for the case studies. The volume is cohesive with editors and individual authors alike citing other chapters.
I sensed some tension among the contributors over the extent to which pauper apprenticeship practices were shaped by labor market conditions versus ideological attitudes. One of the merits of this volume is that the essays map out how much variation there could be in the influence of labor market conditions according to local circumstances. One common finding is that children who were males, whites, and those with some kin connections tended to get better terms in their indentures than their female, black, and kinless counterparts. One could interpret this alternatively as reflecting market valuation, as in Hamilton's examination of apprentices in Montreal or ideological and cultural influences, which feature more prominently in Brewer's study of Virginia. The essays in this volume feature the incentives and attitudes of masters, parents, and families more prominently than those of servants, children, or the state; this probably reflects both the more proactive role of the former and the limitations of existing sources; however, giving more attention to the motives and attitudes of servants, children, and local magistrates does suggest one direction, albeit a challenging one, for future research.
While Bourque finds that in Chester County, Pennsylvania, binding out was as common in 1860 as in 1800, other studies in the volume report a general decline over the antebellum era as localities found orphanages and other methods of providing for pauper child welfare to be more cost effective and humane than binding out. A number of the studies emphasize the role of labor market conditions in influencing the rise and subsequent demise of binding out. The ready emergence of pauper apprenticeship and its general rise during the eighteenth century can be interpreted as Hindle and Herndon note in their essay as reflecting an ample supply of pauper children. However, binding out required a pool of masters willing to make the commitment to supporting indentured children for the duration of the agreement and soft labor market conditions could weaken their interest in doing so. In contrast, Brewer in her study of Virginia emphasizes quite broad ideological factors such as a shift away from patriarchal to more egalitarian republican values as accounting for the ultimate demise of binding out in early-nineteenth-century Virginia.
Thus, careful historians that they are, editors and individual contributors have rightly resisted arriving at simple generalizations regarding central issues in this volume. They have provided numerous insights and firm groundwork for further research on the neglected, but significant topic of how North American communities have treated particularly vulnerable children.
